[EOL] PSU Tier List rev. 14.8

[MrBrightSyde]

13 minutes ago, Cholosniper said:

https://www.amazon.es/dp/B06W9G6H11/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_apa_i_WQFCK0MGWHWAMY12J572

This one is txm placed on tier a? I ask for the fact that in the list says 2017, so Idk if only the psu frabricated in 2017 are on this place

Yes it's Tier A. No, the 2017 doesn't mean they were only fabricated in 2017, that is just when they started selling (i think). The TXM is still in production. The reason for the 2017 is to differentiate it from the old TX-m Bronze from 2011, and the other old TX models from 2007-2011.

[boghubodaghi]

46 minutes ago, rcarlos243 said:

Is it incompatible due to a flaw in the Seasonic design?

Since you have many reports on Prime/Prime Ultra shut downs, it is supposedly caused by a flaw in the design of the protection system. 

46 minutes ago, rcarlos243 said:

Then if that is true why is it still on the recommendation list?

I'm not entirely sure about that, maybe @Juular can explain it better. I could try to answer though, unlike the Seasonic Focus issue, it's hapenning less frequently and Seasonic has yet to make an official statement.

1 hour ago, rcarlos243 said:

So far it looks like the Corsair HX/HXi fits the bill.

I am also looking at the Seasonic Focus PX 750w, but worried it might have the same issue.

 

If you can get the HX, get the HX. It's better built and performs better than the Focus PX. Also Seasonic said that the newer released PX has fixes on high transient GPUs, so you are not likely to run in the same issue.

 

But in my opinion, you can ask Seasonic for a replacement rather than buying a new one. Seasonic should provide you with a PSU that has the problem fixed.

[rcarlos243]

2 hours ago, boghubodaghi said:

Since you have many reports on Prime/Prime Ultra shut downs, it is supposedly caused by a flaw in the design of the protection system. 

I'm not entirely sure about that, maybe @Juular can explain it better. I could try to answer though, unlike the Seasonic Focus issue, it's hapenning less frequently and Seasonic has yet to make an official statement.

If you can get the HX, get the HX. It's better built and performs better than the Focus PX. Also Seasonic said that the newer released PX has fixes on high transient GPUs, so you are not likely to run in the same issue.

 

But in my opinion, you can ask Seasonic for a replacement rather than buying a new one. Seasonic should provide you with a PSU that has the problem fixed.

 

I bought my Seasonic Prime 2nd hand so I can't get RMA.

 

I see B&H has the Seasonic Prime Ultra 750W Titanium in stock at $200.

 

Should I buy a new one (might be a newer revision) or will it have the same issue?

 

Is there any better 80Plus Titanium 750W PSU than the Seasonic Prime at similar price?

[Guest]

10 hours ago, boghubodaghi said:

I believe there is a lot of reported cases of Prime/Prime Ultra Titanium tripping when using a high transient GPU.

Correct.  Even the Seasonic made Corsair AX850 has this issue.

 

But it's not from power spikes.  The problem is noise introduced from the card feeding back into the +12V sense line.  This makes the supervisor IC freak out and shut down the PSU.

[electropical]

2 hours ago, jonnyGURU said:

Correct.  Even the Seasonic made Corsair AX850 has this issue.

 

But it's not from power spikes.  The problem is noise introduced from the card feeding back into the +12V sense line.  This makes the supervisor IC freak out and shut down the PSU.

Since it is not caused by power spikes, does this mean the AX1000 is also subject to the same tripping issues with 3080s and 3090s?

(I know someone that just bought one of these for future-proofing)

[Guest]

3 minutes ago, electropical said:

Since it is not caused by power spikes, does this mean the AX1000 is also subject to the same tripping issues with 3080s and 3090s?

(I know someone that just bought one of these for future-proofing)

I haven't seen it with the 1000W.

[boghubodaghi]

11 hours ago, jonnyGURU said:

Correct.  Even the Seasonic made Corsair AX850 has this issue.

 

But it's not from power spikes.  The problem is noise introduced from the card feeding back into the +12V sense line.  This makes the supervisor IC freak out and shut down the PSU.

