Modded MC: getting extremely low framerate on decent PC

[computer1up]

Yikes! Another thread on the low-fps train with Minecraft. 

 

So yeah, using modpacks of the game, whatever version I'm running, whichever version of Java I've got installed, no matter which driver versions I've got, my performance in modpacks is poor (unplayable poor, 3fps average). I know my pc can handle it, it USED to run them fine. 

 

Currently troubleshooting Schematica V4 by Recallgaming. It's got Optifine Ultra D6 installed by default, even updating that to D8 manually didn't help anything. Hell, I'm typing this from a fresh Windows 10 install I just did, and nothing has changed. I'm seeing all the comments on other threads and the usual answers say "Allocate more RAM", "Set affinity and priority", "update Java", "Get optifine", and so the list goes on. But no, all of that had no avail. 

 

It seems like the problem lies deeper, maybe somewhere with later forge versions. 

 

Fun fact: my rMBP 15" from 2015 with only Iris Pro runs the pack flawlessly at 60FPS, so that's a bit weird eh?

 

Specs: 

i5 2400

12GB DDR3

RX470 8GB by MSI (yep, the Gaming X card, god I love that card)

[Clanscorpia]

I had the exact same issue. Im pretty sure it has something to do with the Polaris arch because I had shaders on low running at 30FPS on my OCed RX 480 which could run maxed out Arma 3 60fps. I feel like we should just wait until the mods/game get proper Polaris support

[computer1up]

Yeah, but that should at least give me 24fps or more, but it runs at just 3fps now...

[DarkBlade2117]

What packs?

[computer1up]

I did mention I'm running Schematic V4 now. Used to run YogsCastComplete pack a while back, which ran at least playable on my GTX560TI and older java version... 

 

Schematic V4 is available from the Technic Launcher.

Edited July 23, 2017 by computer1up

[LienusLateTips]

Minecraft is very CPU demanding.

[CyberFern0]

30 minutes ago, computer1up said:

Yikes! Another thread on the low-fps train with Minecraft. 

 

So yeah, using modpacks of the game, whatever version I'm running, whichever version of Java I've got installed, no matter which driver versions I've got, my performance in modpacks is poor (unplayable poor, 3fps average). I know my pc can handle it, it USED to run them fine. 

 

Currently troubleshooting Schematica V4 by Recallgaming. It's got Optifine Ultra D6 installed by default, even updating that to D8 manually didn't help anything. Hell, I'm typing this from a fresh Windows 10 install I just did, and nothing has changed. I'm seeing all the comments on other threads and the usual answers say "Allocate more RAM", "Set affinity and priority", "update Java", "Get optifine", and so the list goes on. But no, all of that had no avail. 

 

It seems like the problem lies deeper, maybe somewhere with later forge versions. 

 

Fun fact: my rMBP 15" from 2015 with only Iris Pro runs the pack flawlessly at 60FPS, so that's a bit weird eh?

 

Specs: 

i5 2400

12GB DDR3

RX470 8GB by MSI (yep, the Gaming X card, god I love that card)

dude you like minecraft? I LOVE minecraft. I have a gtx 1080 fe so i run the game on like 600fps 4k. I play Hypixel all the time, and the only mod i have is optifine.

[computer1up]

1 hour ago, CyberFern0 said:

dude you like minecraft? I LOVE minecraft. I have a gtx 1080 fe so i run the game on like 600fps 4k. I play Hypixel all the time, and the only mod i have is optifine.

So what exactly does this post contribute to solving the problem?

[computer1up]

1 hour ago, JDE said:

Minecraft is very CPU demanding.

I know that, but it doesn't seem like it maxes out my 2400 though. Besides, AFAIK minecraft relies less on threads and more on clocks, in which case my 2400 shouldn't be that far behind the 4770HQ mobile CPU in my MBP...

[CyberFern0]

Just now, computer1up said:

So what exactly does this post contribute to solving the problem?

meh

 

maB it's just a java problem I had like 30fps on a laptop i used to have but since you have lots of modpacks it dropped fps. Check to make sure you have the latest java.

[computer1up]

1 hour ago, CyberFern0 said:

meh

 

maB it's just a java problem I had like 30fps on a laptop i used to have but since you have lots of modpacks it dropped fps. Check to make sure you have the latest java.

Sorry dude but did you read the entire first post? I thought I mentioned I'm running the latest version...

[CyberFern0]

5 minutes ago, JDE said:

Minecraft is very CPU demanding.

Oh it is, thx man i have a water cooled i7 6700k so if i waterclock it i should be getting high frames thanks.

[CyberFern0]

Just now, computer1up said:

Sorry dude but did you read the entire first post? I thought I mentioned I'm running the latest version...

check again

[computer1up]

1 hour ago, CyberFern0 said:

check again

I did, and I saw this: 

Quote

I'm seeing all the comments on other threads and the usual answers say "Allocate more RAM", "Set affinity and priority", "update Java", "Get optifine", and so the list goes on. But no, all of that had no avail. 

 

 

[CyberFern0]

Just now, computer1up said:

I did, and I saw this: 

 

ok...

[computer1up]

 

1 hour ago, CyberFern0 said:

ok...

Please, if you're going to comment on this thread, at least let it be somewhat useful in solving the problem. 

 

Quick edit: that wasn't to offend you, but just to keep the thread clean

Edited July 23, 2017 by computer1up

[LienusLateTips]

32 minutes ago, computer1up said:

I know that, but it doesn't seem like it maxes out my 2400 though. Besides, AFAIK minecraft relies less on threads and more on clocks, in which case my 2400 shouldn't be that far behind the 4770HQ mobile CPU in my MBP...

It's also very dependent on IPC. Is your RAM and GPU maxed out?

[computer1up]

1 hour ago, JDE said:

It's also very dependent on IPC. Is your RAM and GPU maxed out?

Both aren't maxed out as far as Taskmanager can tell me

[LienusLateTips]

1 minute ago, computer1up said:

Both aren't maxed out as far as Taskmanager can tell me

Try reinstalling Minecraft, or even Windows.

[computer1up]

1 hour ago, JDE said:

Try reinstalling Minecraft, or even Windows.

Hehe, I'm currently typing from a fresh Windows install that I just installed this evening (which was a pain to do because of other system troubles and installation media fails)

[LienusLateTips]

1 minute ago, computer1up said:

Hehe, I'm currently typing from a fresh Windows install that I just installed this evening (which was a pain to do because of other system troubles and installation media fails)

What Minecraft version is this?

[computer1up]

1 hour ago, JDE said:

What Minecraft version is this?

1.7.10, vanilla runs fine on this version but modpacks seem to give me problems every time. 

 

I ran both 1.6.4 modpacks and 1.10.2 modpacks wich were still very playable (the 1.10.2 modpacks even ran good enough with SEUS shaders!)

[LienusLateTips]

Just now, computer1up said:

1.7.10, vanilla runs fine on this version but modpacks seem to give me problems every time. 

Try using Java 7.

http://www.oracle.com/technetwork/java/javase/downloads/java-archive-downloads-javase7-521261.html

Use the Java Runtime Enviroment 7.

[computer1up]

1 hour ago, JDE said:

Try using Java 7.

http://www.oracle.com/technetwork/java/javase/downloads/java-archive-downloads-javase7-521261.html

Use the Java Runtime Enviroment 7.

Ok, will try. 

 

By the way, that link is probably not very useful since it requires you to sign up, and they want business information for that.

[LienusLateTips]

Just now, computer1up said:

Ok, will try

BTW uninstall Java 8.