Rate the Photo Above you

[rmac52]

@fallendigital

This is a tough one to rate for me.  I don't like watermarks.  And I don't like corporate branding.

That being said.  This is some interesting architecture.  I like the walkway and the building is wicked cool.

Every aspect of the photography portion of this shot are well done.  The only thing I could think off to in prove it would be to get rid of the people.  But unless they paid you to take that shot, that's asking way too much of you.  

So to rate the "Photo" I need to decide if I'm rating your photography or the subject it self. 

And with that I would give this a 9/10.  You did everything right.  I hate watermarks.  But I decided to ignore that to rate this.  I don't think its fair to give this a 1/10 because i hate watermarks.

green rose by r.macrae, on Flickr

I may have rambled a bit in this.  But I'm drunk and I don't care.

If anyone can guess where in the US I'm from, from this post i'll owe you a cookie.

[bob345]

@fallendigital

This is a tough one to rate for me.  I don't like watermarks.  And I don't like corporate branding.

That being said.  This is some interesting architecture.  I like the walkway and the building is wicked cool.

Every aspect of the photography portion of this shot are well done.  The only thing I could think off to in prove it would be to get rid of the people.  But unless they paid you to take that shot, that's asking way too much of you.  

So to rate the "Photo" I need to decide if I'm rating your photography or the subject it self. 

And with that I would give this a 9/10.  You did everything right.  I hate watermarks.  But I decided to ignore that to rate this.  I don't think its fair to give this a 1/10 because i hate watermarks.

green rose by r.macrae, on Flickr

I may have rambled a bit in this.  But I'm drunk and I don't care.

If anyone can guess where in the US I'm from, from this post i'll owe you a cookie.

looks good, id say 8/10. I would prefer it without the negative colors though. Here is a pic i took today. Starting to mess around with macro shots.

 

[Simon_Schmidt]

9/10 ! I love macro shots

 

[ZacDaMan72]

9/10. Background is a bit cluttered IMO, but everything else is miiiint.

 

Auckland, Waiheke, Rangitoto visit 2015 by Zachary Ong, on Flickr

[Redut]

9/10

Rate JonTron pls

[StormtrooperStu]

Nice but a little more depth of field would have been better so the whole flower was in focus. 7/10

 

My shot was taken at my golf club, it is the view from the clubhouse. 

 

[virusal19]

Nice but a little more depth of field would have been better so the whole flower was in focus. 7/10

 

My shot was taken at my golf club, it is the view from the clubhouse. 

 

 

 

10/10. I love it, it's a great photo. Everything just appeals to me; the sun rays, the reflection of the sky on the water, it's captured well.

 

Here's something that's a bit more boring; a light bulb. 

 

Light bulb by Virusal19, on Flickr

[StormtrooperStu]

Here's something that's a bit more boring; a light bulb. 

 

I love the lightbulb, 9/10 I just wish it was clean.

 

I broke mine.

[virusal19]

Here's something that's a bit more boring; a light bulb. 

 

I love the lightbulb, 9/10 I just wish it was clean.

 

I broke mine.

 

Not much to fault here, probably just need to slightly adjust the framing. Other than that, it's a great photo! 9.5/10

 

Trying to experiment with some reflections.

 

Periodic Table by Virusal19, on Flickr

[Silvercall]

Not much to fault here, probably just need to slightly adjust the framing. Other than that, it's a great photo! 9.5/10

 

Trying to experiment with some reflections.

 

Periodic Table by Virusal19, on Flickr

 

I really like the concept, but I'd like to see what else you shoot using this idea.  The reflected "r's look cool but I'd like to see more. 8/10.  My photo is of a new soft release I recently acquired... 

 

1.

[upliftsleet1974]

I really like the concept, but I'd like to see what else you shoot using this idea.  The reflected "r's look cool but I'd like to see more. 8/10.  My photo is of a new soft release I recently acquired... 

 

1.

 

I am a fan of the focus and color gah its good....But I hate the framing I would really like the boxes all the way in...Still a great photo 8.5/10

 

 

IMG_4386 by Downpour Photography, on Flickr

[MattP123]

9/10 I really like the background and its a sharp picture. 

 

I took this on my phone through a window, so it might look a little potato. 

 

[StormtrooperStu]

 

 

I took this on my phone through a window, so it might look a little potato. 

 

 

 

Spud. At least it's straight. 5.547/10

 

I thought I would moon you. 

 

[fritzgoesrawr]

Spud. At least it's straight. 5.547/10

 

I thought I would moon you. 

 

 

Very clean shot, deep black and nice focusing on the moon  9/10

 

Here's mine. I'm using Finepix s4200 and I'm new to photography scene

 

[Simon_Schmidt]

8/10

A little bit too dark at the left side imo

 

[Blade of Grass]

7/10

Photo seems out of focus to me

EDIT: Back story, someone's house caught on fire.

[.spider.]

img=https://bladeofgrass.net/images/w650/ltt/house-fire.jpg

That's superb 10/10

Another one from Circus Flic Flac

[StormtrooperStu]

Another one from Circus Flic Flac

 

Really great shot, what camera are you using and what are the details. 9/10

 

This is my new dog.

 

[Blade of Grass]

@StormtrooperStu Aw, cute dog! 8.5/10

 

Another "action" shot of the fire.

[wolfgang]

@StormtrooperStu Aw, cute dog! 8.5/10

 

Another "action" shot of the fire.

5/10 I Feel like most of the shot is too dark so you dont get much detail from anything aside from the one area of the truck that is lit.

 

 

[.spider.]

Really great shot, what camera are you using and what are the details.

450D and EF50mm 1.8 II

What do you mean by details?

[wolfgang]

450D and EF50mm 1.8 II

What do you mean by details?

I am guessing he means what settings you had set like ISO and apeture.

[.spider.]

I am guessing he means what settings you had set like ISO and apeture.

Nothing special 1/320s f2.8 ISO1600

[Flight1sim]

5/10 I Feel like most of the shot is too dark so you dont get much detail from anything aside from the one area of the truck that is lit.

 

 

 

9/10, i don't really see anything wrong with it, but maybe it's the little bit of reflection of light on the headphones (center part?) that put me off 1 point ;D

What camera and lens? (settings)

Messing around with the 50mm 1.8 with some macro shots with the lens removed. I don't expect most people to like it, i thought it looked kinda artistic tho, just my opinion

No Post editing

Also, this is a very low resolution because i was doing an experiment earlier with some 5FPS burst etc, had it set to S image quality and forgot to change it! Whoops...

Again, this was just a shot i took for fun in like 2 minutes

[CriticalTrees]

Blurry, that's understandable because you were testing stuffs. 6/10.

 

 

Used a iPhone 4s, I was bored.