Got it. I have a question for you though. How does this relate into high transience? Shouldn't lower power consuming cards experience the same issue if it's caused by the +12V sense?

 

13 hours ago, rcarlos243 said:

 

I bought my Seasonic Prime 2nd hand so I can't get RMA.

 

I see B&H has the Seasonic Prime Ultra 750W Titanium in stock at $200.

 

Should I buy a new one (might be a newer revision) or will it have the same issue?

 

Is there any better 80Plus Titanium 750W PSU than the Seasonic Prime at similar price?

If I were you I'd pick up a HX 750 instead. It's only platinum but its performance can rival the Prime Titanium, if not better. It can be found at prices similar to the prime, if not cheaper. But if you still insists on having to go with Titanium efficiency, then it's OK to buy the Prime Ultra. If you have problems then you can ask Seasonic for a replacement this time.

[DesMahaVailo]

On 2/12/2021 at 5:53 PM, Juular said:

Nothing to do with the PSU, it's a UEFI / RAM / CPU / IF stability thing.

So I did a LOT of testing (different RAM, different GPU, different PSU etc.). I always have the blue screen issue with varying frequency. I even tried my PC at a friends house and for 4 hours nothing happened. Exact same system, exact same testing, no issues. Tried at home again and a lot of blue screens. Tried with a 600w PSU and got blue screens instantely and couldn't even boot into windows most of the time. This leads me to believe PSU as I have an old house where maybe the signal is not as "clean" while at my friends house it is somehow better? (I am not a tech expert here)

So, my guess either my EVGA G2 650w is not enough for a 5800x and a 3080FE or my 5800x has some problems regarding voltage. I can either send it my 5800x and ask for a replacement or get a better PSU. The blue screens are even happening when I undervolt my 3080 (~80watts less). The only thing how I can stop it from happening is disabling CPB and PBO (auto boosting of CPU) and leave it at stock 3.8GHz.
What do you think? PSU or CPU?

 

I am considering buying a new PSU anyway and have 2 options now

Corsair RM850x for about 160 Euros

 

Thermaltake GF1 ARGB 850w for 215 Euros (with 150 credits for the shop)

When reading the first post it says Corsair RMx is good but only the white version? Is this correct? Should I go for the Corsair RM850x in white?

[Schrotty]

Which 850w power supply is currently the quietest and also works without problems with a RTX 3080 / 3090? Its better to use a Multi oder Singel Rail?

[Skiiwee29]

2 hours ago, DesMahaVailo said:

So I did a LOT of testing (different RAM, different GPU, different PSU etc.). I always have the blue screen issue with varying frequency. I even tried my PC at a friends house and for 4 hours nothing happened. Exact same system, exact same testing, no issues. Tried at home again and a lot of blue screens. Tried with a 600w PSU and got blue screens instantely and couldn't even boot into windows most of the time. This leads me to believe PSU as I have an old house where maybe the signal is not as "clean" while at my friends house it is somehow better? (I am not a tech expert here)

So, my guess either my EVGA G2 650w is not enough for a 5800x and a 3080FE or my 5800x has some problems regarding voltage. I can either send it my 5800x and ask for a replacement or get a better PSU. The blue screens are even happening when I undervolt my 3080 (~80watts less). The only thing how I can stop it from happening is disabling CPB and PBO (auto boosting of CPU) and leave it at stock 3.8GHz.
What do you think? PSU or CPU?

 

I am considering buying a new PSU anyway and have 2 options now

Corsair RM850x for about 160 Euros

 

Thermaltake GF1 ARGB 850w for 215 Euros (with 150 credits for the shop)

When reading the first post it says Corsair RMx is good but only the white version? Is this correct? Should I go for the Corsair RM850x in white?

yea, 650w is now here near enough for a 3080 card.. I would upgrade to an 850w minimum. Personally, I avoid anything and everything Thermaltake so I wouldn't personally recommend it. 

