Jump to content

NFC S4 Mini #193 - "Acrylic Ant-Man" (4.4L = 7700k delidded & GTX 1080 mini)

CubanLegend

Preface: I'm sharing my build log from the SFF Forums, here on the LTT forums, welcomeing any feedback, suggestions, & constructive criticisms to better my build. :)

 

So I got my S4 Mini April 22nd, 2017, It's #193! The build is Code-named "Ant-Man" by Josh from NFC himself.
Here's an early pic of the build sent to me by Josh (check out the custom Frosted Acrylic Front Bezel), click it to see Josh's imgur of my S4-mini/1080mini:
32465338850_ed83e55462_c.jpg

 

---------------------------------------------
Build Intro, Goals & Challenges
---------------------------------------------
Build Intro: I've had the same Gaming PC based on an ASUS Crosshair Mobo from 2006, & an aging CPU/GPU, this Full-ATX PC lasted me 10 years, but no longer runs modern games at 1080p60fps or even 30fps. So, I recently came into some money & decided I was due for an upgrade... to an i7-7700k and a GTX 1080!!, but then, I watched a video by "Tek Everything" where I discovered Josh's "NFC S4 Mini Chassis", and I fell in love, and it became the catalyst for making a 7700k and a GTX 1080 mini fit into my SFF build idea.

 

Goal/Use of my build: On top of using this PC at home and taking it to friend's houses for game/movie nights. I also take this build to work everyday and game during my lunch breaks, so I required: A no-compromise PORTABLE 4K gaming/4K media PC (w/ 4K UHD Bluray drive support). I wanted this build to use "the fastest performing parts, be quiet, be portable, and be wrapped in luxury" to paraphrase Josh's description of this build. I use this build for all my 1080p gaming on my Optoma GT1080 projector (most games I supersample to 4K using Nvidias DSR), (and for 4K gaming on my 4K tv) while I wait for 4K projectors to become more affordable. I also plan to hook up an external UHD/4K Bluray player once they're available, to enjoy my 4K Bluray Collection on from my PC on my 4K TV once I can rip my 4K UHD Blurays to take them along with me & this PC!

 

Challenges: At first, NO GTX 1080 could fit inside the S4 mini until the ZOTAC 1080 mini was released, but even then no one had tried to fit it into the S4 mini yet (with the front panel in place)... ;) So I volunteered & sent Josh my 1080mini so he could test fit & mod it to fit into my S4 mini. He ended up having to shave a bit off the card's plastic shroud and he cut me a custom Acrylic Front Bezel (2D/non-wrap around) that he frosted beautifully for extra GPU fan clearance, so that we wouldn't have to mod the stock fans/heatsink on the 1080 mini. AND IT WORKED! :D


So although my 1080mini was modded to fit inside the S4-mini with a custom 5mm Acrylic Bezel: Going forward, all future S4 Mini customers (batch #3 and forward) will be able to purchase an alternate 7mm Front Bezel from Josh's S4 Mini site/shop page... that will allow fitment of the ZOTAC 1080 mini in the S4 Mini without ANY modding of the GPU. :D


---------------------------------------------------------
PCPartPicker part list & Price Breakdown
---------------------------------------------------------

Spoiler

 

PCPartPicker part list / Price breakdown by merchant

CPU: Intel Core i7-7700K 4.2GHz Quad-Core Processor  (Purchased For $350.00)
CPU Cooler: Thermolab LP53 (Purchased for $56.00)
Motherboard: Asus ROG STRIX Z270i GAMING - Mini ITX LGA1151  (Purchased For $180.00)
Memory: CORSAIR Vengeance LPX 16GB (2 x 8GB) DDR4-4000  (Purchased For $193.00)
Storage: Intel 600p Series 256GB M.2-2280 Solid State Drive  (Purchased For $92.00)
Storage: Seagate BarraCuda 5TB 2.5" 5400RPM Internal Hard Drive  (Purchased For $179.00)
Storage: Seagate FireCuda Gaming SSHD 2TB 2.5" Internal Hard Drive (Purchased For $114.99)
Video Card:Zotac GTX 1080 MINI 8GB (ZT-P10800H-10P) (Purchased For $720.00)
Case:NFC S4 Mini Chassis (Purchased For $155.00)
Case: NFC S4 Mini Flat Frosted Acrylic Front-Bezel w/Dinox Vent Plate & Logo (Purchased For $72)
Case: Aluminum Vandal Switch (Sleeved, Black, Non-LED)  (Purchased For $20.00)
Case: Aluminum Vandal Switch (Sleeved, Black, white LED)  (Purchased For $20.00)
Case: NFC-SYSTEM HDPLEX Wire Mod (Black) (Purchased For $75.00)
Power Supply: [/B]Dell 330W DA330PM111 AC Adapter charger  (Purchased For $104.00)
Power Brick: HDPLEX 300W Hi-Fi DC-ATX Power Supply  (Purchased For $85.00)
Operating System: Microsoft Windows 10 Home OEM 64-bit  (Purchased For $25.00)

Delid Parts:
De-Lid Kit: Rockit 88 - Intel CPU Delid Tool (Purchased For $30.00)
Re-Lid Kit: Re-Lid Kit for the Rockit 88 Delid Tool - 1150 Version (Purchased For $16.00)
CPU Delid TIM: Coollaboratory Liquid Ultra 0.15g Thermal Paste  (Purchased For $13.00)
CPU Delid Cleaner: ARCTIC SILVER CAN-60ML ARCTICLEAN 1 & 2 60ML SET  (Purchased For $6.00)
CPU Delid Sealant: Permatex 81158 Black Silicone Adhesive Sealant, 3 oz. Tube  (Purchased For $6.00)

