Jump to content

so im looking at this rad. its thick so i was thinking about have 6 fans on a 240mm rad. i would have 2 infront of my HDD cage then inside my HDD cage have the rad sandwhiched with 4 fans. so 6 fans in total. then i was curious about adding a 2nd rad behind my HDD cage. it would be serperate from the orignal rad and would have 2 of its own fans.

 

is this still considered stacking?

 

would i be able to have enough power to pull al the air through ~120mm total thickness rads with 8 fans? 

 

should i use 6 fans on the thick rad? 

 

thanks guys!

Big Bertha3570k @ 4.5GhzASRock Fatal1ty Z777970 DCUII TOP EVGA GTX 780Swiftech H220 w/ NF-F1216GB RAM128GB Kingston HyperX 3K1TB Western Digital Black40GB Western Digital Raptor 10K PeripheralsMionix 3200 MouseCMStorm Quickfire Rapid w/ Cherry MX Blues2 x Dell U2713HM AudioAsus ROG Orion Pro HeadsetSony XB-500AKG K240Bose AE2i​Fiio E10

Samsung Galaxy S45.0" 1920x1080p Super AMOLED screen16GB Storage2600 mAh battery1.9Ghz quad-core Krait CPU2GB RAMCyanogenMod CameraNikon D310018x55mm NIKKOR VR Lens14.2 MP
Link to comment
https://linustechtips.com/topic/44399-stacking-fans-placements-pressure/
Share on other sites

Link to post
Share on other sites

There is no point doing that, just use push pull, by adding more fans you will get about 0.00000000000000000121ºc improvement.

Link to post
Share on other sites

No that will waste your time and power 4 in pull, push, push/pull is fine

 

 

There is no point doing that, just use push pull, by adding more fans you will get about 0.00000000000000000121ºc improvement.

 

i didnt know if the thickness of the radiator would slow airflow drastically.

 

what about adding a second rad?

Big Bertha3570k @ 4.5GhzASRock Fatal1ty Z777970 DCUII TOP EVGA GTX 780Swiftech H220 w/ NF-F1216GB RAM128GB Kingston HyperX 3K1TB Western Digital Black40GB Western Digital Raptor 10K PeripheralsMionix 3200 MouseCMStorm Quickfire Rapid w/ Cherry MX Blues2 x Dell U2713HM AudioAsus ROG Orion Pro HeadsetSony XB-500AKG K240Bose AE2i​Fiio E10

Samsung Galaxy S45.0" 1920x1080p Super AMOLED screen16GB Storage2600 mAh battery1.9Ghz quad-core Krait CPU2GB RAMCyanogenMod CameraNikon D310018x55mm NIKKOR VR Lens14.2 MP
Link to post
Share on other sites

i didnt know if the thickness of the radiator would slow airflow drastically.

 

what about adding a second rad?

There is lot more sense, i would suggest you to do that.
Link to post
Share on other sites

There is lot more sense, i would suggest you to do that.

I mean behind the harddrive cage :p

Big Bertha3570k @ 4.5GhzASRock Fatal1ty Z777970 DCUII TOP EVGA GTX 780Swiftech H220 w/ NF-F1216GB RAM128GB Kingston HyperX 3K1TB Western Digital Black40GB Western Digital Raptor 10K PeripheralsMionix 3200 MouseCMStorm Quickfire Rapid w/ Cherry MX Blues2 x Dell U2713HM AudioAsus ROG Orion Pro HeadsetSony XB-500AKG K240Bose AE2i​Fiio E10

Samsung Galaxy S45.0" 1920x1080p Super AMOLED screen16GB Storage2600 mAh battery1.9Ghz quad-core Krait CPU2GB RAMCyanogenMod CameraNikon D310018x55mm NIKKOR VR Lens14.2 MP
Link to post
Share on other sites

I mean behind the harddrive cage :p

If you can fit radiator there, then great! :)

Link to post
Share on other sites

i didnt know if the thickness of the radiator would slow airflow drastically.

 

what about adding a second rad?

The FPI of a rad is far more important than thickness when it comes down to air restriction.

Feel free to PM for any water-cooling questions. Check out my profile for more ways to contact me.

 

Add me to your circles on Google+ here or you can follow me on twitter @deadfire19.

Link to post
Share on other sites

1 in the roof, 1 in the front is a staple of cooling for a reason...

its been proven (on overclockers forum i think) that having 1 radiator infront of another makes no sence, passing hot air from 1 to another doesnt help, and beyond having a super thick one doesnt help either, this is because of air saturation, the more heat the air absorbs the less it wants to absorb i.e your temps dont improve.

push/pull will also only improve things if the fin density is dense enough to restrict the airflow from the fans to the point that performance is lost compared to a less densely thinned radiator, in that case push/pull has an advantage, but this comes down to how dense the rad is, what fans your using, what rpm those fans are at and this all comes down (though not allot) to what cpu block you're using..

like allot of things its a mixture of everything you put it all coming together.

