intel i3 4150 vs Pentium g3558

[TestedMATTIA]

hey guys ! currently i have to make a decision between an intel i3 4150 and a pentium g3258.

the pc is for my dad and he only use the pc for Excel and Chrome in general (youtube in particular).

i have an idea of using it as a "nas" to backup games ecc

but my question is: is the integrated graphics worse than the i3 ? and will be enough to handle 1080p youtube videos ?

 

this is the current idea (fell free to suggest changes): http://i.imgur.com/5SBTKz2.png

[IMPERIUS]

Yes take the i3 and yes, those integrated graphics are enough

[Shhuks]

hey guys ! currently i have to make a decision between an intel i3 4150 and a pentium g3258.

the pc is for my dad and he only use the pc for Excel and Chrome in general (youtube in particular).

i have an idea of using it as a "nas" to backup games ecc

but my question is: is the integrated graphics worse than the i3 ? and will be enough to handle 1080p youtube videos ?

 

this is the current idea (fell free to suggest changes): http://i.imgur.com/5SBTKz2.png

I just built a new rig with that 4150 and the on-board graphics can handle minimal gaming and the YouTube easy. 

[Mr.Reggin]

I just built a new rig with that 4150 and the on-board graphics can handle minimal gaming and the YouTube easy. 

if its intel hd grpahics 4600, then yes, you wont believe it but with these graphics I can get 15-20fps in BF3 in 1080p low without having too many explosions being displayed

[Shhuks]

if its intel hd grpahics 4600, then yes, you wont believe it but with these graphics I can get 15-20fps in BF3 in 1080p low without having too many explosions being displayed

I didn't see him mention he would be playing Battlefield on it? 

[TestedMATTIA]

Yes take the i3 and yes, those integrated graphics are enough

but why the i3 ?

[Shhuks]

*Hyper-threading* I was also looking at the G3258, but I don't know from my own experience if it could handle those programs alone. I got my 4150 for the same price as a G3258 when it was on sale last week. 

[Mr.Reggin]

just get the i3

[IMPERIUS]

but why the i3 ?

Its hyperthreaded and so on...basically an all around better chip