Extra Parts/Accessories (unused in final build):
2nd CPU Cooler: Zalman CNPS2X CPU Cooler  (Purchased For $26.00)
3rd CPU Cooler: Noctua NH-L9i 33.8 CFM CPU Cooler  (Purchased For $39.95)
2nd CPU Case Fan: Noctua SSO Bearing Fan Retail Cooling NF-B9 redux-1600 PWM (Purchased for $15.00)
Thermal Compound: Noctua NT-H1 3.5g Thermal Paste  (Purchased For $6.00)
CPU Cooler Fan : SY1012SL12H-PWM (Purchased For $10.00)
Case Fan (GPU bracket): SY1212SL12H-PWM (Purchased For $10.00)
Extra Case Fan: Rosewill RASF-141213 54.5 CFM  120mm Fan  (Purchased For $13.00)
Extra Case Fan: Rosewill RASF-141213 54.5 CFM  120mm Fan  (Purchased For $13.00)
GPU Fan Adapter: Gelid CA-PWM-02 PWM Fan Adapter Sleeved Cable Cord for VGA Cards Cooler Fan (Purchased For $7.00)
GPU Fan Adapter: 4-Pin Mini GPU Connector Extension Cable (10cm) (Purchased For $14.00)
Case GPU Hole Cover: CaseLabs Flex-Bay Cover, Single Bay, Ventilated, Black (Purchased For $18.00)

Assembly Parts:
USB 3.0 Internal Header cable: RAYSUN Dual 2 Port USB 3.0 A Type Female to 20 Pin Box Header Cable (Purchased for $10.00)
Tape: Duck Brand 299006 3/4-Inch by 60 Feet Utility Vinyl Electrical Tape with Single Roll, Black  (Purchased For $4.50)
Tape: LCDGlue - 12mm Clear Double Sided Adhesive PET Tape - Red Backing - Very High Bond  (Purchased For $12.00)
Tape:  Gaffer Tape (Premium Grade - Black) - 2 Inch X 30 Yards (Purchased For $17.00)
Black Vinyl Spray: VHT SP942 Vinyl Dye Black Satin Can - 11 oz.  (Purchased For $13.00)

 

 

Total: $2749.37 (ouch) I intended to max my costs at $2300, lol
Prices include shipping, taxes, and discounts when available
Generated by PCPartPicker 2017-02-06 20:32 EST-0500


-----------
MEDIA:

-----------
Below are Josh's Twitter 1080mini video preview of my 1080 mini that I sent him to mod/review , and his youtube'd S4 Mini & 1080mini Fitment Project video for my build, & his imgur photo album of his project to fit my 1080mini into the NFC S4 mini chassis

Spoiler

Here's Josh's preview video of the ZOTAC 1080mini:

ZfzdPaIst0chxiTq.jpg

 

And here's Josh's longer video on how he fitted my 1080mini into my S4 mini (completed successfully with some creative cutting of the 1080's plastic shroud and using a new, custom, front-bezel made out of Frosted Acrylic!): 

 

Josh's 1080mini & S4 Mini Glamour Shots Imgur Album:

 


------------------------------------------------------
Build Thread - TABLE OF CONTENTS
------------------------------------------------------
STAGE1: Pre-S4-Mini "Open Test-Bench Testing": 

 

STAGE2: S4-Mini Chassis "Build/Fitment" Progress, Final Pics:

 

STAGE3: Pre&Post CPU Delid Temp Testing

-------------------------------
Performance RESULTS
-------------------------------
Temps:(CPU Cooling used: Themolab LP53 & NF-A9-14xPWM)

  • CPU: 4.5GHz, 35/36c idle, 70-78c +/- while gaming
  • GPU: +200 Core (~2080MHz w/GPUBoost3) & +1GHZ Memory (11GHz effective) 120% power target, 35c idle, max 72c gaming

 Benchmarks Setup:

  • i7-7700k stock we/Turboboost @ 4.5GHz & XMP 2x8GB DDR4-4000Mhz
  • ZOTAC 1080mini (if OC'ed: 120% power target, +200MHz Core & 11GBps Memory) average 2080Mhz Core w/GPUboost3)

3DMark Timespy Scores:

3DMark Firestrike Scores:

---------------------
Conclusion:
---------------------
All in all, all the parts and accessories I ended up buying & the price premiums I paid on a few parts for buying them early-on, added up to a little bit more than I expected to pay originally (originally aimed at $2300 total using a GTX1070)... but for a build that I plan to keep for 10 years... Let's hope it's enough with a 1080!

 

Thank you!: Thank you, to the LTT Community for any feedback you give me. And thanks to everyone in the S4 Mini thread over on the SFF forums, for helping me with finding custom parts and gathering ideas for this build. Thank you to Josh of NFC, for his infinite creativity, hard work, dedication, and skills with building and modding custom SFF Computer Cases that double as works of art in my book! Josh's communication during the process of this custom build was very quick and he was very upfront and thorough regarding all aspects of my build throughout the entire process, he was a pleasure to deal with in answering all my questions while offering practical options & solutions. :D 

2006-2016 PC: CM-Stacker 830v1, ASUS Crosshairv1, Phenom2 x4-940BE, Zalman CNPS-9700, 2x4GB DDR2-800, ASUS GTX-770-DCU2-OC, EVGA-G2 750W.
2017 PC: NFC S4 Mini #193: ASUS z270i STRIX, i7-7700K, Thermolab LP53 & NF-A9x14-PWM, 2x8GB DDR4-4000, ZOTAC GTX-1080 Mini, HDPLEX-300 DC-DC & Dell 330W AC-DC Power Brick PC-PartPicker
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Link to post
Share on other sites

