Buy Borderlands 2 (or and the PreSequel) if you dont have it yet over G2A its under 15$ I think! Best Koop Series Ever if you have friends
I have the first two Games from your list and they are also very good for what they are but Borderlands is much more fun Buy this or the Witcher 3 I think around 23$ on G2A.com
Just my opinion and those are the Games I play these days! Didn't got many hours in the first two Games u listed. 20 in the Cities Skylines Game and 10 in Rocket League.
But the Witcher has 86 hours and I think I'm about half way through, and Borderlands 2 I have 50 hours and just completed the main game. Now I bought the PreSequel and its also such a great game