Rate the Photo Above you

[ItsSimple01]

Untitled by Ethan Gollehon, on Flickr

5/10

Too much headroom and the trees are not in enough to create a sub frame and more if distractions from the mountain itself.

[the pokemon kid]

 

snip

 

7/10
Nice overall colours and contrast. However it looks slightly soft on the focus, but it might just be the size of the image. Also it might just be me, but there is some halo'ing on the planes themselves. If it isnt just me, its because the clarity has been turned up slightly too much...

Here is my shot/ shots. Its 260 images merged.

Tenerife Star Trail by Mathew Teague, on Flickr

[Brennan Price]

Wow, looks completely swish. I am trying to do this with my photos but I've not had the time or the right weather for it. I would say about 8/10 because the colours all go well together but sadly I think the flowers look too bright because of the light you cannot see in the photo.

 

Anyway, Here is mine. Btw, sorry for the poor quality image. It looks much better when it isnt blown up loads.

[reptileexperts]

6/10. May just be the upload Rez but the colors are just too bland and the light is all over the place. I get where you were going with the image for a silhouette and sun flare but honestly the dynamic range on your sensor was not capable of producing this result properly.

Something different for fun. Three of our cats at their dinner bowls. We have this on a 20x30 canvas above our dinner table and it looks great

[LandensnevoK]

Hahaha, I give it a 7/10 just for the cat on the right.  Even though it's not a super fancy picture, it's adorable and that's all that matters.  To counter the cats, here's a picture of my dog named Goose.  

 

[bob345]

Hahaha, I give it a 7/10 just for the cat on the right.  Even though it's not a super fancy picture, it's adorable and that's all that matters.  To counter the cats, here's a picture of my dog named Goose.  

 

 

id say 8/10. Your dog looks so silly  

 

here's a pic i took at a cars and coffee of this heavily modified camaro.

 

camaro racecar by Tauss ., on Flickr

[handymanshandle]

@bob345 I'm not a huge fan of car photography but 9/10

 

I'm still a smartphone camera pleb but now with a Samsung Galaxy S6...

 

[Tedster]

@bob345 I'm not a huge fan of car photography but 9/10

 

I'm still a smartphone camera pleb but now with a Samsung Galaxy S6...

 

 

I really like that! 8.7/10. The background grabs most of my attention and it would be 10 if the buds were slightly crisper and more in focus, and the stem likewise.

 

Here's a photo from my Note 4, untouched.

[Aruxx]

I really like that! 8.7/10. The background grabs most of my attention and it would be 10 if the buds were slightly crisper and more in focus, and the stem likewise.

 

Here's a photo from my Note 4, untouched.

 

-snip-

 

The colors are very drab; this could've been taken at a better time of day and it would look great, but I love how wide the picture seems.  6.5/10

 

LARGE PICTURE:

[bob345]

The colors are very drab; this could've been taken at a better time of day and it would look great, but I love how wide the picture seems.  6.5/10

 

LARGE PICTURE:

I,m going to have to say 6/10. Interesting subject, but the composition just feels off to me. I feel the glare and reflection at that angle take away from the clock.

 

Here's a pic i took this morning at a local cars and coffee (yes, i go to allot of those ).

 

gtrwheel by Tauss ., on Flickr

[Surburb]

I would have to give that a 8/10, the main thing that bothers me is that the center wheel logo is upside down .  Otherwise it has great composition and alignment.

 

[ShiftHitTheFan]

Smartphone here, I'm really limited by the dynamic range.

XXl LARGE PICTURE:

 

The worlds largest smoke stack:

original: http://i1293.photobucket.com/albums/b593/thatwimpykid/P_20151103_163128_SRES_zpsww9vmxkv.jpg~original

 

 

 

A fall walk:

orginal; http://i1293.photobucket.com/albums/b593/thatwimpykid/P_20151017_163937_SRES_zps2iuqsn37.jpg~original

 

 

 

[WinNut]

Smartphone here, I'm really limited by the dynamic range.

XXl LARGE PICTURE:

 

The worlds largest smoke stack:

original: http://i1293.photobucket.com/albums/b593/thatwimpykid/P_20151103_163128_SRES_zpsww9vmxkv.jpg~original

 

-snep-

 

 

A fall walk:

orginal; http://i1293.photobucket.com/albums/b593/thatwimpykid/P_20151017_163937_SRES_zps2iuqsn37.jpg~original

 

-snep-

 

 

8/10, I really like the colors of the first photo and the second photo is also good but the sky is blown out, obviously not your fault since it's a phone camera.

 

-incoming photo-

[WinNut]

for some reason i couldn't edit my post above so:

 

into the mist 1 edit by Nutty LTT, on Flickr

[PillowSmoke]

for some reason i couldn't edit my post above so:

 

into the mist 1 edit by Nutty LTT, on Flickr

 

That picture is really grainy, so much noise. 

[flibberdipper]

7/10 Little grainy, weather sucks, everything is dead. #NewYork

 

Don't get me wrong, it's a great idea, just it suffered execution...

 

...just like my pic. I took this on my shitty ass phone (Samsung Galaxy Avant), so it's grainy AF, not really focused, and yeah. Also snuck this in with like 5 seconds of down time before the teacher came in, so there's that. Wish I had time to bring my SIII in and some lights so I could set it up right lol

 

2015-12-02_04-23-21 by Travis McClelland, on Flickr

[Brennan Price]

6/10. May just be the upload Rez but the colors are just too bland and the light is all over the place. I get where you were going with the image for a silhouette and sun flare but honestly the dynamic range on your sensor was not capable of producing this result properly.