Wow, looks gorgeous 

Want to custom loop?  Ask me more if you are curious

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Link to post
Share on other sites

Pre-S4-MINI Parts Testing Pics/Notes


These are pics of me receiving/modding and testing my parts outside of the S4 mini (which is recommended by Josh before putting anything into the chassis):

Spoiler

Rosewill 15x120 vs Scythe 12x120mm slim fans:
31899374613_27f7d965b0_k.jpg
32671844976_632f7b4a3c_k.jpg

Here's those two 120mm fans next to the scythe 12x100mm PWM slim fan too:

NOTE: The two Scythe fans had to be ordered from Scythe directly via email. they were $10 each, $20 total, shipped.
31869414794_b136950746_k.jpg


The caselabs cover i WAS going to use (didn't end up using it) to protect the 1080mini if i were to run the S4 without a front bezel and not mod the 1080mini and just let it hang outside the GPU cutout on the front panel of the case.
32671842026_07ac2031e9_k.jpg

The ASUS STRIX z270i GAMING mobo:
31988924413_4d0f344b86_k.jpg
32680006901_14522ffdd0_k.jpg
31988922553_80907db30f_k.jpg

i7-7700K (don't know if it's a golden batch # but it's a decent chip, lol):
32682155601_d84b45b625_k.jpg
32424723990_6bc0474613_k.jpg

Intel 600p 250GB M.2 SSD (size comparison next to the 7700K):
32764457186_07e0fd5a5d_k.jpg
here's the M.2 heatsink removed to install the 600p in the top m.2 slot:
32805199215_41c42942b6_k.jpg

NH-L9i and the stock fan it comes with the NF-A9x14PWM, the best performing slim 92mm fan (albeit it's a bit ugly with the beige and brown, IMO)

Extra note: Make sure you keep the dense neoprene stuff inside the box of the NH-L9i! it's SUPER USEFUL and it came in handy later when I was propping my 1080mini in place so the big GPU fan wouldn't hit the front bezel of the S4 mini.
31991149953_180cc02f84_k.jpg

Here's my Corsair DDR4-4000 kit (wasnt available in black so i decided to plastidip them black:
31991151283_133cb1edf6_k.jpg32682158331_bf9b856575_k.jpg
31991150813_57fc316b52_k.jpg32682157241_04b30ede04_k.jpg

31962398674_909af96856_k.jpg32764456266_fb32e64f6b_k.jpg32764454476_9ab2d49ca7_k.jpg32682137211_d02a5c260e_k.jpg

32682148791_eab42119b2_k.jpg
32764452886_896c8bc74d_k.jpg

RAM/CPU/M.2 all set and ready for the NH-L9i!
32682147171_6ef910149f_k.jpg
32682144571_ce7c5ef744_k.jpg31962393894_189b91c33b_k.jpg

Here's the NH-L9i orientation I used for best airflow and CPU cooling potential:
32682144031_8121d375aa_k.jpg

The scythe 12x100mm slim fan BARELY fit on top of the NHL9i, it pushed my RAM stick over a little bit... and it was WAY too loud and didn't cool as well as the stock NH-L9i's beige fan, so i didn't end up using it :( Kinda sucks because I custom ordered it directly from scythe and its a great fan. :(
32682142151_5fcf7b2cfe_k.jpg32651994262_ddd9bfd6c7_k.jpg

Putting it all together to test outside the S4 Mini to install windows onto the M.2, but my HDPLEX was being modded by Josh so i had to improvise... I borrowed the 24-pin power and 8-pin CPU power cables from my old PC and used sturdy cardboard to place my z270i in a "floating" position over the side panel of my old PC's Full-ATX case.
31962389954_05d251cff5_k.jpg

It worked! and i was able to install windows and run some CPU benchmarks. THEN i tested the "reinforced PCi-Ex slot" that ASUS marketed and it surprisingly worked, the ASUS GTX 770 I put on top didnt bend sideways at all. :)

For the open air testbench I was idling at about 36/37c at stock clocks, and at about 38/39 C with a 4.8Ghz OC w/XMP, that NH-L9i is a great little cooler if it has plenty of breathing room. :D
32846223665_9fc7caa980_k.jpg32003264164_8e5a50c468_k.jpg

Performance tests of the 7700K in that open-air test-bench went smoothly and performance was AMAZING even using my super-old GTX770 2GB card:
32003259704_7335328497_k.jpg

So the CPU was great at 4.8GHz 1.28vcore, and RAM was stable with the XMP @ 4000 MHz. BUT I was going to be waiting a while for the S4 chassis, 1080mini and HDPLEX to arrive... so i took some time to copy all my games and media over from my 3.5in drives of my old Full-tower to the new 2 2.5inch laptop drives I was going to install in the S4-mini SSD bracket.

I was able to boot into windows at 4.9/5.0 and 5.1GHz in the open-air testbench at 1.35vcore, but benchmarks all thermally throttled past 90c... So I'd have to wait for my delid to push this CPU past my stable 4.8GHz OC reliably, no problem... I can wait! >=)

So to copy everything I prepared to copy all my games from my current 2TB 3.5in drive to my 2TB 2.5in SSHD (7mm height), and I transferred all my media from my 5TB 3.5in drive to my new 5TB 2.5in drive (15mm height) using the following Dell 850W Server PSU testbench, and a USB 3.0 HDD dock to connect the bigger 3.5in drives to the tech-bench system:
32933251996_d51be93535_k.jpg

Everything copied over great, I moved all my save files, steam libraries, and Origin and Uplay games over without too many problems. It was a hassle in some cases where i HAD TO redownload parts of the games from Origin or uplay but I didnt have to redownload all of them. :)

 

My next post will detail receiving my HDPLEX-300 and ZOTAC 1080 mini, before I sent them off to Josh @ NFC to mod them.

