@Blatcher2 @ManyCoresGuy @Mira Yurizaki
So I went ahead and tried the recovery program. It recognized the drive and scanned it to recover the data, but all the data it did find was the wrong format. For example, I had over 300 MKV files on the drive ranging from 2-3GB, those all were recovered as Shockwave Flash Files that I couldn't open at all.
So yeah, program doesn't work. Just copied everything over and then reformatted it, now it works perfectly fine.