Looking for a new router

[balzer45]

I have a dying apple airport extreme router that was purchased for me a few years back, its time for an upgrade and I was hoping to find something that would give my 1,800 sqft house with 10 or so devices future proofing and reliability, every router I've considered has had several negative reviews on amazon for either "not being the router they purchased" or "dying after 3 months." any recommendations would be much appreciated, thanks!

Edit:
Realized I forgot to mention my budget, preferably under 160$ but can go up to 200 if necessary

Edited March 30, 2018 by balzer45
Forgot budget info