Which PSU is the most suitable for this Rig? (x58 build)

[Akila_KuKu]

I had a choice to build the 1st generation system unit in 2019. So I bought,

 

• Processor - Xeon X5675.
• Motherboard - X58 ( Asus P6T6 WS Revolution).
• Ram - DDR3 24Gb (4Gb x 6).
• GPU - Gigabyte RX580 8Gb.
• HDD - 1 x SSD + 2 x 7200rpm HDD.
• SATA 3 PCIe card.
• USB 3.0 PCIe card.
• CPU Cooler - Hyper 212X
• Casing - Cooler Master Masterbox MB511 ( 4x120mm fans) 
• Power supply - 600W normal PSU

 

So this PSU doesn't enough for this rig... Please help me to decide to buy the most suitable PSU for this rig among the following 3 brands. 

"Corsair, Seasonic, Cooler Master "

What do you guys recommend for this?

[Jurrunio]

PSU's enough in wattage though maybe not in quality. You're limited by CPU cooler though

[Akila_KuKu]

3 minutes ago, Jurrunio said:

PSU's enough in wattage though maybe not in quality. You're limited by CPU cooler though

Yes, enough in wattage, but this PSU doesn't. This one is a low-quality PSU.

[Jurrunio]

1 minute ago, Akila_KuKu said:

Yes, enough in wattage, but this PSU doesn't. This one is a low-quality PSU.

might want tier A or higher and skip B.

[Akila_KuKu]

16 minutes ago, Jurrunio said:

might want tier A or higher and skip B.

Perfect.   So 650W or 750W? Which wattage will be most suitable? What's your point?

[Oalei]

20 minutes ago, Akila_KuKu said:

Perfect.   So 650W or 750W? Which wattage will be most suitable? What's your point?

500-600W is enough, IMO

[Spotty]

17 minutes ago, Akila_KuKu said:

Perfect.   So 650W or 750W? Which wattage will be most suitable? What's your point?

That's not a dual socket motherboard and you only have a single RX580. No need for 650/750W.

[Jurrunio]

15 minutes ago, Akila_KuKu said:

Perfect.   So 650W or 750W? Which wattage will be most suitable? What's your point?

550w will do, though I'm not against a higher wattage one if prices are good

[Akila_KuKu]

Just now, Jurrunio said:

550w will do, though I'm not against a higher wattage one if prices are good

 

6 minutes ago, Oalei said:

500-600W is enough, IMO

 

5 minutes ago, Spotty said:

That's not a dual socket motherboard and you only have a single RX580. No need for 650/750W.

OK then 

Thanks friends, all of you... 

[Akila_KuKu]

Guys, which model will most suitable with this rig among the following PSUs????

 

• Seasonic-SSR-750FM-Semi-Modular - $130.88
• Seasonic-SSR-650FX-Modular - $130.88
• Seasonic-SSR-650FM-Semi-Modular - $119.69
• Corsair CX Series 650 Watt - $96.89
• CORSAIR-TX650M - $108.29
• CORSAIR-TX750M - $128.23
• MasterWatt 750 Watt - $97.74

(The price quoted above is in my country)

 

What do you guys think????????????

[Oalei]

59 minutes ago, Akila_KuKu said:

Guys, which model will most suitable with this rig among the following PSUs????

 

• Seasonic-SSR-750FM-Semi-Modular - $130.88
• Seasonic-SSR-650FX-Modular - $130.88
• Seasonic-SSR-650FM-Semi-Modular - $119.69
• Corsair CX Series 650 Watt - $96.89
• CORSAIR-TX650M - $108.29
• CORSAIR-TX750M - $128.23
• MasterWatt 750 Watt - $97.74

(The price quoted above is in my country)

 

What do you guys think????????????

i would personally go for CX/TXM 650W, but focus gold+ is good too

[Princess Luna]

1 hour ago, Akila_KuKu said:

CORSAIR-TX650M - $108.29

I'd go with this one, seems to me the best price ratio.

[Spotty]

1 hour ago, Akila_KuKu said:

Guys, which model will most suitable with this rig among the following PSUs????

I'm really confused why you asked if 650-750W was needed for your system and had all 3 people who answered tell you that 650-750w isn't necessary... Then follow it up by asking which 650-750W unit to buy?

What's the prices of the 450-550W variants of those models?

[Akila_KuKu]

[Akila_KuKu]

2 hours ago, Spotty said:

I'm really confused why you asked if 650-750W was needed for your system and had all 3 people who answered tell you that 650-750w isn't necessary... Then follow it up by asking which 650-750W unit to buy?

Future proof heheehe. Not really because all PSU calculators recommend more than 650W. That's why I looked at those PSUs... 

 

Currently, my PSU is Oasis 600os dual v2.3 (600W)  It doesn't enough, PC suddenly restart when Unigine GPU benchmark. So I doubt if 600W will be sufficient. 

 

 

[Akila_KuKu]

2 hours ago, Spotty said:

What's the prices of the 450-550W variants of those models?