[Spike_Spiegel]

3 hours ago, DesMahaVailo said:

So I did a LOT of testing (different RAM, different GPU, different PSU etc.). I always have the blue screen issue with varying frequency. I even tried my PC at a friends house and for 4 hours nothing happened. Exact same system, exact same testing, no issues. Tried at home again and a lot of blue screens. Tried with a 600w PSU and got blue screens instantely and couldn't even boot into windows most of the time. This leads me to believe PSU as I have an old house where maybe the signal is not as "clean" while at my friends house it is somehow better? (I am not a tech expert here)

So, my guess either my EVGA G2 650w is not enough for a 5800x and a 3080FE or my 5800x has some problems regarding voltage. I can either send it my 5800x and ask for a replacement or get a better PSU. The blue screens are even happening when I undervolt my 3080 (~80watts less). The only thing how I can stop it from happening is disabling CPB and PBO (auto boosting of CPU) and leave it at stock 3.8GHz.
What do you think? PSU or CPU?

 

I am considering buying a new PSU anyway and have 2 options now

Corsair RM850x for about 160 Euros

 

Thermaltake GF1 ARGB 850w for 215 Euros (with 150 credits for the shop)

When reading the first post it says Corsair RMx is good but only the white version? Is this correct? Should I go for the Corsair RM850x in white?

If you have a friend with a 850w PSU try it out with his... 
The RM850x is still available in MM and it's fairly cheaper (I've already suggested that one with the voucher, since we're in the same country )
The white version has "better" (cables) but it's not so tight when it comes to working within the specs vs the RM850x - if I can remember correctly, but it's nothing too dramatic

Btw the WHEA errors you've been getting (which was in your previous post), as stated on the hardwareluxxx forum it has to do with faulty CPUs and nothing can help it unless you RMA it. The RMA is fairly fast and AMD responds on emails fairly fast, in matter of hours, many users have confirmed this on that forums, which is apparently and issue since the Ryzen 3000 series and certain batch of procesors (same goes for 5000).
AMD know us about this and is keeping it quiet for now (same thing with Corsair and their problematic batches of CX line in Brazil), until it gets covers by media and it blows up.

Hopefully  Gerow won't slap me again for this post and he'll see the question about the HX vs RMx post ...

[DesMahaVailo]

9 minutes ago, Spike_Spiegel said:

If you have a friend with a 850w PSU try it out with his...

Btw the WHEA errors you've been getting (which was in your previous post), as stated on the hardwareluxxx forum it has to do with faulty CPUs and nothing can help it unless you RMA it. The RMA is fairly fast and AMD responds on emails fairly fast, in matter of hours, many users have confirmed this on that forums, which is apparently and issue since the Ryzen 3000 series and certain batch of procesors (same goes for 5000).
AMD know us about this and is keeping it quiet for now (same thing with Corsair and their problematic batches of CX line in Brazil), until it gets covers by media and it blows up.

I know about these and have been trying to test for them as well, but using my old graphics card (gtx 680) I could never get these to appear with the exact same system.

[Guest]

11 hours ago, boghubodaghi said:

Got it. I have a question for you though. How does this relate into high transience? Shouldn't lower power consuming cards experience the same issue if it's caused by the +12V sense?

It's actually two different issues... but the same.   Different PSUs have different issues.  We can't just lump all PSUs into "doesn't work with Ampere" and assume it's the same reason. 

 

And the issue with the Seasonic is limited to the EVGA FTW and FE cards only.  

 

Either the PSU has enough capacitance on the secondary side to absorb the transient spikes, or the PSU has enough capacitance on the secondary side to absorb the noise.

 

I've found by cutting the +12V sense on the Seasonic, the Seasonic works.  I've also found that using a motherboard that has auxiliary PCIe power to the board (like the Gigabyte "Designare" boards) will prevent shut down.  I've yet to try the old school trick of winding the +12V sense around a ground wire.  I've been out of the office this past week.

 

[Ankerson]

I saw SEASONIC is releasing it's Prime TX 1600 here soon/

[Guest]

On 2/15/2021 at 10:53 AM, jonnyGURU said:

It's actually two different issues... but the same.   Different PSUs have different issues.  We can't just lump all PSUs into "doesn't work with Ampere" and assume it's the same reason. 

 

And the issue with the Seasonic is limited to the EVGA FTW and FE cards only.  

 

Either the PSU has enough capacitance on the secondary side to absorb the transient spikes, or the PSU has enough capacitance on the secondary side to absorb the noise.

