laptop Which pc to chose

[PRIYANSH geek]

Hey

Can anyone help me in choosing between two laptops one is adus TUF Fx505 Dy and the other is Acer nitro 5 an515-52

I need a laptop to do gaming for 2 hours , some productivity like Photoshop, premiere, aftereffects and watching movies

Please compare between two according to points

 

1. Durability

2. Battery 

3. Cooling system 

4. Gaming  Performance

5. Productivity performance 

 

At last please suggest which laptop is best do that I can get value for money 

 

 

[Devin92]

I have neither experience with them but go check out notebookcheck. their review is pretty fair and comprehensive.

[Dedayog]

6 minutes ago, PRIYANSH geek said:

Hey

Can anyone help me in choosing between two laptops one is adus TUF Fx505 Dy and the other is Acer nitro 5 an515-52

I need a laptop to do gaming for 2 hours , some productivity like Photoshop, premiere, aftereffects and watching movies

Please compare between two according to points

 

1. Durability

2. Battery 

3. Cooling system 

4. Gaming  Performance

5. Productivity performance 

 

At last please suggest which laptop is best do that I can get value for money 

 

 

Yes, let me get right on writing you a comprehensive review
 

One sec, going to use the bathroom real fast.  Why don't you google them and read reviews when I do so?

[Wh0_Am_1]

22 minutes ago, PRIYANSH geek said:

Hey

Can anyone help me in choosing between two laptops one is adus TUF Fx505 Dy and the other is Acer nitro 5 an515-52

I need a laptop to do gaming for 2 hours , some productivity like Photoshop, premiere, aftereffects and watching movies

Please compare between two according to points

 

1. Durability

2. Battery 

3. Cooling system 

4. Gaming  Performance

5. Productivity performance 

 

At last please suggest which laptop is best do that I can get value for money 

 

 

For durability I would trust the ASUS TUF, as it meets or exceeds the MIL-STD-810G tests, for battery, I am not sure that any laptop in this segment could withstand two hours of use under load, these components just simply draw too much power, I would give you an hour and half maybe just maybe 2 hours. Cooling, I wouldn't know. Performance, alright here we need budget/ and or the models you are looking at as these laptop chassis are available in multiple different configs. Value, usually fall to the Acer Nitro 5 but not always, once again, I need to know what your budget is and or what kinds of configs you are looking at.

[Wh0_Am_1]

31 minutes ago, PRIYANSH geek said:

Hey

Can anyone help me in choosing between two laptops one is adus TUF Fx505 Dy and the other is Acer nitro 5 an515-52

I need a laptop to do gaming for 2 hours , some productivity like Photoshop, premiere, aftereffects and watching movies

Please compare between two according to points

 

1. Durability

2. Battery 

3. Cooling system 

4. Gaming  Performance

5. Productivity performance 

 

At last please suggest which laptop is best do that I can get value for money 

 

 

Let me put it this way if you are looking to spend about a $1000 USD on a laptop, get this, if you are looking to spend about $700 get this.

[PRIYANSH geek]

6 hours ago, Wh0_Am_1 said:

Let me put it this way if you are looking to spend about a $1000 USD on a laptop, get this, if you are looking to spend about $700 get this.

Thanks 

 

[PRIYANSH geek]

7 hours ago, Wh0_Am_1 said:

For durability I would trust the ASUS TUF, as it meets or exceeds the MIL-STD-810G tests, for battery, I am not sure that any laptop in this segment could withstand two hours of use under load, these components just simply draw too much power, I would give you an hour and half maybe just maybe 2 hours. Cooling, I wouldn't know. Performance, alright here we need budget/ and or the models you are looking at as these laptop chassis are available in multiple different configs. Value, usually fall to the Acer Nitro 5 but not always, once again, I need to know what your budget is and or what kinds of configs you are looking at.

650-800 $

But the thing is that price differs in India 

Usually it is more than in us

 

Actually in INR it must be about 55000

[PRIYANSH geek]

6 hours ago, Wh0_Am_1 said:

For durability I would trust the ASUS TUF, as it meets or exceeds the MIL-STD-810G tests, for battery, I am not sure that any laptop in this segment could withstand two hours of use under load, these components just simply draw too much power, I would give you an hour and half maybe just maybe 2 hours. Cooling, I wouldn't know. Performance, alright here we need budget/ and or the models you are looking at as these laptop chassis are available in multiple different configs. Value, usually fall to the Acer Nitro 5 but not always, once again, I need to know what your budget is and or what kinds of configs you are looking at.

