Port forwarding issues

[Cookiecrumbles222]

1 minute ago, xCykrix said:

Alright. Try closing the server (with "stop") and recreating the rule under Inbound Rules. Then starting the server and checking. Also worth noting since I forgot about this. But what level firewall is your Xfinity router set on?

secrity is low i dont think the rules are the problem becaus ei can host the server with hamachi and havee no problems, its a problem with my router because the tester just test if the port is open to other computers and it says it still closed (this sight http://www.yougetsignal.com/tools/open-ports/)

 

[xCykrix]

Just now, Cookiecrumbles222 said:

secrity is low i dont think the rules are the problem becaus ei can host the server with hamachi and havee no problems, its a problem with my router because the tester just test if the port is open to other computers and it says it still closed (this sight http://www.yougetsignal.com/tools/open-ports/)

 

Alright. Could you screenshot your list of inbound rules for me perhaps? Make sure there is nothing odd that stands out. Firewalls are finniky. If you really don't care you could try disabling both your router and computer firewall, however that can heavily compromise security on your network.

[Cookiecrumbles222]

1 minute ago, xCykrix said:

Alright. Could you screenshot your list of inbound rules for me perhaps? Make sure there is nothing odd that stands out. Firewalls are finniky. If you really don't care you could try disabling both your router and computer firewall, however that can heavily compromise security on your network.

I've already made sure that port works with security because I've had people connect to my server with hamachi and i made this rule a long time ago i just refreshed it to make sure it worked and it did, the problem is my port forward isn't port forwarding and I don't know how to fix it.

[xCykrix]

Just now, Cookiecrumbles222 said:

I've already made sure that port works with security because I've had people connect to my server with hamachi and i made this rule a long time ago i just refreshed it to make sure it worked and it did, the problem is my port forward isn't port forwarding and I don't know how to fix it.

Hamachi doesn't handle it the same way as a regular port. Your machine (as it appears) is dropping the request when it reaches you. Your port forwarding is identical to mine but I had to delete rules that conflicted before mine showed as open. Unless your modem is blocking the ports (since your on xfinity I would assume its their integrated one) then it would have to be your host machine.

There is also the chance that hamachi is conflicting with the machine. It's not a very nice software for handing stuff over and networking. Which is why its looked down upon for any hosting.

[Cookiecrumbles222]

Just now, xCykrix said:

Hamachi doesn't handle it the same way as a regular port. Your machine (as it appears) is dropping the request when it reaches you. Your port forwarding is identical to mine but I had to delete rules that conflicted before mine showed as open. Unless your modem is blocking the ports (since your on xfinity I would assume its their integrated one) then it would have to be your host machine.

There is also the chance that hamachi is conflicting with the machine. It's not a very nice software for handing stuff over and networking. Which is why its looked down upon for any hosting.

could hamachi be my issue?

[xCykrix]

Just now, Cookiecrumbles222 said:

could hamachi be my issue?

Possibly, it adds virtual networking drivers and virtual adapters which could be interrupting requests.

[Cookiecrumbles222]

Just now, xCykrix said:

Possibly, it adds virtual networking drivers and virtual adapters which could be interrupting requests.

if i uninstall it will that remove all of it (through control pannel uninstall)

 

[xCykrix]

Just now, Cookiecrumbles222 said:

if i uninstall it will that remove all of it

 

As long as you use their uninstaller (should be included) then yes. It will remove all of those. However just to make sure I would still recommend screenshotting your Inbound Firewall Rules just so I can look. If its blocking a port in another task it wont run properly.

[Cookiecrumbles222]

3 minutes ago, xCykrix said:

As long as you use their uninstaller (should be included) then yes. It will remove all of those. However just to make sure I would still recommend screenshotting your Inbound Firewall Rules just so I can look. If its blocking a port in another task it wont run properly.

https://gyazo.com/b2babfeeb4c2e9ca1539e3b02dcec9ac

 

https://gyazo.com/0c0645df132237ff5081df6a41b0aafe

 

https://gyazo.com/6614059738d5c9dd3682d3b08bda0ba6

 

 those were the only ones that looked weird

if i turn off windows fire wall does it make it so i dont have to worry about this?

[xCykrix]

1 minute ago, Cookiecrumbles222 said:

https://gyazo.com/b2babfeeb4c2e9ca1539e3b02dcec9ac

 

https://gyazo.com/0c0645df132237ff5081df6a41b0aafe

 

https://gyazo.com/6614059738d5c9dd3682d3b08bda0ba6

 

 those were the only ones that looked weird

if i turn off windows fire wall does it make it so i dont have to worry about this?

That would be my last ditch attempt, but yes. You could try turning off both public and private Firewalls.

[Cookiecrumbles222]

32 minutes ago, xCykrix said:

That would be my last ditch attempt, but yes. You could try turning off both public and private Firewalls.

