PC?

[Enxgma]

Which processor is better?(r5 2400G or r5 3400G)

 

 

My peripherals-

Monitor- 1920 x 1080

Refresh Rate- 120Hz

 

I live in India, You can check prices from-

Amazon-https://www.amazon.in/ref=nav_logo

Pricelist-http://www.costtocost.in/list/pricelist.pdf

Flipkart-https://www.flipkart.com/

 

Which system is better?

AMD Ryzen 5 3400G- $193.94  (or Ryzen 5 2400G- $158.61)

MSI B450 Gaming Plus- $90.72

HyperX 2x4GB 2400MHz Ram- $48.85                                                                                         

Thermaltake 500W RGB- $36.29

240Gb SSD + 1TB External HDD( I already have them)

 

Grand Total- $369.8 with r5 3400G (with r5 2400G- $334.47)

 

 

or                                                   Xbox One S - $341.82           

 

 

 

You can also recommend me any Build under $356.76

[Enxgma]

I wanna play games like Minecraft, Fortnite, Apex Legends,

Call of duty-   WW2, Infinite Warfare, Ghosts, Black Ops IV

and other fps games

 

 

 

 

 

Please don't include case or Storage Price

[Stormseeker9]

3400g is better. 

 

But xonsidering you you are so low in budget a console might be better here 

[Enxgma]

But isn't there room for putting a GPU in the near future?

I checked their benchmarks, it only showed a difference of 3-5 FPS

[Enxgma]

What about this build-

Intel i3-9100F

AMD RX570 4GB

Any Mobo

same ram and psu

[mariushm]

3400g still uses the Zen+ cores, it's not the 7nm chips that make the Ryzen 3xxx series , it's just Ryzen 2400g on 12nm process and running at slightly higher frequencies.

So, it's not worth the extra money if you think you're gonna get the performance increase of  3rd generation of Ryzen processors.

 

You have very good deals on the old Ryzen 3 1200 processor, they're available for ₹5430.00 on Amazon : https://www.amazon.in/dp/B0741DN383/

If you really need some integrated graphics, 2200g is not that more expensive at ₹7250.00  : https://www.amazon.in/dp/B079D3DBNM/

You get slightly less raw performance compared to 3200g or 3400g but you should be able to easily overclock the 1200 to get close to 3200 or 3400g.

 

The idea is that you can go with the 5430 INR processor and save ~75$ and maybe put a few dollars and get a 100-120$ (if you get from Aliexpress or eBay in your case) RX 570 which will give you several times the graphical performance.

 

Or, you could go for a RX 560 or a GTX 1050, both giving you more performance than the integrated graphics.

 

You can save some money by going with a cheaper motherboard yet still perfectly fine for your needs:

 

6370 INR (89$) : GIGABYTE B450M DS3H (AMD Ryzen AM4/M.2/HMDI/DVI/USB 3.1/DDR4/Micro ATX/Motherboard)

 

Added bonus it had 4 memory slots, so you can buy 2 x 4 GB sticks now to save money and add more ram later in the other 2 slots.

 

Ram is also cheaper if you look around a bit :

 

2 x 1399 INR (39$) : Crucial CB4GU2400 4GB 2400Mhz DDR4 1.2v CL17 UDIMM RAM Memory Module for Desktop

 

So let's add them up:

 

5430 INR : Ryzen 1200 : https://www.amazon.in/dp/B0741DN383/

6370 INR : GIGABYTE B450M DS3H : https://www.amazon.in/dp/B07FWVJSHC/

2800 INR : 2 x Crucial CB4GU2400 4GB 2400Mhz DDR4 1.2v

 

= 14600 INR or ~ 203$

 

If you want new video cards, here's some options... all are more powerful than integrated graphics , from less power to more:

 

7700 INR : Gigabyte GV-RX560OC-4GD REV2.0 Radeon RX 560 OC 4GB : https://www.amazon.in/dp/B079LSNP74/

11300-11500 INR :  GTX 1050 ti ...  similar perf and price and gpu chip and ram size etc:

