i5 10400f vs Ryzen 3600

[Burnedice25]

Just now, mahyar said:

in my opinion if you dont overclock 10400/10400f is better performance diffrance is not much

so for the price get the 10400f.

gotcha

 

[nox_]

3 minutes ago, Burnedice25 said:

 

 

back to the main question.....

You guys think R3600 100%?

For your workload it would be better, but the difference is not that huge, you could get a better ssd or psu, but I personally would not buy it, dead platform, limited upgrade path.

1 minute ago, Burnedice25 said:

so for the price get the 10400f.

gotcha

 

Keep in mind that it has very limited upgrade path.

[mahyar]

1 minute ago, nox_ said:

For your workload it would be better, but the difference is not that huge, you could get a better ssd or psu, but I personally would not buy it, dead platform, limited upgrade path.

limited? 3950x is a joke to you?

[nox_]

1 minute ago, mahyar said:

limited? 3950x is a joke to you?

If going with the i5 it would be limited.

[mahyar]

Just now, nox_ said:

If going with the i5 it would be limited.

no 11th gen intel also will be at lga1200

[Burnedice25]

3 minutes ago, nox_ said:

For your workload it would be better, but the difference is not that huge, you could get a better ssd or psu, but I personally would not buy it, dead platform, limited upgrade path.

 

2 minutes ago, mahyar said:

limited? 3950x is a joke to you?

I think he meant the i5

even then, LGA 1200 is lined up to support rocket lake soooooo....

[nox_]

Just now, mahyar said:

no 11th gen intel also will be at lga1200

Again, by going with amd the upgrade path would be better imo. Not saying that upgrade path is not existant, just more limited than with AMD.

[mahyar]

Just now, Burnedice25 said:

 

I think he meant the i5

even then, LGA 1200 is lined up to support rocket lake soooooo....

yeah upgrade path is similar 

[nox_]

Just now, mahyar said:

yeah upgrade path is similar 

AMD upgrade path is still better.

[mahyar]

1 minute ago, nox_ said:

AMD upgrade path is still better.

lets be honest a 10900k is still a powerful cpu

not counting 11th gen

[Burnedice25]

2 minutes ago, mahyar said:

lets be honest a 10900k is still a powerful cpu

not counting 11th gen

thats what im thinking too, i have current gen AND next gen upgrade paths if i really wanted 

[nox_]

5 minutes ago, mahyar said:

lets be honest a 10900k is still a powerful cpu

not counting 11th gen

I never said it isn't, it is. AMD's upgrade path is better, but i5 also does better in gaming, so, different priorities for different people.

2 minutes ago, Burnedice25 said:

thats what im thinking too, i have current gen AND next gen upgrade paths if i really wanted 

Going AMD you are getting much more options to choose from, also cheaper motherboards that can run much higher end cpu's, if you want to upgrade Intel cpu you might need to upgrade your mb also.

[Deli]

37 minutes ago, WY6 said:

The R5 3600 can be anywhere from 5-20% faster in multi-core and single-core workloads, and anywhere from 40-60% faster than the i7 3770

That's a 3770 non-k. The 3600 can easily double the performance of 3770 in multi-core. I know because I have both.

[mahyar]

5 minutes ago, Burnedice25 said:

thats what im thinking too, i have current gen AND next gen upgrade paths if i really wanted 

so pick whatever you think is better 

lets summarize

10400/f is cheaper and better in gaming

3600 more expensive and more powerful and can overclock

so pick one that suits you 

[Burnedice25]

1 minute ago, Deli said:

That's a 3770 non-k. The 3600 can easily double the performance of 3770 in multi-core. I know because I have both.

I have a 3770 non - k

[Deli]

10 minutes ago, Burnedice25 said:

I have a 3770 non - k

Do you OC it to 4.1GHz all core?

[Burnedice25]

Just now, Deli said:

Do you OC it to 4.1GHz all core?

I'm using a pretty crappy dell MOBO (long story, got it for free tho) no its running fully stock

 

[Deli]

1 minute ago, Burnedice25 said:

I'm using a pretty crappy dell MOBO (long story, got it for free tho) no its running fully stock

 

You will be shocked how much more responsive and faster the 3600 compares to 3770 non-k.

 

Why don't you wait a while for the 5600 early next year?

[Burnedice25]

1 minute ago, Deli said:

You will be shocked how much more responsive and faster the 3600 compares to 3770 non-k.

 

Why don't you wait a while for the 5600 early next year?

Over the summer break (for me anyway here is aus, dec-jan) im planning on doing a lot of video editing and hobbyist work.... catching up on all my projects lol

with the double performence, is that true aswell in games? or  is that gpu bottlenecked anyway?

[mahyar]

1 minute ago, Burnedice25 said:

Over the summer break (for me anyway here is aus, dec-jan) im planning on doing a lot of video editing and hobbyist work.... catching up on all my projects lol

with the double performence, is that true aswell in games? or  is that gpu bottlenecked anyway?

what gpu

[Burnedice25]

1 minute ago, mahyar said:

what gpu

GTX 1070ti, heavily overclocked running at 1440p 144hz

Also, i dont generally play below high or ultra on anything

[Deli]

1 minute ago, Burnedice25 said:

Over the summer break (for me anyway here is aus, dec-jan) im planning on doing a lot of video editing and hobbyist work.... catching up on all my projects lol

with the double performence, is that true aswell in games? or  is that gpu bottlenecked anyway?

In games less so. More like 20-30% faster.

 

Depends on resolution. If you plan to stick with 1080p, RTX3070 will be plenty. If you want 1440p or 4K, and have the budget, then RTX3080. No worry of bottlenecking with a fast six core 3600 or 5600 in games.

[mahyar]

Just now, Burnedice25 said:

GTX 1070ti, heavily overclocked running at 1440p 144hz

Also, i dont generally play below high or ultra on anything

a 30% improvement is expected with a modern 6c/12t

like 10400f or 3600

[Burnedice25]

Just now, Deli said:

In games less so. More like 20-30% faster.

 

Depends on resolution. If you plan to stick with 1080p, RTX3070 will be plenty. If you want 1440p or 4K, and have the budget, then RTX3080. No worry of bottlenecking with a fast six core 3600 or 5600 in games.

again, i play at 1440p

Also, as ive said, no matter what its gonna be GPU bottleneck, so the slight perfromence difference the 3600 has is useless as my gpu will hold it back

[Deli]

Just now, Burnedice25 said:

GTX 1070ti, heavily overclocked running at 1440p 144hz

Also, i dont generally play below high or ultra on anything

I would be comfortable even with a RTX3080 for 1440p with a 3600. Your 1070Ti will be piece of cake.