2006-2016 PC: CM-Stacker 830v1, ASUS Crosshairv1, Phenom2 x4-940BE, Zalman CNPS-9700, 2x4GB DDR2-800, ASUS GTX-770-DCU2-OC, EVGA-G2 750W.
2017 PC: NFC S4 Mini #193: ASUS z270i STRIX, i7-7700K, Thermolab LP53 & NF-A9x14-PWM, 2x8GB DDR4-4000, ZOTAC GTX-1080 Mini, HDPLEX-300 DC-DC & Dell 330W AC-DC Power Brick PC-PartPicker
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Link to post
Share on other sites

Receiving my HDPLEX-300 DC-DC PSU and ZOTAC 1080 mini, before I sent them off to Josh @ NFC to mod them.
 

Spoiler

 


HDPLEX-300 DC-DC PSU:
Came VERY WELL PACKAGED and safe inside an anti-electrostatic bag.

BUT as you look below, Note how the 24-pin cable is SUPER long and threaded in multi colors EW...So I opted to send the HDPLEX to Josh so he could cut the wires to perfect length for use in the S4 mini and make them all black, and he would even cut a CUSTOM 2-inch 24-pin power cable in ALL BLACK. My S4 build post coming up will show how awesome and perfectly it fits in the S4, so I HIGHLY recommend you opt in to Josh's HDPLEX wire mod.

But for now lets look at the rest of the HDPLEX-300... notice how the DC-DC jack cable has some yellow wires, I want all my cables to be black so I took some of the Black vinyl dye i purchased, and wrapped the connectors of the DC-DC jack and painted it black. Protip: WEAR GLOVES xD

31409156213_65e4a41f9f_k.jpg

Here's me dying the yellow DC-Dc wires with black vinyl dye:
31379471044_c744fa4a68_k.jpg

And the result. with minimal overspray, it matches the other stock black wires nicely:
32182638436_337201ed46_k.jpg
31379467194_9ca5d5165c_k.jpg
32182633426_a3dc817f28_k.jpg


ZOTAC 1080mini:

I only had 1 hour with the card before I had to pack it and the HDPLEX to ship to Josh so i did a quick picture/size comparison and plugged it into my old Full-ATX build to make sure it wasnt DOA.

So on top of the pictures below I also did a brief unboxing video. and a brief look at the END of the 1080mini so Josh and others would get an idea as to how things looked on it, up close and from all angles. :)

 

 

here it is next to my Fuill-ATX build's ASUS GTX 770 and a 3.5in HDD.
32294074140_473e3bad50_k.jpg

Here's a close up of the rear of the card
31860896473_1d9246b4c3_k.jpg

And a shot of the card powered up in my Full-ZTX system to test it, all lit up w/ a nice white LED.
32632647536_ca25216d24_k.jpg

Then I quickly uninstalled the 1080mini, packaged it back into it's box and I jammed the HDPLEX-300 and all its wires into the 1080 mini's box and sent it off to Josh. :D
31860890973_1f0b8bb27b_k.jpg

 


 

OKAY so for real this time, My NEXT POST will detail me receiving the S4/HDPLEX/1080mini back from Josh and putting it all together. :)

2006-2016 PC: CM-Stacker 830v1, ASUS Crosshairv1, Phenom2 x4-940BE, Zalman CNPS-9700, 2x4GB DDR2-800, ASUS GTX-770-DCU2-OC, EVGA-G2 750W.
2017 PC: NFC S4 Mini #193: ASUS z270i STRIX, i7-7700K, Thermolab LP53 & NF-A9x14-PWM, 2x8GB DDR4-4000, ZOTAC GTX-1080 Mini, HDPLEX-300 DC-DC & Dell 330W AC-DC Power Brick PC-PartPicker
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Link to post
Share on other sites

S4-Mini Chassis Build Progress, Pics/Notes [PART 1 - "Building the PC"]:

 

So I received my S4 mini last wednesday. I sadly have no pictures of it's packaging sooo, I'll just write about it below: It was an a large box, the S4 mini was suspended nicely with styrofoam in the center of the box. The S4 mini was very carefully wrapped in super heavy seran-wrap style clear plastic wrap, very sturdy.  And on top of the centered mini was a small cardboard box fitted into the styrofoam which contained My HDPLEX and modded cables, and the S4's Riser, my alternate power button and the 120mm fan bracket. All well packaged and safely stored.  (Josh held onto my case's original black 5mm aluminum wrap-around bezel for later... when he has time to maybe cut over the front panel GPU vent and put a Dinoc vented cover on it to fit my 1080mini.) 

