Compare these, which of them is good?

[lais911]

 

Amd ryzen 5 1600
Corsair vengeance 3000mhz 8gb
Barracuda 1tb 7200rpm
Gigabyte pb500
Amd raedon rx550
Asus ex a320m gaming amd motherboard
Cabinet ~ chiptronex mx2 

                 Or

 

These are my spec's are they good? Or should I change the specs

Amd ryzen 3 3400g
Corsair vengeance 3000mhz 8gb
Barracuda 1tb 7200rpm
Gigabyte pb500
Asus ex a320m gaming amd motherboard
Cabinet ~ chiptronex mx2 

 

[Spudwell06]

When it comes to mobos, I'd go b450/b550, just as a bit better upgradablity 

An ssd would go far

And if possible, atx mobo instead of matx

 

 

Ps, post this in the builds folder instead of discussion 

[nox_]

3 hours ago, Spudwell06 said:

And if possible, atx mobo instead of matx

 

That is a waste of money, especially when budget is limited.

 

3 hours ago, lais911 said:

Amd ryzen 5 1600
Corsair vengeance 3000mhz 8gb
Barracuda 1tb 7200rpm
Gigabyte pb500
Amd raedon rx550
Asus ex a320m gaming amd motherboard
Cabinet ~ chiptronex mx2 

                 Or

 

These are my spec's are they good? Or should I change the specs

Amd ryzen 3 3400g
Corsair vengeance 3000mhz 8gb
Barracuda 1tb 7200rpm
Gigabyte pb500
Asus ex a320m gaming amd motherboard
Cabinet ~ chiptronex mx2 

How much are you paying for these? ssd's is a must in both builds, at least a small sized. Wouldn't go with a320 mb's, also you would benefit from more ram, at least in the second build.

Edited August 29, 2020 by nox_

[Spudwell06]

1 hour ago, nox_ said:

That is a waste of money, especially when budget is limited

I understand that, but it was as a expansion thing 

[nox_]

1 minute ago, Spudwell06 said:

I understand that, but it was as a expansion thing 

Matx is plenty these days, very few situations require atx imho. What you would be expanding?

[TetraSky]

No dedicated GPU in the second one? 

While the APU is good, the performances of the 550 would be slightly better in multiple games.

But if all you want is a basic PC... 

Second one is best, but I wouldn't recommend the 320a motherboard with a Ryzen 3000 series CPU (even if it's based on Zen+). A B450 is the bare minimum today IMO for an AMD build, regardless of the CPU you put in it. Since it also gives you a greater upgradability later on when used Zen2 cpus hit the market in like 2 years for "dirt cheap".

[Haro]

13 hours ago, Spudwell06 said:

b550

does not support the agesa code for zen 1 cpu's or zen + apu's, the build wouldn't boot in the first place.

 

13 hours ago, lais911 said:

Or

budget for the build? workload? and are you limited to both of these only? 

[DeanB097]

Hello,

 

I see that you haven't gone for a dedicated GPU is one of your builds, and I would suggest you to go for one, since the performance you attain from it will make a huge difference. Also, the motherboards on both these builds are not up to mark, which means you can opt for a better one for sure.

Are you tight on budget? What kind of games do you play? Almost forgot, try to have more RAM as well.

 

Good luck with your build!

[lais911]

On 8/29/2020 at 8:10 PM, TofuHaroto said:

does not support the agesa code for zen 1 cpu's or zen + apu's, the build wouldn't boot in the first place.

 

budget for the build? workload? and are you limited to both of these only? 

I am already out of my budget