Smite lag with others on same connection. Any solutions?

[NebulaShadow]

My girlfriend and 2 friends of mine have recently gotten into Smite. We have been trying to play this game together on my internet, which is a stable 50mbps connection through TWC. However, when we try to play together using my router in the same games, we are experiencing a teleporting lag quite often. It isn't rubberbanding really, just a short teleport that is frequent enough to cause gameplay to be considerably more difficult. I have tried setting unique static IP's to my both my girlfriend's laptop and my own, and either I did this wrong or it didn't help any. My modem/router is aNETGEAR N450 WiFi DOCSIS 3.0 Cable Modem Router (N450-100NAS). Any help or tips I could try to reduce lag when we game together would be great. Thanks!

[Jade]

Does it happen in other games? Are you using Ethernet or Wifi? Is your ping higher than usual? Lots of missing + potentially important information missing. :\

[NebulaShadow]

I am using wired, but it seems to happen both wired and wireless for us. It is primarily in Smite, but I don't play any other MOBA's so it is hard to say. Doesn't seem to be an issue much in shooters though. Ping during the lag seems to be around 120-130 for my girlfriend. She lags more than I do on my desktop when she uses the laptop, but that is consistent with both wired and wireless connections. After running speedtest, it says I have 8ms Ping, 56.26mpbs download speed, and 5.72mbps upload speed. This should be plenty fast enough I believe, but the lag is still present. If you need to know anything else, just ask. Thanks.

[NebulaShadow]

Anyone able to find anything to help? Maybe router settings that would improve performance?