what type of video game walkthrough do you prefer?

[ImRyan]

for me it depends on the game 

[Husky]

I prefer with commentary

 

it just feels empty, boring and "lonely" without commentary.

[Ridska]

Detailed , Well edited , And a good voiced commentator.

[Paralectic]

With commentary, if there isn't any I won't even notice any story because I'm busy playing.

[ZetZet]

With commentary. But it more depends on how the person who is doing the walkthrough plays. I just can't watch some people play, it makes me angry.

[Narnash]

100% with commentary, most of the time I game simultaneously.

[Sir Asvald]

I like games that have Commentaries. Watching a game without any commentaries it dead. 

 

[Helly]

sorry i got a different definition of walkthrough. I prefer them in text. Easier to find where you left off.

If you're talking about a playthrough. That really depends on the game. If its a real story driven game then i want to follow the story and be pulled in, not have some jackass talk through the story building stuff.... So it really depends on the game and player i guess.

[Avericious]

28 minutes ago, Ridska said:

Detailed , Well edited , And a good voiced commentator.

Exactly. I've found that ChipCheezumLPs do this the best on YouTube. He'll put info in little pop-ups that are indistinguishable from the game UI, play the game multiple times to get good takes or he wants to show off something specific and the commentary is fun and informative to boot.

[Ridska]

2 minutes ago, Avericious said:

Exactly. I've found that ChipCheezumLPs do this the best on YouTube. He'll put info in little pop-ups that are indistinguishable from the game UI, play the game multiple times to get good takes or he wants to show off something specific and the commentary is fun and informative to boot.

I think Yogscast will strife makes good videos ( and no im not a 10 year old who watches the other yogs who make those dull minecraft videos ). And thanks for the sugguestion.

[Avericious]

1 minute ago, Ridska said:

I think Yogscast will strife makes good videos ( and no im not a 10 year old who watches the other yogs who make those dull minecraft videos ). And thanks for the sugguestion.

And thank you for your suggestion.

[GeekJump]

well, I need someone telling me the steps. Especially if I'm following along in real time I can't watch the screen and do it at the same time.

Plus with commentary people are better at spacing the steps out and making it a good length. When I try to watch videos with little to no commentary I have to constantly rewind because they go too fast. 

[PCBjon]

Bring back Ocedmytoaster!!!!!!!

I prefer to have to player talk.