Thanks, its just really annoying because I had a camera able to take photos like this properly but I upgraded and am now stuck with this lol. However I find that I now get clearer results on this one. (I know that it may not look it on the image now but on my pc it looks fine)

[Zambonie]

7/10 Little grainy, weather sucks, everything is dead. #NewYork

 

Don't get me wrong, it's a great idea, just it suffered execution...

 

...just like my pic. I took this on my shitty ass phone (Samsung Galaxy Avant), so it's grainy AF, not really focused, and yeah. Also snuck this in with like 5 seconds of down time before the teacher came in, so there's that. Wish I had time to bring my SIII in and some lights so I could set it up right lol

 

--snip--

 

2015-12-02_04-23-21 by Travis McClelland, on Flickr

 

6/10, im being kind it is grainy and really unfocused but the picture is really nice

 

The one below is just one I took while my friend was playing the piano during third period. It was a failed attempt to record a video actually, because I was using the QCircle camera app on my G4, which I forgot can't record lol. It wasn't meant to be professional at all, hence it being portrait (sorry for not doing it in landscape, portrait is just easier to hold.), I didn't focus it or anything, just took a quick picture in attempt to record. I didn't look at it until today, and It actually didn't turn out to be bad at all, it just looks pleasing though.

 

 

(It flipped the photo from protrait to landscape. Weird. Heres the original link: http://puu.sh/lJHGw/0efdeb5bc5.jpg)

[Worth]

6/10, im being kind it is grainy and really unfocused but the picture is really nice

 

The one below is just one I took while my friend was playing the piano during third period. It was a failed attempt to record a video actually, because I was using the QCircle camera app on my G4, which I forgot can't record lol. It wasn't meant to be professional at all, hence it being portrait (sorry for not doing it in landscape, portrait is just easier to hold.), I didn't focus it or anything, just took a quick picture in attempt to record. I didn't look at it until today, and It actually didn't turn out to be bad at all, it just looks pleasing though.

 

-snip-

 

(It flipped the photo from protrait to landscape. Weird. Heres the original link: http://puu.sh/lJHGw/0efdeb5bc5.jpg)

Honestly it looks better in landscape.

[Guest]

6/10, im being kind it is grainy and really unfocused but the picture is really nice

 

The one below is just one I took while my friend was playing the piano during third period. It was a failed attempt to record a video actually, because I was using the QCircle camera app on my G4, which I forgot can't record lol. It wasn't meant to be professional at all, hence it being portrait (sorry for not doing it in landscape, portrait is just easier to hold.), I didn't focus it or anything, just took a quick picture in attempt to record. I didn't look at it until today, and It actually didn't turn out to be bad at all, it just looks pleasing though.

 

(It flipped the photo from protrait to landscape. Weird. Heres the original link: http://puu.sh/lJHGw/0efdeb5bc5.jpg)

7/10 

 

As has been said, would look way better in landscape imo.

Maybe show more of the person or just don't show the hand!

[Aruxx]

7/10 

 

As has been said, would look way better in landscape imo.

Maybe show more of the person or just don't show the hand!

 

-snip-

 

8/10 - I really like the idea of the shot, but it feels drab.  Bump in some contrast!  That's my 2c on the postprocessing, I liked the actual shot.

 

Large picture warning:

Nikon D3200, 50mm f/1.8 

[bob345]

8/10 - I really like the idea of the shot, but it feels drab.  Bump in some contrast!  That's my 2c on the postprocessing, I liked the actual shot.

 

Large picture warning:

Nikon D3200, 50mm f/1.8 

Im going to have to say 6/10. The main reason is because the focus is off. Had the focus been on the front of the car and the horizon been level it would have ended up much better. When shooting cars, i recommend not shooting wide open especially on a fast lens like yours. Even with auto focus its easy to miss focus with such a shallow depth of field.

 

Here's a pic i got a couple hours ago at a cars and coffee up in San Fransisco of an awesome viper.

 

Viper by Tauss ., on Flickr

[Aruxx]

Im going to have to say 6/10. The main reason is because the focus is off. Had the focus been on the front of the car and the horizon been level it would have ended up much better. When shooting cars, i recommend not shooting wide open especially on a fast lens like yours. Even with auto focus its easy to miss focus with such a shallow depth of field.

 

Here's a pic i got a couple hours ago at a cars and coffee up in San Fransisco of an awesome viper.

 

-snip-

 

Yeah I see where you're coming from.  It was my dad's lens meant for a body with an AF motor in it, so I had to manual focus.  The horizon was more level than it looks.  The actual car was sinking into the dirt on the left side so that's where the lean comes from.

 

I like that picture a lot but I'll leave it for the next person to judge, thanks!

[Guest]

Im going to have to say 6/10. The main reason is because the focus is off. Had the focus been on the front of the car and the horizon been level it would have ended up much better. When shooting cars, i recommend not shooting wide open especially on a fast lens like yours. Even with auto focus its easy to miss focus with such a shallow depth of field.

 

Here's a pic i got a couple hours ago at a cars and coffee up in San Fransisco of an awesome viper.

Damn that's a sharp picture. Awesome car too.

Focus is on point, 9/10

I guess the background could be more interesting, that's all I can think of atm though.

Covent Garden, London (near the Houses of Parliament)

[LiquidGoo]

Really cool pic above me. 9/10. The yellow sign thingy looks really low quality infront.

Edited December 6, 2015 by Godlygamer23