 

4 minutes ago, PRIYANSH geek said:

500-600 $

But the thing is that price differs in India 

Usually it is more than in us

So my range drops 

 

[PRIYANSH geek]

8 minutes ago, PRIYANSH geek said:

Thanks 

But they don't fit my budget they will cost out of the range in India 

 

 

[PRIYANSH geek]

9 minutes ago, PRIYANSH geek said:

650-800 $

But the thing is that price differs in India 

So, in INR appx 45000-55000

Usually it is more than in us

 

[Wh0_Am_1]

This is a little out of budget, but if you can afford it get it. Though once again 2 hours on battery is a stretch for any laptop of this weight class, and esp this value. Also down the line I would recommend purchasing 8GB more of RAM for it and an SSD, as SSDs in laptops are more reliable, as they are significantly more drop resistant that HDDs, faster, and they are not susceptible to damage from movement during use, ( as in HDDs lose notable amounts of their life span if you do not wait 30 seconds for them to spin down before moving them, but do not fret, this damage will not appear for several years and SSDs are very cheap, just don't store overly sensitive data on your HDD. 

[PRIYANSH geek]

2 hours ago, Wh0_Am_1 said:

This is a little out of budget, but if you can afford it get it. Though once again 2 hours on battery is a stretch for any laptop of this weight class, and esp this value. Also down the line I would recommend purchasing 8GB more of RAM for it and an SSD, as SSDs in laptops are more reliable, as they are significantly more drop resistant that HDDs, faster, and they are not susceptible to damage from movement during use, ( as in HDDs lose notable amounts of their life span if you do not wait 30 seconds for them to spin down before moving them, but do not fret, this damage will not appear for several years and SSDs are very cheap, just don't store overly sensitive data on your HDD. 

I think its processor would be a bottle neck for its gpu as a turbo boost of 3.4GHzwould not handle heavy gaming for a hour 

 

[Wh0_Am_1]

8 minutes ago, PRIYANSH geek said:

I think its processor would be a bottle neck for its gpu as a turbo boost of 3.4GHzwould not handle heavy gaming for a hour 

 

Not in the slightest, the 8250u is plenty capable of keeping up with the GTX1050 I know as I have a Core i5 2500 (a 2011 desktop CPU that is ~%1 faster than the 8250u) and in most modern games, I could even strap an 1650 to it without bottle-necking issues. For your budget the 8250u and the 1050 is a very balanced combination that will meet your needs. P.S. if you could afford to get a laptop with a 8300h, 3750h or an 8750h get it, also if you can get a 1050ti or 1060, but otherwise I do not believe that your budget allows for a more balanced performance laptop with better value or effective performance.

[PRIYANSH geek]

41 minutes ago, Wh0_Am_1 said:

Not in the slightest, the 8250u is plenty capable of keeping up with the GTX1050 I know as I have a Core i5 2500 (a 2011 desktop CPU that is ~%1 faster than the 8250u) and in most modern games, I could even strap an 1650 to it without bottle-necking issues. For your budget the 8250u and the 1050 is a very balanced combination that will meet your needs. P.S. if you could afford to get a laptop with a 8300h, 3750h or an 8750h get it, also if you can get a 1050ti or 1060, but otherwise I do not believe that your budget allows for a more balanced performance laptop with better value or effective performance.

the acer laptop i mentioned has i5 8300H, 1050Ti but i dont know is acer good in terms of durability and service so, i also chose an asus tuf series laptop which is a complete amd setup , processor is better than i5 8250 and gpu equivalent to 1050 (i bring asus into my list so that if acer fails to fulfill of my needs i can go with amd setup but now you gave me a new choice

I also included Asus FX504GD-E4021T(its price increased rapidly and now out of my budget)  

So, with whom should i step forward

also please tell me is asus fx504 a good laptop

[Wh0_Am_1]

18 hours ago, PRIYANSH geek said:

the acer laptop i mentioned has i5 8300H, 1050Ti but i dont know is acer good in terms of durability and service so, i also chose an asus tuf series laptop which is a complete amd setup , processor is better than i5 8250 and gpu equivalent to 1050 (i bring asus into my list so that if acer fails to fulfill of my needs i can go with amd setup but now you gave me a new choice

I also included Asus FX504GD-E4021T(its price increased rapidly and now out of my budget)  

So, with whom should i step forward

also please tell me is asus fx504 a good laptop

Yes it is, it does not have the military ruggedness rating of the FX505, but it is a good laptop, I apologize those are better laptops, I was aiming for the best available value for ~₹55,000 INR as per your listed budget, so I recommended that laptop, if you can afford these other laptops, then go ahead, they are better laptops.