 

Spoiler

 

So Here's everything laid out on a table, and a closeup of both sides of the table (note the 7700k, the Intel 600p M.2 and the NH-L9i and my RAM were already installed on the motherboard, so the boxes for those components are displayed only for posterity):
32242120754_f8736860d6_k.jpg32960870071_e8f31a6d33_k.jpg32931571842_9c0173c982_k.jpg

My second power button (white LED) next to the S4 mini modded cables that Josh made, and the screws included:
32242120224_4086af3104_k.jpg

Fitting the 2TB 7mmm SSHD on the left, and the 5TB 15mm HHD on the right of the dual 2.5inch SSD bracket opposite my ZOTAC 1080mini against it's backplate:
32960869691_a961b532ce_k.jpg

The 2 HDDs sorta fit, so it's obvious I'll need to support the card better with some Neoprene from the NH-L9i's box so it worn't sag and so the big fan wont hit the front panel of the S4 when it spins:
32960869551_001ece459e_k.jpg

My black non-LED power button and my white LED power button. The non-LED one's button is shorter than the LED one, probably because it has no light wiring. But in the end I ended up using the white LED button. So I vinyl dyed it black:
33045884386_824dc5a372_k.jpg32242119634_89f0902bca_k.jpg33045888906_3a9e19e01b_k.jpg

And here is the White LED (with cabling dyed black) power button installed in the S4 on my z270i's power and power light pins. In retrospect I should have installed my HDPLEX300 onto my motherboard first, because the power button DID NOT make it possible to install the HDPLEX300 the "normal way".
32960869361_81d2566d72_k.jpg

Here's the New S4 Mini PCiEx riser installed. It was stored already pre-bent, so installation wasn't too hard. Method of installation was interesting: I plugged the dual-male plastic connector into the mobo end of the riser then I anchored the mobo end over the mobo connector as I forced the GPU end into the GPU, then I just pushed and straightened the mobo end into the mobo:
32242119244_cf02cdd544_k.jpg
33045888306_cc877518ad_k.jpg

HDPLEX-300 installation... so here's a doozy. So I had to detach the mobo from the case and I connected all the cables into the HDPLEX and the 24-pin onto the mobo, THEN. I pushed the mobo into place against the rear I/O as far as i could, and using the space left between the mobo and the front panel (which was VERY limited and i did have to squeeze the HDPLEX) I carefully, with some moderate pressure and cramming required, pushed the HDPLEX down and it wedged itself into the case against the front panel. I had put 2 strips of LCD glue on the back of the HDPLEX's back plate to mate it to the inner chassis of the front panel...in case I was going to mount it permanently. But i didnt need to stick it to the front panel at all, the cable mod that [USER=43]@Josh | NFC[/USER]  made for the HDPLEX was so perfect and snug that it sits perfectly against the front panel without any mounting. It's impossible to move it with all the cables plugged in. :D

So here's the HDPLEX300 after being plugged in, before I slid the mobo in and then crammed the HDPLEX into place:
33045883956_919699ebf5_k.jpg

And here is the HDPLEX300 wedged into place, it is super stylish and impossible to move, so I'm not worried about it at all.
32960868871_5a2e369d26_k.jpg

Here's the 2 SATA connectors I used for the HDDs, they were so snug but I was able to access and push the SATA cables in with the tip of an XACTO knife (also note the Power button's Power Switch and LED pins, pictured to the left SATA cables):
32960868861_70addfd7e9_k.jpg
The farthest HDD had a short cable so i got a longer one from the z270i's box and used it to hide it for better cable management and looks. :)
33045887786_ceccdfbe0a_k.jpg
32705623450_aeec845130_k.jpg

Also a NOTE: once the Mobo and HDPLEX were in place I only needed to screw the 2 mobo screws by the Rear I/O, the other 2 were inacessable to me due to the cabling of the HDPLEX (and because I dont have a magnetic screw driver, lol)
32960868681_c910e98464_k.jpg

So here's  a size comparison of the Dell 330W power brick, my ASUS GTX 770, the S4 mini, and my old Coolermaster CM Stacker 830 Full-ATX build:
33045883356_b7c3dc68e7_k.jpg
33045887116_07ebe840c5_k.jpg

Here it is powered up and running next to my OLD build... goodbye old friend. :,)
32705622720_30c17d627c_k.jpg

 

So my next post will cover the 2nd part of the Build process, fitments of all the parts. After that I will post some of the final build pics. And then After that I will post a little more about my temperature discoveries from working outside on an open-test bench to now working inside the S4 mini, both stock and OCed. :D

2006-2016 PC: CM-Stacker 830v1, ASUS Crosshairv1, Phenom2 x4-940BE, Zalman CNPS-9700, 2x4GB DDR2-800, ASUS GTX-770-DCU2-OC, EVGA-G2 750W.
2017 PC: NFC S4 Mini #193: ASUS z270i STRIX, i7-7700K, Thermolab LP53 & NF-A9x14-PWM, 2x8GB DDR4-4000, ZOTAC GTX-1080 Mini, HDPLEX-300 DC-DC & Dell 330W AC-DC Power Brick PC-PartPicker
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Link to post
Share on other sites

S4-Mini Chassis Build Progress, Pics/Notes [PART 2 - "Build Fitment"]:
So once I got everything in the build. I realized my 1080's big fan would graze against the S4 mini's inner chassis front bezel if my case was sitting horizontally, and would not graze it when sitting vertically. Hmmm... This was a problem, as I wanted to ensure no fan impact or fitment issues in either orientation. So I ran a test: when I removed the 15mm 2.5in HDD from the SSD bracket, this was resolved and the card didn't graze the inner chassis. BUT I really wanted to be able to have that 5TB drive in my system at all times without it causing problems. :(

So basically I had NO MORE ROOM inside the S4 and had to figure out what to do, I had to make some minor and creative fitment adjustments to get the GPU fan to not graze the case even with the FAT 15mm 2.5in 5TB HDD that was sitting on 1080's backplate, pushing the card OUT and causing the fan problem.

SO I REMEMBERED SOMETHING from Josh's "Teeny Tiny 1080 Build" Video @ 10:25 about some Neoprene that he used to secure the GPU from being pushed OUT like this. And I realized that I remember REMOVING that Neoprene peice earlier, thinking it was an extra, or loose peice... xD So I re-cut another piece of Neoprene from my NH-L9i's packaging and I wedged it back into place where Josh mentioned in his video. It sits in-between the GPU's 6-pin power adapter and the inner chassis frame, pushing the GPU IN towards the case/SSD bracket, so it's level with the case, and prevents the 1080's larger GPU fan from impacting or grazing the inner chassis front panel.
 

