Ryzen 5 3600 with RTX 2060 Zotac vs i7-9700KF with Asus RTX 2060 Super

[Blanche018]

Hi,

I'm buying my first PC, can you suggest between this 2 which are best for gaming performance?

 

Build 1:

Ryzen5 3600

B450 gigabyte

32gb 3600 mhz ram

RTX 2060 zotac amp

256gb nvme kingston

1tb hdd

Cooler master hyper 212

Seasonic s12-III 620w

 

Build 2:

i7 9700KF Unlocked

Asus EX-B365M-V

Deepcool Gammaxx 120mm

16gb 2666mhz Hyper X Fury

Asus RTX 2060 SUPER 8gb Dual EVO

240GB Kingston Sata SSD

Huntkey GS705 700w Power Supply

Fans: 2xRGB YGT fans

 

Please help me.

 

[Cool Dude 101]

Well, build 1 has more ram and more threads, not to mention more storage. 

Build 2 has more Vram, more CPU cores and a 700w PSU instead of a 620w.

Swap the ram to build 2 and add the hdd.  That is my suggestion. 

[Middcore]

Build 2 will give better gaming performance, mostly on the strength of the superior video card. It won't be a huge margin.

 

32GB of RAM is unnecessary for gaming. 

[Blanche018]

Does the Processor on Build 2 will bottleneck its GPU?

[Middcore]

1 minute ago, Blanche018 said:

Does the Processor on Build 2 will bottleneck its GPU?

No. Although that cooler will probably not be adequate to get the most out of the 9700KF with overclocking. 

[Blanche018]

13 minutes ago, Middcore said:

No. Although that cooler will probably not be adequate to get the most out of the 9700KF with overclocking. 

May I know what cooler do you suggest to make this better?

[Middcore]

2 minutes ago, Blanche018 said:

May I know what cooler do you suggest to make this better?

 

I could make suggestions, but I just noticed that the Intel build has a B365 board that isn't capable of overclocking at all, a very silly pairing with the 9700KF, so there's no point in buying a chungus cooler. 

 

That being the case, assuming these two systems are priced about the same for you, I'd say get the Ryzen system. It at least makes sense and has an upgrade path, and will only lag a little behind in performance from the vanilla 2060 compared to the 2060 Super.

 

If you could drop to 16GB of RAM on the Ryzen build and get the 2060 Super with it, that would be the best combo. 

[Blanche018]

18 minutes ago, Middcore said:

 

I could make suggestions, but I just noticed that the Intel build has a B365 board that isn't capable of overclocking at all, a very silly pairing with the 9700KF, so there's no point in buying a chungus cooler. 

 

That being the case, assuming these two systems are priced about the same for you, I'd say get the Ryzen system. It at least makes sense and has an upgrade path, and will only lag a little behind in performance from the vanilla 2060 compared to the 2060 Super.

 

If you could drop to 16GB of RAM on the Ryzen build and get the 2060 Super with it, that would be the best combo. 

I would definitely do that if possible.

but the thing is the build 1 cost around $1.1k  with included 145 Hz gamdias Curved Monitor 24"

and the build 2 cost around $872 just as it is.
so do you think that build 1 and 2 is bit overpriced?

and they are being sold separately as package by different seller
 

[Mark Kaine]

build 1 should be faster, also build 2 has a poor psu, so yeah.

 

 

18 minutes ago, Blanche018 said:

cost around $1.1k

thats extremely overpriced however,  a friend of mine just bought a prebuilt with 10700k and a 3070 for 1200, just to put it into perspective.

 

 

[Blanche018]

Hey guys just found this another build.
do you think this is also good? this set comes at $1169 usd

 

CPU: AMD Ryzen 7 2700 Eight-Core

Processor 16 thread CPU w/box

MOBO: B450 AORUS PRO (rev. 1.0) w/box

RAM: T-Force Delta TUF DDR4 16GB (2x8GB) 3200MHz w/box

GPU: Radeon™ RX 5600 XT GAMING OC 6G rev. 2.0 w/box

PSU: Seasonic SS-620 GM (M12II-620 Bronze) 620 Watt Power Supply (80 PLUS®BRONZE) w/box

CASE: FSP CMT340 Addressable RGB Mid-Tower Chassis

M.2 250 GB / O.S Windows 10 Pro

HDD 500 GB

 

Peripherals:

Logitech C920 HD PRO WEBCAM w/box

Rakk Illuminated Gaming Keyboard V2 GCB

Marvo Scorpion M513 RGB Gaming Mouse

Dual monitor: Samsung 21" / Nvision XC24S Curve 24"

V8 soundcard and BM800 condenser microphone.

Large RGB Colorful LED Lighting Gaming Mouse Pad Dual LED Monitor Mount with C-clamp and Grommet bracket

 

Is this build really good for gaming? and is it overpriced also?

[Mark Kaine]

6 hours ago, Blanche018 said:

Is this build really good for gaming

it's mediocre, the cpu is old, the gpu rather weak, its not bad, just not great for modern games.

 

6 hours ago, Blanche018 said:

and is it overpriced also?

 

6 hours ago, Blanche018 said:

$1169 usd

yes, very much so.

 

 

as i posted above why don't you try finding a prebuilt for a similar price? 10th gen intel, 3060ti or 3070 or something, should cost between 1200-1400 and will be far more powerful. 

 

im not sure where you are, but if in NA especially that is a far better option. 

[Blanche018]

39 minutes ago, Mark Kaine said:

it's mediocre, the cpu is old, the gpu rather weak, its not bad, just not great for modern games.

 

 

yes, very much so.

 

 

as i posted above why don't you try finding a prebuilt for a similar price? 10th gen intel, 3060ti or 3070 or something, should cost between 1200-1400 and will be far more powerful. 

 

im not sure where you are, but if in NA especially that is a far better option. 

I'm located at Philippines, and the graphics card here cost so much.

I'll probably wait a few more years or so, to increase my budget, just so I could buy the powerful one.

Thank you for the information btw. this really help me soo much and have prevented me from impulse buying some 2nd hand used unit.

 

See ya in another year or so.