GPU recommendation

[Cohenian]

Hello friends, first of all I wish you a good day.
I want to buy a second hand graphics card and I'm stuck between a few models.

 

RX570 4GB
RX570 8GB
gtx1060 6gb

 

Note: Of course, 8gb is better than 4gb, but if there is no big fps difference, it makes more sense to buy 4gb, please give your opinion; D

Also, my system in case you need it;

 

i5 10400
8GB Ram
GT 1030

 

thanks.

[filpo]

1 minute ago, Cohenian said:

Hello friends, first of all I wish you a good day.
I want to buy a second hand graphics card and I'm stuck between a few models.

 

RX570 4GB
RX570 8GB
gtx1060 6gb

 

Note: Of course, 8gb is better than 4gb, but if there is no big fps difference, it makes more sense to buy 4gb, please give your opinion; D

Also, my system in case you need it;

 

i5 10400
8GB Ram
GT 1030

 

thanks.

the rx 570 8 gig will be much better in the long run but if you can find a 580 you should go for that one

[SorryBella]

3 minutes ago, Cohenian said:

RX570 4GB
RX570 8GB
gtx1060 6gb

Region? Used price can be super unreliable outside of global markets like ebay, to the point that where you live locally can affect pricing.

[Cohenian]

Just now, SorryClaire said:

Region? Used price can be super unreliable outside of global markets like ebay, to the point that where you live locally can affect pricing.

Turkey 

[Cohenian]

3 minutes ago, filpo said:

the rx 570 8 gig will be much better in the long run but if you can find a 580 you should go for that one

Yeah it makes sense and i guess i should get the 8gb rx580 for better vram for upcoming titles right? Just trying to make sure

[WereCat]

If you can grab an RX 5600 XT or 5700 XT instead... Otherwise the RX 570 8GB from those you've listed.

Many modern game will struggle with just 4GB of VRAM. 

[Crunchy Dragon]

4 minutes ago, Cohenian said:

Yeah it makes sense and i guess i should get the 8gb rx580 for better vram for upcoming titles right? Just trying to make sure

RX 580 and GTX 1060 are very similar in performance, so for me it'd be a decision between VRAM and software. I quite like Nvidia's software personally so I'd lean more 1060 but your use cases are likely different than mine.

[SorryBella]

1 hour ago, Cohenian said:

Turkey 

Ow. Yeah i dont think you can get any better than that, but id definitely eliminate the 4GB. While yes, the on-die performance is pretty much down to a coinflip, 4GB isnt a lot even on low settings on a lot of newer games out there. 1060 or 580? Hard to say, they were both neck in neck on launch, theyre still neck in neck now. If the VRAM didnt call you in or the software on nvidia with CUDA, NVENC (albeit not as good as Ampere and above, Pascal NVENC is still really great), or GFE software suite, pick the lowest price.

[Cohenian]

2 hours ago, SorryClaire said:

Ow. Yeah i dont think you can get any better than that, but id definitely eliminate the 4GB. While yes, the on-die performance is pretty much down to a coinflip, 4GB isnt a lot even on low settings on a lot of newer games out there. 1060 or 580? Hard to say, they were both neck in neck on launch, theyre still neck in neck now. If the VRAM didnt call you in or the software on nvidia with CUDA, NVENC (albeit not as good as Ampere and above, Pascal NVENC is still really great), or GFE software suite, pick the lowest price.

So after a lot of looking in site i actually found a very clean 570 8gb and 580 8gb with good price but the 580 look like opened so if there isn't a HUGE gap between 570 8gb and 580 8gb i may grab the 570 one because its very clean tbh.

[Cohenian]

2 hours ago, SorryClaire said:

Ow. Yeah i dont think you can get any better than that, but id definitely eliminate the 4GB. While yes, the on-die performance is pretty much down to a coinflip, 4GB isnt a lot even on low settings on a lot of newer games out there. 1060 or 580? Hard to say, they were both neck in neck on launch, theyre still neck in neck now. If the VRAM didnt call you in or the software on nvidia with CUDA, NVENC (albeit not as good as Ampere and above, Pascal NVENC is still really great), or GFE software suite, pick the lowest price.

And this is the 580 and it looks likes it has opened lately