-removed-

[xCykrix]

2 minutes ago, Cookiecrumbles222 said:

they have been off this entire time and we have been haveing these errors

Then I would assume Hamachi is the cause if they are fully disabled.

[Cookiecrumbles222]

Just now, xCykrix said:

Then I would assume Hamachi is the cause if they are fully disabled.

if I uninstall it and it still doesn't work what do I try then?

[xCykrix]

Just now, Cookiecrumbles222 said:

if I uninstall it and it still doesn't work what do I try then?

Good ol' restart first of all. If not just quote me and we can try to find an alternate solution.

[Cookiecrumbles222]

1 minute ago, xCykrix said:

Good ol' restart first of all. If not just quote me and we can try to find an alternate solution.

kk, i'm waiting tell my friend to get off in 30 mins then ill try again thanks so much for all the help!

[Cookiecrumbles222]

49 minutes ago, xCykrix said:

Good ol' restart first of all. If not just quote me and we can try to find an alternate solution.

I deleted hamachi and it still didn't work do any of these settings have to do with it

[xCykrix]

Just now, Cookiecrumbles222 said:

I deleted hamachi and it still didn't work do any of these settings have to do with it

Are you 100% sure your firewall is fully disabled? Not parts.

Also check your `Network and Sharing Center > Change Adapter Settings` and make sure nothing but your hardware is listed.

[Cookiecrumbles222]

2 minutes ago, xCykrix said:

Are you 100% sure your firewall is fully disabled? Not parts.

Also check your `Network and Sharing Center > Change Adapter Settings` and make sure nothing but your hardware is listed.

https://gyazo.com/e75526b1a9913cf67620ffe268bcbf1c

https://gyazo.com/16dcd128eac780890e981d76a645564a

https://gyazo.com/a11595e1225b4dbbb4d83ebba116caba

 

[xCykrix]

Just now, Cookiecrumbles222 said:

https://gyazo.com/e75526b1a9913cf67620ffe268bcbf1c

https://gyazo.com/16dcd128eac780890e981d76a645564a

https://gyazo.com/a11595e1225b4dbbb4d83ebba116caba

 

Try opening your Network and Sharing Center and where it says "View your active networks". Does that say Public, Work, or Home Network? (Under your ethernet connection.)

[Cookiecrumbles222]

2 minutes ago, xCykrix said:

Try opening your Network and Sharing Center and where it says "View your active networks". Does that say Public, Work, or Home Network? (Under your ethernet connection.)

https://gyazo.com/fa1eee66e61beff376262526e6491169

[xCykrix]

Just now, Cookiecrumbles222 said:

https://gyazo.com/fa1eee66e61beff376262526e6491169

It being set as public could be why. Windows by default (even without firewall) restrictions functionality on a public network. Try removing any networks in "Manage Wireless Connections" (I think that would include Ethernet), Unplugging and plugging it back in. If that does not allow you to select the type of network you can follow this thread's solution https://social.technet.microsoft.com/Forums/en-US/f1c3040e-ec3d-40b2-9cc8-35f6e2a4e48e/changing-network-from-public-to-private-for-ethernet-connection?forum=WinPreview2014Setup

The solution uses powershell to forcefully change the type to private and will likely require a restart after.

[Cookiecrumbles222]

7 minutes ago, xCykrix said:

It being set as public could be why. Windows by default (even without firewall) restrictions functionality on a public network. Try removing any networks in "Manage Wireless Connections" (I think that would include Ethernet), Unplugging and plugging it back in. If that does not allow you to select the type of network you can follow this thread's solution https://social.technet.microsoft.com/Forums/en-US/f1c3040e-ec3d-40b2-9cc8-35f6e2a4e48e/changing-network-from-public-to-private-for-ethernet-connection?forum=WinPreview2014Setup

The solution uses powershell to forcefully change the type to private and will likely require a restart after.

nvm found it

[Cookiecrumbles222]

8 minutes ago, xCykrix said:

It being set as public could be why. Windows by default (even without firewall) restrictions functionality on a public network. Try removing any networks in "Manage Wireless Connections" (I think that would include Ethernet), Unplugging and plugging it back in. If that does not allow you to select the type of network you can follow this thread's solution https://social.technet.microsoft.com/Forums/en-US/f1c3040e-ec3d-40b2-9cc8-35f6e2a4e48e/changing-network-from-public-to-private-for-ethernet-connection?forum=WinPreview2014Setup

The solution uses powershell to forcefully change the type to private and will likely require a restart after.

ok its private now what do i do

[xCykrix]

Just now, Cookiecrumbles222 said:

it says "Look at the interface index number of your ethernet connection." where do i find this?

I apologize, that was meant for Windows 10 based systems.

[Cookiecrumbles222]

Just now, xCykrix said:

I apologize, that was meant for Windows 10 based systems.

i am on windows 10