Falcon: Corsair 750D 8320at4.6ghz 1.3v | 4GB MSI Gaming R9-290 @1000/1250 | 2x8GB 2400mhz Kingston HyperX Beast | Asus ROG Crosshair V Formula | Antec H620 | Corsair RM750w | Crucial M500 240GB, Toshiba 2TB, DarkThemeMasterRace, my G3258 has an upgrade path, my fx8320 doesn't need one...total cost £840=cpu£105, board£65, ram£105, Cooler £20, GPU£200, PSU£88, SSD£75, HDD£57, case£125.

 CASE:-NZXT S340 Black, CPU:-FX8120 @4.2Ghz, COOLER:-CM Hyper 212 EVO, BOARD:-MSI 970 Gaming, RAM:-2x4gb 2400mhz Corsair Vengeance Pro, GPU: SLI EVGA GTX480's @700/1000, PSU:-Corsair CX600m, HDD:-WD green 160GB+2TB toshiba
CASE:-(probably) Cooltek U1, CPU:-G3258 @4.5ghx, COOLER:-stock(soon "MSI Dragon" AiO likely), BOARD:-MSI z87i ITX Gaming, RAM:-1x4gb 1333mhz Patriot, GPU: Asus DCU2 r9-270 OC@1000/1500mem, PSU:-Sweex 350w.., HDD:-WD Caviar Blue 640GB
CASE:-TBD, CPU:-Core2Quad QX9650 @4Ghz, COOLER:-OCZ 92mm tower thing, BOARD:-MSI p43-c51, RAM:-4x1GB 800mhz Corsair XMS2, GPU: Zotac GTX460se @800/1000, PSU:-OCZ600sxs, HDD:-WD green 160GBBlueJean-A
 CASE:-Black/Blue Sharkoon T9, CPU:-Phenom2 x4 B55 @3.6Ghz/1.4v, COOLER:-FX8320 Stock HSF, BOARD:-M5A78L-M/USB3, RAM:-4GB 1333mhz Kingston low profile at 1600mhz, GPU:-EVGA GTX285, PSU:-Antec TP550w modu, STORAGE:-240gb  M500+2TB Toshiba
CASE:-icute zl02-3g-bb, CPU:-Phenom2 X6 1055t @3.5Ghz, COOLER:-Stock, BOARD:-Asrock m3a UCC, RAM:2x2GB 1333mhz Zeppelin (thats yellow!), GPU: XFX 1GB HD6870xxx, PSU:-some 450 POS, HDD:-WD Scorpio blue 120GB
CASE:-Packard Bell iMedia X2424, Custom black/red Aerocool Xpredator fulltower, CPU's:-E5200, C2D [email protected]<script cf-hash='f9e31' type="text/javascript"> /* */</script>(so e8500), COOLER:-Scythe Big shuriken2 Rev B, BFG gtx260 sp216 OC, RAM:-tons..
Gigabyte GTX460, Gigabyte gt430,
GPU's:-GT210 1GB,  asus hd6670 1GB gddr5, XFX XXX 9600gt 512mb Alpha dog edition, few q6600's
PICTURES CASE:-CIT mars black+red, CPU:-Athlon K6 650mhz slot A, COOLER:-Stock, BOARD:-QDI Kinetiz 7a, RAM:-256+256+256MB 133mhz SDram, GPU:-inno3d geforce4 mx440 64mb, PSU:-E-Zcool 450w, STORAGE:-2x WD 40gb "black" drives,
CASE:-silver/red raidmax cobra, CPU:-Athlon64 4000+, COOLER:-BIG stock one, BOARD:-MSI something*, RAM:-(matched pair)2x1GB 400mhz ECC transcend, GPU:-ati 9800se@375core/325mem, PSU:-pfft, HDD:-2x maxtor 80gb,
PICTURES CASE:-silver/red raidmax cobra (another), CPU:-Pentium4 2.8ghz prescott, COOLER:-Artic Coolering Freezer4, BOARD:-DFI lanparty infinity 865 R2, RAM:-(matched pair)2x1GB 400mhz kingston, GPU:-ati 9550@375core/325mem, PSU:-pfft, HDD:-another 2x WD 80gb,
CASE:-ML110 G4, CPU:-xeon 4030, COOLER:-stock leaf blower, BOARD:-stock raid 771 board, RAM:-2x2GB 666mhz kingston ECC ddr2, GPU:-9400GT 1GB, PSU:-stock delta, RAID:-JMicron JMB363 card+onboard raid controller, HDD:-320gb hitachi OS, 2xMaxtor 160gb raid1, 500gb samsungSP, 160gb WD, LAPTOP:-Dell n5030, CPU:-replaced s*** cel900 with awesome C2D E8100, RAM:-2x2GB 1333mhz ddr3, HDD:-320gb, PHONE's:-LG optimus 3D (p920) on 2.3.5@300-600mhz de-clock (batteryFTW)
Link to post
Share on other sites

If you can fit radiator there, then great! :)

  

I could but what I meant was a rad in the hddcage the another rad on the outside of the hdd cage. about 40mm apart :)

The FPI of a rad is far more important than thickness when it comes down to air restriction.

 

so if its thick with high fin density, will 4fans be enough?