Spoiler

Here's what this perfectly functional peice of Neoprene looked like in it's mounting position (courtesy of Josh's 1080 video):
33117740401_69b03cd7ba_h.jpg33246221295_5fae89ecbf_h.jpg

So the case was able to sit sideways without the GPU fan impacting the edge of the front panel's GPU hole:
32705620930_b0f1a06d1d_k.jpg

Notice how TINY my space between the fan and the front panel's GPU hole, about 2mm! this is more than enough room for other 1080 mini's:
32960867481_c6d7afdc03_k.jpg

SUCESS, I DID IT! I was able to fit a 15mm SSD in the SSD bracket of the S4 mini, with a GTX 1080 mini all squeezed together. You're probably wondering why I didn't just remove the backplate on the 1080 so I wouldn't have to use Neoprene at all... Well, the backplate created a nice airgap for venting hot air on the back of the GPU between the 1080mini and the SSD bracket mounted HDDs, and because of that the backplate also kept the HDD's cool, and protected from getting cooked by the 1080mini's load temps at the low/mid 70c range. The HDDs only ever reached a maximum temp of 43c when the 1080 was humming away at 75c at it hottest, after hours of gaming.
 
You can further see the fitment of the SSD bracket on the backplate of the card here, notice how the SSD bracket is kind of bent outwards towards the side-panel from the HDD's flush fitment against the 1080's backplate:
32705620560_aae9343d0a_k.jpg

Another fitment note, remember to make sure the HDPLEX cable's clips are pushed down properly, as they could interfere with side-panel fitment if they aren't all set in place (for example, notice my 24-pin power clip is pushed UP here, where the rest are pushed down):
32242116184_2d9c3d4906_k.jpg

Time to cover the pins on the S4 MINI's PCiEx riser, with some Gaffer's Tape, Looks much better! :
32960867141_e0de800356_k.jpg33045882966_c67cb0798e_k.jpg

 

So my fitment was complete! The only sacrifice I had to make was a peice of Neoprene to push the 1080 mini IN towards the case's SSD bracket, so it wouldn't graze the inner chassis when the case was laying horizontally.

My next post will detail the Final Build pics of the S4-mini build once all was in place and working. :) 

2006-2016 PC: CM-Stacker 830v1, ASUS Crosshairv1, Phenom2 x4-940BE, Zalman CNPS-9700, 2x4GB DDR2-800, ASUS GTX-770-DCU2-OC, EVGA-G2 750W.
2017 PC: NFC S4 Mini #193: ASUS z270i STRIX, i7-7700K, Thermolab LP53 & NF-A9x14-PWM, 2x8GB DDR4-4000, ZOTAC GTX-1080 Mini, HDPLEX-300 DC-DC & Dell 330W AC-DC Power Brick PC-PartPicker
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Link to post
Share on other sites

Final Pics: Final S4-Mini Build Pics

So after it was all said and done and I was able to cram everything I wanted into a tiny 4.4L S4-Mini Chassis... I present to you, S4-Mini #193! Codenamed, "Ant-Man"!

Spoiler

 


PC Off, On, & On in the Dark:
32242117474_a876a63957_k.jpg33045883176_f8eb67eb3d_k.jpg32960867611_cae4d0131f_k.jpg

32705622030_d3ae4197f9_k.jpg32242116784_e9947c3f51_k.jpg32705621270_f38d6715ba_k.jpg

Here's what the build looked like from both sides:
33045886556_8b3f9b18db_k.jpg32960868071_aa4afa9fb2_k.jpg

Truly, portable!
33045885356_4a7e6caa44_k.jpg

 

 

Remember that the RGB on the ASUS Motherboard can be controlled, tweaked and even turned OFF completely, great for movie nights when the LEDs can be a distraction.

 

My next post will be an alternate CPU HSF Temp Test [Pre-Delid, PART1] of the: Zalman CNPS2X w/ Scythe 12x120 & Rosewill 15x120mm vs Noctua NH-L9i w/ NF-a9x14PWM & NF-B9 Redux PWM...:)

2006-2016 PC: CM-Stacker 830v1, ASUS Crosshairv1, Phenom2 x4-940BE, Zalman CNPS-9700, 2x4GB DDR2-800, ASUS GTX-770-DCU2-OC, EVGA-G2 750W.
2017 PC: NFC S4 Mini #193: ASUS z270i STRIX, i7-7700K, Thermolab LP53 & NF-A9x14-PWM, 2x8GB DDR4-4000, ZOTAC GTX-1080 Mini, HDPLEX-300 DC-DC & Dell 330W AC-DC Power Brick PC-PartPicker
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Link to post
Share on other sites

Wall of text ahead!  Pictures included sparingly to ease the reading.

 

CPU Alt. HSF Temp Testing [Pre-Delid, PART1] (Zalman CNPS2X w/ Scythe 12x120 & Rosewill 15x120mm vs Noctua NH-L9i w/ NF-a9x14PWM & NF-B9 Redux PWM)

Storytime: Okay, my Noctua NF-B9 Redux 1600 PWM came in & now that I had the NF-B9 I decided to test a combo of 4 cooling solutions...I tested the NH-L9i stock, with the NF-B9 fan against the Zalman CNPS2X w/Scythe's 12x120mm slim fan and with Rosewill's 15x120mm fan.
 

