Heaven Society - Week 44 (Bakuman)

[Maheshvara]

How many of you actually watched it? I just finished bakuman. I have to say,

it went above and beyond my expectations. The story is alot more well done 

than what i expected, it just kept getting better and better, it grew on me up

until the end. 

 

Sure, some characters were overwhelmingly bland. Well, i'd rather say they

were oversimplified to induce a specific reaction, the target audience is

probably fairly young. But overall it was unexpectedly nuanced and well done.

The ending didn't feel satisfying, but might partially be because i could have

watched another season or two. Niizuma Eiji is one of my favorite characters

so far. But i have to say, i hated what they did with Toru Nanamine. Again with

the oversimplification to portray him as a villain. 

I haven't watched it, but i read the manga, and hence i know the complete story

 

Yeah, Tooru Nanamine was an awesome character (if he's the guy that made a corporation of making manga's). His ending was too abrupt... Oh well, great manga nontheless Although i still want for Eiji and that +Natural author to end up together

 

 

 

nope I have not even started it yet so it is just joining my long list of things I need to watch for the club

list of poll winners i still need to watch

1. Steins;Gate
2. Wolfs Rain
3. Black Rock Shooter
4. No Game No Life
5. The Garden of Sinners
6. Time of Eve
7. Watamote
8. My Teen Romantic Comedy SNAFU
9. Clannad
10. Higurashi no Naku Koro ni
11. aldnoah zero
12. fate/zero
13. Knights of Sidonia
14. The Devil is a Part-Timer!
15. Date A Live
16. maoyuu maou yuusha
17. humanity has declined
18. Jormungand
19. White Album 2
20. Mushi-shi
21. UN-Go
22. The Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya
23. Love, Election and Chocolate
24. Jyu-Oh-Sei
25. Death Parade
26. Bakuman

 

A superb list, many of which i haven't watched, but i heard about. I just don't have the time to watch all the anime's... I still need to catch up with Arc-V

[tobben]

I haven't watched it, but i read the manga, and hence i know the complete story

 

Yeah, Tooru Nanamine was an awesome character (if he's the guy that made a corporation of making manga's). His ending was too abrupt... Oh well, great manga nontheless Although i still want for Eiji and that +Natural author to end up together

Taking this from a anime perspective, i don't think that part about the corporation was mentioned.

But seeing his approach that might very well have happened. As for Aiko, aka +Natural author. 

Seeing as she is pretty much portrayed as a empty shell and childish, whimsical brat i wouldn't

want her ending up with anyone. Particularly Eiji. I get the impression the anime might have gone

overboard, and ended up falling short of the manga in a few aspects. But then again, manga is

more open to interpretation. 

[TheProfosist]

nope I have not even started it yet so it is just joining my long list of things I need to watch for the club

list of poll winners i still need to watch

• Steins;Gate
• Wolfs Rain
• Black Rock Shooter
• No Game No Life
• The Garden of Sinners
• Time of Eve
• Watamote
• My Teen Romantic Comedy SNAFU
• Clannad
• Higurashi no Naku Koro ni
• aldnoah zero
• fate/zero
• Knights of Sidonia
• The Devil is a Part-Timer!
• Date A Live
• maoyuu maou yuusha
• humanity has declined
• Jormungand
• White Album 2
• Mushi-shi
• UN-Go
• The Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya
• Love, Election and Chocolate
• Jyu-Oh-Sei
• Death Parade
• Bakuman

want me to cut down that list for you?