CORSAIR VS550 550W - $59.85
COOLER MASTER MWE 550 - $57.00
CORSAIR TX550M 550W - $105.45
CORSAIR VS550 550W - $58.43

[Spotty]

23 minutes ago, Akila_KuKu said:

CORSAIR VS550 550W - $59.85
COOLER MASTER MWE 550 - $57.00
CORSAIR TX550M 550W - $105.45
CORSAIR VS550 550W - $58.43

Skip the VS and MWE (Bronze) units.
The TX550M pricing sucks [compared to the TX650M].

Are the 450/550 Corsair CX/CXm units available? They should be a bit cheaper.
What country are you buying in? What's the website that you are searching?

[Jurrunio]

11 minutes ago, Akila_KuKu said:

all PSU calculators recommend more than 650W

and they always overestimate. I dont know how much power the CPU can draw when overclocked, but I'm certain you're not cooling 250w of power draw from that little surface area without cooking the CPU or going custom cooling. RX 580 can do 250w when you're pushing it but again, without modding the cooling you're not going more than that.

 

29 minutes ago, Akila_KuKu said:

Currently, my PSU is Oasis 600os dual v2.3 (600W)  It doesn't enough, PC suddenly restart when Unigine GPU benchmark. So I doubt if 600W will be sufficient. 

something like that might not able to do its ratings in the first place

[Akila_KuKu]

1 hour ago, Spotty said:

Skip the VS and MWE (Bronze) units.
The TX550M pricing sucks [compared to the TX650M].

Are the 450/550 Corsair CX/CXm units available? They should be a bit cheaper.
What country are you buying in? What's the website that you are searching?

I'm in Sri Lanka, these prices are retail prices in our ordinary shops.

 

http://www.nanotek.lk/category/power-supply

http://gamesstreet.lk/products.php?cat=Mg==&scat=NQ== 

etc.

 

Most items are not available at the moment.

[Akila_KuKu]

2 hours ago, Jurrunio said:

and they always overestimate. I dont know how much power the CPU can draw when overclocked, but I'm certain you're not cooling 250w of power draw from that little surface area without cooking the CPU or going custom cooling. RX 580 can do 250w when you're pushing it but again, without modding the cooling you're not going more than that.

 

something like that might not able to do its ratings in the first place

 I admit what you say. 

[Spotty]

9 minutes ago, Akila_KuKu said:

I'm in Sri Lanka, these prices are retail prices in our ordinary shops.

 

http://www.nanotek.lk/category/power-supply

http://gamesstreet.lk/products.php?cat=Mg==&scat=NQ== 

etc.

 

Most items are not available at the moment.

Ah, I see the problem. Most the decent PSUs available start at 650/750 Watts and that's why you're looking at those. That's a little unfortunate for you as it's not really necessary for your system, and if the 450/550w models were available they should have been a little cheaper, so you end up forced to spend more than you really should have to.

Most of the stuff listed on those sites are out of stock as well which doesn't help.

 

5 hours ago, Akila_KuKu said:

• Corsair CX Series 650 Watt - $96.89 
• CORSAIR-TX650M - $108.29 

Either of those would be the ones I would go with... Though the CX650 is currently listed as Out of Stock on those websites.
There's also the TX550M listed ( http://www.nanotek.lk/product/609), but it's only 500 Sri Lanken Rupees (~$2 USD) cheaper than the TX650M and the TX550M is also listed as Out of Stock.

If your budget is really tight, then the VS450 (grey label) would also work. As I mentioned earlier, I wouldn't normally recommend it, but it is USD $50 cheaper than the Corsair CX models so if you can't afford the CX/TXM then the VS450 (GREY LABEL) would be the best of the cheaper units listed on those sites. (Best under 10,000 Rupees).
http://gamesstreet.lk/product_view.php?pid=MzYy

[Akila_KuKu]

8 hours ago, Spotty said:

If your budget is really tight, then the VS450 (grey label) would also work. As I mentioned earlier, I wouldn't normally recommend it, but it is USD $50 cheaper than the Corsair CX models so if you can't afford the CX/TXM then the VS450 (GREY LABEL) would be the best of the cheaper units listed on those sites. (Best under 10,000 Rupees).

Will that be enough with this rig?  According to the PSU calculators, minimum PSU load wattage is around 500W.  That's why I can not make a final decision.  

 

8 hours ago, Spotty said:

the TX650M and the TX550M is also listed as Out of Stock

So I can ask for the items which are currently out of stock.

[Vejnemojnen]

5 hours ago, Akila_KuKu said:

Will that be enough with this rig?  According to the PSU calculators, minimum PSU load wattage is around 500W.  That's why I can not make a final decision.  

 

according to the most popular (in my country..) PSU calculator, your whole rig (95W TDP CPU, RX580 card, 6 ram moduls, 3 SATA devices, 4 case fans& others) consumes up to 365w under heavy, theoretical loads (stress tests, benchmarking, etc).

 

Therefore, 450-500w should suffice nicely. No need to opt for more wattage. Quality over wattage!

[Akila_KuKu]

15 minutes ago, Vejnemojnen said:

according to the most popular (in my country..) PSU calculator, your whole rig (95W TDP CPU, RX580 card, 6 ram moduls, 3 SATA devices, 4 case fans& others) consumes up to 365w under heavy, theoretical loads (stress tests, benchmarking, etc).

 

Therefore, 450-500w should suffice nicely. No need to opt for more wattage. Quality over wattage!

If it is true, there is no problem. Thank you for informing about that.