Here's the Scythe and the Rosewill installed in the 120mm fan bracket included with the S4 Mini, with the Zalman CNPS2X below them:

Spoiler

 

32300090693_e4ab8ff420_m.jpg32959288492_ddfa46d11e_m.jpg
Ease of installation VS  CNPS2X Note: The NH-L9i was way easier to install, the CNPS2X had this great backplate that is highly compatible, but was a pain to line up properly with the motherboard holes to get it to mount correctly. I had to fiddle so much with the backplate trying to fit it properly to the back of the mobo even though it DID fit and did not bulge the S4's side panel. But here's the most annoying and time consuming part (after you go through and build the HSF/backplate using the instructions): after applying the Thermal Grease (NT-H1), placing the actual CNPS2X HSF onto the CPU... the real pain in the neck was trying to align the HSF mounting holes to the mobo and screw together the HSF with the backplate ALL WHILE holding the backplate up against the mobo simultaneously, as it wanted to pull away from the mobo's backside unless you held it in place before mounting the HSF to  it. >_> The NH-L9i has the CNPS2X beat in the ease-of-installation department, hands down, by a landslide.
32733163210_413b607b8e_m.jpg32988874541_931e824da5_m.jpg32959296142_6dac13e0f8_m.jpg
32300088143_e9145ff8aa_m.jpg32300086373_f9ae09669d_m.jpg

After all that mounting ordeal, and after testing... I think I came to an already known conclusion with the temps, results were similar to Josh's results in his Mini-ITX cooler video.

 

 

Fitting the NF-B9 Redux in the S4-Mini Chassis:

 

Okay so I went to work on the NF-B9 because I didn't' want to give up on it just yet! And I found some household items to help!

So here's my Nf-B9 Redux Fitment project detailed below:

Spoiler

 

After the NF-B9 came in and I test fitted it I had bad news...
33115581505_5b9a7da995_m.jpg
Sadly it didn't come with the proper mounting screws for the NH-L9i, but I used the alternate set of 25mm-fan compatible screw that came with the NH-L9i and it mounted just fine.
32959306352_620e2f0ccd_m.jpg33074105766_c4756d2d3d_m.jpg
ONE HUGE PROBLEM THOUGH: The 25mm-fan compatible NH-L9i screws you have to use to mount it, have bulgy heads and push the S4-mini's side panel out and leaves a clearly visible bulge on the side panel that I personally was NOT confortable having on a permanent basis.
33115569245_baea08cbf4_m.jpg33115571615_77b07403f6_m.jpg

We'd need to countersink/file down the bulgy heads of the screws and drill a little into the NF-B9's screw holes to make them sit flush. Without screws though, the NF-B9 seems to sit nice and flush and squeezes up against the S4 mini's side panel, leaving no side panel bulge, BUT... I don't think this is ideal though since you'd normally want at least 1 or 2mm of room between the fan and the side panel to mitigate turbulence, and properly deliver airflow to the fan, correct?

I filed down the 25mm mounting screw heads with a little kitchen knife sharpener/file thingy, then I bored out the mounting holes on the top of the NF-B9 with an electric drill slowly until the new flatter screws could just barely sit flush with the top of the fan surface.
32300083443_9e038af27d_m.jpg32300080363_f726de6802_m.jpg32959285982_127a2ae3e9_m.jpg
And it worked, they were flush!! I DID IT!
32300078813_665c0b2e93_m.jpg
32300074713_3ddacd393d_m.jpg
It fit inside the S4 mini... but with ZERO space between the side panel and the fan itself since it was all flush now without that bulge from before, it looked way better than the stock NH-L9i fan, YAY!!!...
32733138900_a62dd127e3_m.jpg
BUT...after testing it this time with a flush panel the temps actually went up by 4-5 degrees from 52/53c idle to 57/58c idle... DANG IT!!! I think the NF-B9 (or any cpu case-fan for that matter) needs some space between it and the side panel to function optimally... so i took off the side panel and literally in a matter of 3-5 minutes the temps DROPPED down to 50/51c idle!!! Which is actually inline with the performance of the NH-L9i's stock fan (with the side panel ON)
32300070463_de01e2d832_m.jpg
So while I had the side panel off still, I powered down and swapped out the NF-B9 with the stock NH-L9i beige fan and my temps went down AGAIN to 46/47c! :D (and i verified my thermal NT-H1 applications on all tests)...
33115560425_3a131e6a9a_m.jpg32959282972_1cc3dd7b7c_m.jpg

So according to my testing...the NF-B9 is sadly 4c hotter than the stock NH-L9i fan overall. :( So after all that I put my side panel back on and my idle temps were back to the 50/51c i noted above with the stock beige fan. OH ALSO, if i drop my 4.8GHz OC and go back to the 4.2GHz stock and set my BIOS to auto with Speedstep enabled (so the chip will Turboboost itself to 4.5 when it can) its stock vcore is 1.22v and it sits turbo'ed at 4.5 all the time and the temps drop to 46/47C with the side panel ON. :D So that's a nice temp for you guys out there looking to plop a i7-7700K/NH-L9i/HDPLEX-300 into an S4 mini, without delidding. ;)

NF-B9 Final Thoughts:
Oh well, so all in all the NF-B9 was a BUST even though it's stylish and I tried my best to get it to fit as an alt to that stock/ugly beige fan of the NH-L9i. I'm a temp whore soooo... yeah, I'll live with the ugly beige fan sitting on my Noctua NH-L9i, peeking through the holes of my side-panel, in the name of LOW IDLE TEMPS! :D AND IF ANYONE KNOWS OF A BETTER PERFORMING HEATSINK FOR AN S4-MINI that can mount the beige NH-L9i fan or any other 90/92mm fan, please... speak up! I'd like to have the best one to have all my idle and load temps as low as possible, because Once I pop out my 7700k and delid it next Wednesday with CLU, there's no turning back to get pre-delid temp readings for science/for others' consideration. :)