 

1 in the roof, 1 in the front is a staple of cooling for a reason...

its been proven (on overclockers forum i think) that having 1 radiator infront of another makes no sence, passing hot air from 1 to another doesnt help, and beyond having a super thick one doesnt help either, this is because of air saturation, the more heat the air absorbs the less it wants to absorb i.e your temps dont improve.

push/pull will also only improve things if the fin density is dense enough to restrict the airflow from the fans to the point that performance is lost compared to a less densely thinned radiator, in that case push/pull has an advantage, but this comes down to how dense the rad is, what fans your using, what rpm those fans are at and this all comes down (though not allot) to what cpu block you're using..

like allot of things its a mixture of everything you put it all coming together.

im going to ghetto rig a 140mm thin rad on the top. I really dont have room at the top of my case so im trying to squeeze as much cooling as I can out of the front intake :)

Big Bertha3570k @ 4.5GhzASRock Fatal1ty Z777970 DCUII TOP EVGA GTX 780Swiftech H220 w/ NF-F1216GB RAM128GB Kingston HyperX 3K1TB Western Digital Black40GB Western Digital Raptor 10K PeripheralsMionix 3200 MouseCMStorm Quickfire Rapid w/ Cherry MX Blues2 x Dell U2713HM AudioAsus ROG Orion Pro HeadsetSony XB-500AKG K240Bose AE2i​Fiio E10

Samsung Galaxy S45.0" 1920x1080p Super AMOLED screen16GB Storage2600 mAh battery1.9Ghz quad-core Krait CPU2GB RAMCyanogenMod CameraNikon D310018x55mm NIKKOR VR Lens14.2 MP
Link to post
Share on other sites

I could but what I meant was a rad in the hddcage the another rad on the outside of the hdd cage. about 40mm apart :) 

so if its thick with high fin density, will 4fans be enough?

 

im going to ghetto rig a 140mm thin rad on the top. I really dont have room at the top of my case so im trying to squeeze as much cooling as I can out of the front intake :)

As long as you're ghetto rigging a fan in the top, might as well ghetto rig a 180 rad up there

Take your pick:

http://www.frozencpu.com/cat/l3/g30/c95/s1550/list/p1/Liquid_Cooling-PC_Water_Cooling_Radiators-180mm_Single-Page1.html

HP something | 5600X | Corsair  16GB | Zotac ArcticStorm GTX 1080 Ti

CaseLabs SM8 | EK Supremacy | UT60 420 | ST30 360 | ST30 240

Gentle Typhoon's and Noctua's and Noiseblocker eLoop's

 

Link to post
Share on other sites

Staking fans will increase static pressure meaning you can run them on slower to achieve equal static pressure as if you were using less fans running faster. May be a tad quieter, though adding extra fans will add noise.

 

Practicality and temp differences will be pretty negligible though.

 

Those Alphakool rads are not that restrictive, push/pull even on lower RPM will keep your system cool enough. IMO water cooling is about looks and silence. I'd rather have a CPU hit 70C under load and the system be silent than the CPU be cooler but sound like a jet. As long as you hit the OC you want CPU temps don't matter (under recommended temps of course), you're won't be getting more performance by running the CPU cooler.

Link to post
Share on other sites

As long as you're ghetto rigging a fan in the top, might as well ghetto rig a 180 rad up there

Take your pick:

http://www.frozencpu.com/cat/l3/g30/c95/s1550/list/p1/Liquid_Cooling-PC_Water_Cooling_Radiators-180mm_Single-Page1.html

 

i cant fit a 180mm either :/ if there was such a thing as 160 i would be good but unfortunately not. 

 

 

Staking fans will increase static pressure meaning you can run them on slower to achieve equal static pressure as if you were using less fans running faster. May be a tad quieter, though adding extra fans will add noise.

 

Practicality and temp differences will be pretty negligible though.

 

Those Alphakool rads are not that restrictive, push/pull even on lower RPM will keep your system cool enough. IMO water cooling is about looks and silence. I'd rather have a CPU hit 70C under load and the system be silent than the CPU be cooler but sound like a jet. As long as you hit the OC you want CPU temps don't matter (under recommended temps of course), you're won't be getting more performance by running the CPU cooler.

 

my gpu gets pretty hot so wc would be worth it. :) 

 

good info btw :D

Big Bertha3570k @ 4.5GhzASRock Fatal1ty Z777970 DCUII TOP EVGA GTX 780Swiftech H220 w/ NF-F1216GB RAM128GB Kingston HyperX 3K1TB Western Digital Black40GB Western Digital Raptor 10K PeripheralsMionix 3200 MouseCMStorm Quickfire Rapid w/ Cherry MX Blues2 x Dell U2713HM AudioAsus ROG Orion Pro HeadsetSony XB-500AKG K240Bose AE2i​Fiio E10

Samsung Galaxy S45.0" 1920x1080p Super AMOLED screen16GB Storage2600 mAh battery1.9Ghz quad-core Krait CPU2GB RAMCyanogenMod CameraNikon D310018x55mm NIKKOR VR Lens14.2 MP
Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

×