Jump to content

New icons are YouTube’s latest way to alert creators of video demonetization

Recommended Posts

Posted (edited) · Original PosterOP

Source: Ars Technica & YouTube Creator Blog





After the ad-pocolypse earlier this year, YouTube put many new systems in place for advertisers to better control which videos their ads appear over on the platform. The company also clarified what it means to be "advertiser-friendly" on YouTube, as well as what kinds of hate-speech would be ineligible for monetization. However, many creators have expressed frustration with YouTube, its lack of transparency and communication, and the number of videos that were (and continue to be) demonetized after the incident. So now, YouTube is rolling out a system of new icons that should help creators understand which videos are earning them money—and why other videos are not.



YouTube is billing this as a way for creators to glean a "more detailed understanding of whether your video has been identified as not suitable for all advertisers." It's important to note that YouTube has had icons like this to describe video monetization for quite some time. The company is simply updating the system with a few new icons that cater to the needs of creators who are worried about how their "advertiser-friendly" status affects their paychecks. The green and black icons make it clear which videos are totally acceptable in YouTube's eyes and which are not, but the yellow icon is a bit more nebulous.


The new icons are being rolled out to users over the next few weeks, so it's hard to say how a creator will decipher a partially monetized yellow icon from a completely demonetized yellow icon. There could be a message that pops up to indicate the meaning of the yellow icon when hovering over the icon in the Video Manager. For now, YouTube has a troubleshooter tool that explains each icon's meaning, in addition to the meanings of other icons that may pop up while a video is under review if you're sharing revenue from a video with another account.


It sucks that just because a content creator is making videos out of sensational topics would automatically mean demonetization or having less ads. It seems that Google's advertisers wants to turn YouTube back into a safe space or just a website for uploading cat videos. Personally, I'd like to keep an eye on this because there are a lot of content creators who lost up to 90% of their incomes because of the ad-pocalypse brouhaha. 


I really hope Luke and his team can pull off Floatplane as a standalone video platform and be successful.

Edited by hey_yo_
Link to post
Share on other sites

We'd need a lot more big youtubers but I pray every day that they cut ties with youtube, and delete all the videos off youtube and move onto another platform. YT have gotten away with making billions are are not been dicks 

i7-4770 / Z97 / GTX 980 / Corsair 16GB  / H90 / 400C / Antec EDGE / Neutron GTX240 / Intel 240Gb / WD 2TB / BenQ XL24


MSI GE60 2PE i7-4700HQ / 860M / 12GB / WE 1TB / m.Sata 256gb/Elagto USB HD Capture Card

Razer Deathadder Chroma / Razer Blackwidow TE Chroma / Kingston Cloud2's / Sennheiser 429 / Logitech Z333

Link to post
Share on other sites
26 minutes ago, Misanthrope said:

I'm surprised they didn't went with this for the demonetization icon instead

  Hide contents

Image result for troll face


Ironically, this would more accurately depict youtube's stance towards their own creators right now.

Current LTT F@H Rank: 87

Score: 62,532,306

My current rig:

CPU: Delidded :D i7 6700k @ 4.7GHz 1.46v 🔥

Cooler: Noctua NH-D15

Mobo: Asus Z170-A

RAM: 24GB Hyperx Fury Black @ 2900MHz 16-16-16-28



SSD: Samsung 850 evo 120 GB

HDD: WD Caviar Blue 1 TB

Case: Fractal Design Define R5 Black Windowed

Other: White LED strip to illuminate the interior. Extra fractal intake fan for positive pressure.



You may see me defend Apple occasionally. This is not because I am an Apple Fanboy; in fact, I really don't like the direction they are going with their desktops and laptops. in addition, I agree that Apple products are overpriced, some extremely (I'm looking at you Apple pencil and air pods). Also as you can see from my specs, when I finally had the money to buy a computer, I chose a PC, and I have few regrets regarding this decision. However, i still prefer the UI of OSX and iOS (and especially the fact that OSX is based off of Unix), but I can see why others prefer Windows. In other words, I'm not one of the people who go, "ITS A MAC! KILL IT WITH FIRE!!!!!!!", but rather someone who looks more objectively at Apple as a company and is able to see the benefits of their system.



Link to post
Share on other sites

I just make stupid anime and gaming videos for fun but yeah Youtube needs to die

Just your everyday PC and Nintendo gaming nerd and collector

CPU: AMD Ryzen 1800X | GPU:  Gigabyte G1 Gaming GTX 1080 | RAM:  32GB G Skill Flare X DDR4-2400 | PSU: EVGA 1000W GQ 80+Gold | Motherboard: Gigabyte AX370 Gaming 5| Cooler:  Noctua NH-D15 |Case:  NZXT Noctis 450 (White) | Storage: 512GB Samsung SSD + 4TB Western Digital 7200RPM|

Link to post
Share on other sites

I always liked Google's software UI icons :3.

I am the hope of the universe. I am the answer to all living things that cry out for peace. I am protector of the innocent. I am the light in the darkness. I am truth. Ally to good! Nightmare to you!

Link to post
Share on other sites

Youtube isn't exactly in a favourable position either. Sure they are big, but they make absolutely no profit in their operations either (please cite, too lazy to research and prove grapevine). Not to mention that they have a rather convoluted business model to operate in which they have to acquire viewers, content creators AND advertisers, rather than more traditional business models.


Essentially Youtube has to manage a love triangle... We've all sat through enough romcoms to know where that is going.


To me, Youtube is nothing more than a hosting platform, not the media empire it seeks to be.



Your resident osu! player, destroyer of keyboards.

Link to post
Share on other sites

For those that complain about YouTube not having adds on some reason, there is a good reason, the ones that pay for the adds, the companies, don't want their adds on certain videos.

If anyone really believe that YouTube could just ignore what those companies says they don't want adds on, well, you are wrong. But even if they could, that would mean overall add income would be lower for all videos. That hurt would hurt majority of YouTuber's and YouTube, but only benefit those that make content that many companies don't want their adds on.


YouTube Algorithm is far from perfect, and it needs to be improved a lot.

“Remember to look up at the stars and not down at your feet. Try to make sense of what you see and wonder about what makes the universe exist. Be curious. And however difficult life may seem, there is always something you can do and succeed at. 
It matters that you don't just give up.”

-Stephen Hawking

Link to post
Share on other sites

I don't think youtubers care that their stuff is demonitized, but why it was demonitized. The new icons literally show up on videos that shouldn't have it. It doesn't help that you need 1k+ views in a certain time frame to appeal it.


I've already tested a video with safe content, but not so safe tags/words. Instantly demonitized. Also tried with not as safe content, but almost no tags. Took a couple hours to get demonitized. Sure, you can just delete all tags, but that doesn't really help you unless your pewdiepie with millions of loyal followers.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.