Which one is better (pc)

[abcededededede]

I need to know which of these pcs are better

 

1.

AMD Ryzen 5 3600 

MSI B450-A PRO  EVGA GeForce RTX 2070 SUPER Black Edition Gaming Western Digital WD 500GB SSD Toshiba 2TB P300 3.5in Hard Drive Cougar MX330 Black ATX Case be quiet! Pure Power 11 500W CM Power Supply, 80PLUS Gold   2. amd ryzen 5 3600 asrock b450m steal legend micro atx team t-force delta rgb 16gb seagate barracuda 2tb 3.5 silicon power A55 512 gb Msi geforce rtx 2070 cooler master masterbox q3000 seasonic focus plus gold       also in australia is 400 dollars for a 144hz expensive when you could get one for 200 dollars

[Dedayog]

Top of my head, the one with the 2070 Super is going to be slightly better than the regular 2070 but they;'re withing spitting distance.

 

Quality of the other components may sway it slightly.

[Guest]

Hi Mate, the obvious question is better for what? 

 

Everything you've listed there seems to be from a pretty reputable brand, and so it will come down to the way it's clocked vs. benchmarks vs. what you plan to do with it (although the 2070 Super is better for gaming than regular)

 

Where did you find the 144Hz monitor for AUD $200? I'm keen to check it out (I'm in Melbourne).

[Npiet1]

11 minutes ago, SiliconT said:

Hi Mate, the obvious question is better for what? 

 

Everything you've listed there seems to be from a pretty reputable brand, and so it will come down to the way it's clocked vs. benchmarks vs. what you plan to do with it (although the 2070 Super is better for gaming than regular)

 

Where did you find the 144Hz monitor for AUD $200? I'm keen to check it out (I'm in Melbourne).

Kogan has them $190 aud, but Kogan is an awful brand.

[boey]

What is the RAM for the first one

[Guest]

3 minutes ago, Npiet1 said:

Kogan has them $190 aud, but Kogan is an awful brand.

Yeah I might give Kogan a miss

[abcededededede]

11 minutes ago, _d0nut said:

What is the RAM for the first one

16gb

[abcededededede]

24 minutes ago, SiliconT said:

Hi Mate, the obvious question is better for what? 

 

Everything you've listed there seems to be from a pretty reputable brand, and so it will come down to the way it's clocked vs. benchmarks vs. what you plan to do with it (although the 2070 Super is better for gaming than regular)

 

Where did you find the 144Hz monitor for AUD $200? I'm keen to check it out (I'm in Melbourne).

comparing my friends and mine

[Guest]

Gotcha. They are probably pretty similar, except the 2070 Super is more powerful than the 2070 by 10%+ (depending on what the 2070 is clocked at vs. the black edition gaming super, you would be able to look up a benchmark I'm sure).

 

Both nice builds eh?

[boey]

7 minutes ago, abcededededede said:

16gb

what speed is it rated at? Ryzen loves memory speed, so having low-speed memory would really lower your performance by a huge margin

[Dedayog]

7 minutes ago, abcededededede said:

comparing my friends and mine

Oh you're not looking to buy?

 

This is just epeen crap?

[Guest]

Hey @abcededededede, why don't you run Superpositon benchmark in 1080p Extreme and see?

 

https://benchmark.unigine.com/superposition