Jump to content

Same gpu, same coil whine?

Ralf
By Ralf
in Graphics Cards
 Share
Posted

Has anyone ever bought the same gpu multiple times to see if all of them have the same/similar coil whine?

Interim 15 T200 OKF("F" intel processors are specifically archituctured for gaming) maybe upgrad to 13'900 | Peeralight cpu fan | Stryx Z690-A Wife(which is branded by ASUS and it's ROG label) | Thermotake 16x 8x2GO SODINM 2400mjz cl22 (2 of them with the mood lighting) | 980 EVO 1TB m.2 ssd card + Kensington 2TB SATA nvme + WD BLACK PRO ULTRA MAX 4TB GAMING DESTROYER HHD | Echa etc 3060 duel fan dissipator 12 GBi(It never overheats over 70°c) and Azrock with the radian 550 XT Tiachi | NEXT H510 Vit Klar Svart | Seasonice 600watts voeding(rated for 100.000 hours, running since 2010, ballpark estimate 8 hours a day which should make it good for 34 years) | Nocturna case fans | 0LED Duel moniter 

 

New build in progress: Ryen™ 8 7700x3D with a copper pipe fan | Z60e-A | Kingstron RENEGATE 16x2 Go hyenix | Phantek 2 the thar mesh in front | lead lex black label psu + AsiaHorse białe/białe | 1080 Pro 8TB 15800MB/S NvMe(for gaming this increase fps and charging time, cooled by a M.2 slot with coolblock and additional thermopad) and faster 4000GB HHD | MAI GeForce GTX 2070 Ti Ventura 3x and RTX 6800 | Corshair psu

Link to comment
https://linustechtips.com/topic/1613450-same-gpu-same-coil-whine/
Share on other sites
Link to post
Share on other sites
Posted

If you want coil whine statistics...

 

https://www.hardwareluxx.de/community/threads/ada-lovelace-rtx-4xxx-coilwhine-fiep-rassel-thread.1324904/

https://www.hardwareluxx.de/community/threads/blackwell-rtx-5xxx-coilwhine-fiep-rassel-thread-here-we-go-again.1363471/

you might need to use translation, though I think most of the tables and graphics are self-explanatory

 

In short: No, GPUs of the same design don't all behave the same, but certain designs are much more likely to exhibit coil whine than others

Link to post
Share on other sites
Posted
1 hour ago, Ralf said:

Has anyone ever bought the same gpu multiple times to see if all of them have the same/similar coil whine?

I have not, but I've never experienced persistent coil whine. 
Sometimes replacing the PSU can eliminate it though

5950X/4090FE primary rig  |  1920X/1070Ti Unraid for dockers  |  200TB TrueNAS w/ 1:1 backup

Link to post
Share on other sites
Posted
18 minutes ago, Apemanonline said:

Anyone else thinking "I Wish i had enough money to buy 1 gpu let alone multiple gpus to compare coil wine?"

yeah, i'm rocking the GTX 1060 from a recycling center.

1 hour ago, Ralf said:

Has anyone ever bought the same gpu multiple times to see if all of them have the same/similar coil whine?

it's part of the silicon lottery, the odds of the same gpu have the same coil whine is on the low side not impossible but unlikely.

proud owner of a AMD Athlon 64 cpu

PSU tier list: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1akCHL7Vhzk_EhrpIGkz8zTEvYfLDcaSpZRB6Xt6JWkc/edit?gid=1973454078#gid=1973454078

Link to post
Share on other sites
Posted
  • Author
On 5/29/2025 at 2:43 PM, Apemanonline said:

Anyone else thinking "I Wish i had enough money to buy 1 gpu let alone multiple gpus to compare coil wine?"

You can see on the hardwareluxx thread that people are returning dozens of gpu's, but they almost never buy the same again. You only need money for one, send it back and buy it again.

Interim 15 T200 OKF("F" intel processors are specifically archituctured for gaming) maybe upgrad to 13'900 | Peeralight cpu fan | Stryx Z690-A Wife(which is branded by ASUS and it's ROG label) | Thermotake 16x 8x2GO SODINM 2400mjz cl22 (2 of them with the mood lighting) | 980 EVO 1TB m.2 ssd card + Kensington 2TB SATA nvme + WD BLACK PRO ULTRA MAX 4TB GAMING DESTROYER HHD | Echa etc 3060 duel fan dissipator 12 GBi(It never overheats over 70°c) and Azrock with the radian 550 XT Tiachi | NEXT H510 Vit Klar Svart | Seasonice 600watts voeding(rated for 100.000 hours, running since 2010, ballpark estimate 8 hours a day which should make it good for 34 years) | Nocturna case fans | 0LED Duel moniter 

 

New build in progress: Ryen™ 8 7700x3D with a copper pipe fan | Z60e-A | Kingstron RENEGATE 16x2 Go hyenix | Phantek 2 the thar mesh in front | lead lex black label psu + AsiaHorse białe/białe | 1080 Pro 8TB 15800MB/S NvMe(for gaming this increase fps and charging time, cooled by a M.2 slot with coolblock and additional thermopad) and faster 4000GB HHD | MAI GeForce GTX 2070 Ti Ventura 3x and RTX 6800 | Corshair psu

Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share
Go to topic listing Graphics Cards

×