* Gigabyte Technology GeForce GTX 1050 Ti Windforce OC 4G : https://www.amazon.in/dp/B01M25X363/

* Zotac GeForce GTX 1050 Ti 4 GB OC Edition Video Card : https://www.amazon.in/dp/B01M27X994/

* MSI GeForce GTX 1050 Ti 4 GB Video Card : https://www.amazon.in/dp/B01MG3IX4F/

 

12500-12675 INR : GTX 1650 ( kinda similar with RX 570 but not sure, look benchmarks, should use less power than RX 570)

* Gigabyte GeForce GTX 1650 4 GB WINDFORCE OC https://www.amazon.in/dp/B07QPVNL74/

* Zotac GeForce GTX 1650 4 GB GAMING OC https://www.amazon.in/dp/B07QF1H9YR/

* Inno3D GeForce GTX 1650 4 GB https://www.amazon.in/dp/B07R223FKT/

 

13500 INR : Gigabyte Radeon RX 570 4 GB Gaming 4G https://www.amazon.in/dp/B06Y3RT952/

 

If you have that budget, I would go with 1650 or RX 570 but even GTX 1050 TI should be good enough for 1080p gaming on low-medium quality settings, and much better than integrated graphics.

Even better, in the future if you want you could upgrade to a six core cpu or even 8 core cpu, and the motherboard supports even 3rd generation Ryzen processors (with bios updates)

 

 

 

 

[mariushm]

From your Cost To Cost PDF, these would work ... but not sure price is better than Amazon one (if you add the 18% vat)

 

(added +18% vat in brackets)

 

3900 INR Ryzen 1200

5990 INR Ryzen 2200g

 

5290 INR MSI B450 M PRO M2 only 2 mem slots, no heatsinks... not worth to save only 100 INR go with vv

5390 INR MSI B450 M PRO VDH PLUS  looks ok, good price vs features, 4 memory, heatsinks, hdmi/dvi/vga 

5750 INR GIGABYTE B450 M GAMING

5990 INR Asus B450M-A

6000 INR GIGABYTE B 450 MDS3H

6500 MSI B450 M GAMING PLUS

 

Cheaper ones will work, but they'll only have 2 memory slots. So you may save money here, but if you want to upgrade to 16 GB of memory in future, you'll spend more money in ram to get 2 x 8 GB, or you'll lose performance for a while by buying a single 8 GB stick and using PC in single channel mode until you can afford a second stick

Also, may be worth going with a model that costs a bit more but which has some heatsinks on the VRM (the chips between the cpu socket and the IO shield with all the connectors)

 

ram .. .whatever's cheaper, at least 2400 Mhz... get a single 8GB stick if you buy board with only two memory slots (and MUST get 2nd stick as soon as possible, because dual channel mode gives you something like 5-10% extra performance in games), or buy 2 x 4 GB if the board has 4 slots.

 

video cards : rx 560, gtx 1050 ti , gtx 1650, rx 570 .. kind of this order when it comes to graphics performance.. gtx 1660 may also be worth considering but look at reviews to see where it sits.

 

2200g graphics performance is at around GT 1030 / RX 450 / RX 550 levels

2400g is above between GT 1030 and GT 1050 / around RX 450 / RX 550

3200g / 3400g is not much better.

 

Pretty much you have 1050ti for 9500 INR, 1650 at 10300-12600 INR .. don't see any RX 560 or RX 570 in that list... shame. RX 580 is not worth at that list price.

 

One more thing... these modern video cards don't have VGA output ... so make sure your monitor has something else besides VGA. Since you say it's 120 fps, I assume it has DisplayPort or HDMI or DVI.

If it's only VGA, you'll have to buy a HDMI/Displayport to VGA active converter ... or get cpu with integrated graphics and motherboard with vga connector on it.