Criticisms and Improvements

[PHInfinite]

Hey Guys,

 

I have decided to make a youtube channel and I just wanted some feedback from you guys regarding my logo.

 

Please don't tell me it's copied because it's not.

Edited December 5, 2015 by Godlygamer23
YouTube link removed.

[LiamApex]

looks nice, might wanna remove the link since advertising is against coc but i dont really think your advertising but some people can be really picking

[SolarNova]

Is the colour inside the 'eye' of the P R and O meant to be a different shade of grey ?

[Rorgash]

at that size i can see the compression.

[Rorgash]

Is the colour inside the 'eye' of the P R and O meant to be a different shade of grey ?

that my friend i would bet being an optical illusion. 

[ALwin]

So are we supposed to look at just your logo?  Come back when you have some actual content.

[LiamApex]

So are we supposed to look at just your logo?  Come back when you have some actual content.

thats generally how you give someone criticism, gee i bet you can count aswell

[Nexxus]

So are we supposed to look at just your logo?  Come back when you have some actual content.

Logos are super important though.

[SolarNova]

Rorgash, on 05 Dec 2015 - 4:14 PM, said:Rorgash, on 05 Dec 2015 - 4:14 PM, said:Rorgash, on 05 Dec 2015 - 4:14 PM, said:

that my friend i would bet being an optical illusion. 

 

No, I wouldn't be surprised if som1 missed it specially if they designed it on a LCD display.

I run a Plasma so its easy to see differences in colour that would be missed on a LCD.

 

Zoom in and it removes optical illusions.

 

I guess it 'could' be my end, my plasma is getting old, though i would expect to see it within the C also if that's the case. but I would check it on what ever program u used to make, check the color codes.

[PHInfinite]

Sorry your correct guys, but thanks for the feedback. I will start uploading after Christmas but I need to sort out the entire channel first.

 

Thanks

[ALwin]

thats generally how you give someone criticism, gee i bet you can count aswell

 

Logos are super important though.

 

Criticism for what?  A logo is just a cover, the content is more important.

[Rorgash]

No, I wouldn't be surprised if som1 missed it specially if they designed it on a LCD display.

I run a Plasma so its easy to see differences in colour that would be missed on a LCD.

 

Zoom in and it removes optical illusions.

i just did that and since i did a color vision test not long ago and i know its atleast 98% accurate, and i know my monitor is very well set as it is(not perfect ofcourse) but zooming in and it turns into the same grey for me, lots of pixilation tho from the compression.

[ALwin]

This is like an author asking for opinions on what we think about a title he came up for a book, without any of the actual words that are going to be inside the book.

 

Author:  "Guys, what do you think about this, 'Lamest Book Ever'? It's what I am going to call the book I haven't written yet."

[Philosobyte]

@SolarNova @Rorgash

The background

 

The center of the P

 

The center of the R

 

The center of the O

 

Although the interiors are indeed lighter than the background, also note that there is a lighter gray/red-tinted ring where the red from the letter meets the grey of the interior due to compression. In my opinion, this contributes to a slight optical illusion: this ring of lighter gray helps leave an impression that the entire interior is lighter. 

 

I think the logo looks great. The colors are earthy, and the text is attractive for its universal/businesslike/professional font. However, you might have to end up trimming the background, and I think you should reduce the spacing between the words by just a tad.

 

EDIT: Corrected the images. I originally accidentally used the same image for all of them.

Edited December 5, 2015 by Raymondbl