 

I've found by cutting the +12V sense on the Seasonic, the Seasonic works.  I've also found that using a motherboard that has auxiliary PCIe power to the board (like the Gigabyte "Designare" boards) will prevent shut down.  I've yet to try the old school trick of winding the +12V sense around a ground wire.  I've been out of the office this past week.

 

Update:  Twisting the +12V sense with a ground wire did not help.  The only thing that solves the problem is removing the +12V sense wire completely from the 24-pin cable.  

 

[LukeSavenije]

16 hours ago, Ankerson said:

I saw SEASONIC is releasing it's Prime TX 1600 here soon/

hm... I've seen them show off a prototype before in I think 2019@computex

 

took them a decent while

[Ankerson]

1 minute ago, LukeSavenije said:

hm... I've seen them show off a prototype before in I think 2019@computex

 

took them a decent while

 

I suppose we will see once someone reviews one of them.

 

 

[Guest]

6 hours ago, LukeSavenije said:

hm... I've seen them show off a prototype before in I think 2019@computex

 

took them a decent while

Learning curve.

[StillNvidia680]

Quick question for y'all, Corsair RM850X vs Seasonic GX850 Focus at same price for a 5900x / 3070?  Been going back and forth, Corsair apparently runs quieter and fanless more often, but when looking at comparisons of the brands or others discussing these models, the suggestions are either that both are comparable and to go with the cheaper one, or suggest picking Seasonic as they only make PSUs and are generally a better company to deal with.  Any experience/input or reasons you'd go with one over the other? 

[Ankerson]

3 hours ago, jonnyGURU said:

Learning curve.

 

I heard it was going to cost a lot too.

 

Like a grand. 

[seon123]

2 hours ago, StillNvidia680 said:

the suggestions are either that both are comparable and to go with the cheaper one

For completely deaf people that only use older and/or lower end GPUs, and have very little room for PSU length, sure.

2 hours ago, StillNvidia680 said:

or suggest picking Seasonic as they only make PSUs and are generally a better company to deal with. 

Those people are obviously talking out of their asses.

 

 

At the same price, I would choose the RMx. Compared to the Focus GX, it's quieter (and uses a fan that's not crap), is easier to find custom cables for, doesn't have issues with higher end GPUs, and doesn't have known soldering quality issues.

[CY078]

Does anyone know where the Deepcool DQ-M-V2L sits ?

 

the DQ-M is in tier A, but notes the V2L is not part of it, but then doesn’t mention it again
 

Also does anyone have feedback on MSI MPQ A850GA ?

[Elisis]

 

5 hours ago, StillNvidia680 said:

as they only make PSUs

So did Diablotek, for the most part. Just because you do only one thing doesn't mean you're the best at that thing.

[StillNvidia680]

4 hours ago, seon123 said:

For completely deaf people that only use older and/or lower end GPUs, and have very little room for PSU length, sure.

Those people are obviously talking out of their asses.

 

 

At the same price, I would choose the RMx. Compared to the Focus GX, it's quieter (and uses a fan that's not crap), is easier to find custom cables for, doesn't have issues with higher end GPUs, and doesn't have known soldering quality issues.

Fair enough aye, I saw the RMx also looks like one of the top recommendations based on this tier list too so I went for it, more readily available too in case I need to RMA for it being DOA or something, super paranoid about that haha but hoping it all goes smooth!  Appreciate the advice!

1 hour ago, Elisis said:

 

So did Diablotek, for the most part. Just because you do only one thing doesn't mean you're the best at that thing.

And that is a fair point as well haha I get ya, I'm sure I'll be happy in the end with the Corsair!

[electropical]

4 hours ago, CY078 said:

Does anyone know where the Deepcool DQ-M-V2L sits ?

 

the DQ-M is in tier A, but notes the V2L is not part of it, but then doesn’t mention it again

Tier C, low priority units - minor issues or lack of info

 

4 hours ago, CY078 said:

Also does anyone have feedback on MSI MPQ A850GA ?

As far as I know, there is no such thing as the MSI MPQ A850GA.

 

The MSI MPG A850GF is under :

Tier A, low priority units - minor issues or lack of info