 

 

 

Temp/Sound Testing Methodology, Results, and Part 1 Conclusion:
Temp Test Methodology:

Spoiler

 

All done in a room at 72f/22c ambient. I tested the following configs last night WITH MY S4 mini IN THE VERTICAL POSITION, with the S4 standing on it's non-vented side (just like Josh had it setup during his last 2 temp tests @ 4m:19s into his Mini-ITX Cooler Video here). ALL TESTS WERE DONE WITH the 7700K @ 4.8GHz stable at 1.25 vcore, with XMP on (2x8GB DDR4-4000), Speedstep/CPU C-states/Asus Core Enhancement OFF & LLC at Level 4. Fan curves were all using the ASUS' "Q-fan" PWM adjustment tool in the UEFI bios with fan curve preset of "Turbo" (which is a touch more aggressive than "default/standard") and leans more towards a ~20% stronger/louder fan curve than default).

Sound Level Methodology: I just sat the S4 mini 2 feet away from me at eye level on my desk, in a quiet home with ceiling/tower fans and Central A/C turned off for the quietest "i can hear a pin drop" setting.

Neat Discovery: Cool thing I found in the ASUS z270i's manual is that both the CPU_FAN/CHA_FAN's fan curves are tweak-able and controllable inside the UEFI bios! :D (it doesn't seem like the "AIO_PUMP_FAN" header has as much fan curve tweaking available in the UEFI as the other two headers)

 

 

Results: (listed in order of loudest to most quiet)
 

Spoiler

 

[Quietness(lol) 1.0-5.0 "loudest-to-quietest"]-(hottest core temp "usually core #3" @ idle/desktop) - Fan config
[1.0]-(58c)-Noctua NH-L9i with ONLY a Scythe 12x120mm PWM in the 120mm bracket plugged into CPU-Fan header (for fun)
[1.5]-(49c)-Zalman CNPS2X w/Scythe 12x120mm PWM in the 120mm bracket plugged into the CHASSIS-FAN header
[2.0]-(49/50c)-Zalman CNPS2X w/Rosewill 15x120 PWM in the 120mm bracket plugged into the CHASSIS-FAN header
[4.5]-(50/51c)-Noctua NH-L9i with stock fan
[5.0]-(52/53c)-Noctua NH-L9i with NF-B9 Redux 1600-PWM (looks great but by default. screws don't sit flush w/case & side panel has bulge)

S4 Mini CPS2X & NF-B9 Temp Test Conclusion: So both at idle AND under a custom x264 load test, the Zalman CNPS2X & Scythe 12x120PWM/Rosewill 15x120PWM beat out the NH-L9i by 1-2 degrees INSIDE the S4-mini, which is nice (and we already knew that thanks to Josh's video, lol) ... BUT Sadly those 2 120mm slim fans were WAY louder than the Noctua w/it's stock fan, and the Noctua with the NF-B9 1600PWM was even quieter than the NH-L9i w/it's fan, at the cost of a minor temp increase (and it's mounting screws leaving a bulge in the side panel since it barely fit). The Scythe 12x120PWM is the one that is SUPER LOUD when it spins up, and it would be audibly/loudly spinning up just by opening up chrome or desktop apps, before I even loaded up a game. :( the Rosewill would spin up as often as the Scythe but its noise level was a little better.

So which setup will I stick with? Which do I recommend?? That's a tough question. If I gamed with headphones or in a louder environment and didn't mind the fan noise, I'd stick with the CNPS2X and the Rosewill 15x120mm. But since my S4 will be sitting 2-3 feet from me at eye level I need it to be as QUIET AS POSSIBLE when web browsing, running light desktop apps, or watching media. At full LOAD in a game, the NH-L9i setups were comparably about as loud as the CNPS2X combos were was at idle at the desktop... So ideally I'd LIKE to have the NH-L9i for my particular use case. And although i would PREFER the GREY color of the NF-B9 redux's 25x92mm fan since it blends in with the S4 mini and it seemed to run the quietest... it sadly wont fit without modding of the mounting screws and screw holes (kinda like the flush-mounted countersunk screws on the S4 mini's chassis).

 

 

Sneak Peek at PART 2 of my upcoming Temp Testing Post: I will include the Thermolabs/Cooltech LP53 HSF, and ALL-COPPER HSF, and pit it against the NH-L9i! I will be using the stock NF-A9x14-PWM fan from the Noctua NH-L9i, and as a thread on [H]ardOCP has noted... with this HSF configuration, the LP53 is between 8-10c COOLER than the NH-L9i!

  • Could I get the LP53 to fit inside my S4 mini?
  • Will it fit on my z270i STRIX mobo, w/proper heatpipe/fin orientation? (fins parallel to RAM)
  • Will it outperform the NH-L9i, inside the S4-Mini, and with the S4-mini's side-panel closed?

If you're excited to find out,Stay tuned!

2006-2016 PC: CM-Stacker 830v1, ASUS Crosshairv1, Phenom2 x4-940BE, Zalman CNPS-9700, 2x4GB DDR2-800, ASUS GTX-770-DCU2-OC, EVGA-G2 750W.
2017 PC: NFC S4 Mini #193: ASUS z270i STRIX, i7-7700K, Thermolab LP53 & NF-A9x14-PWM, 2x8GB DDR4-4000, ZOTAC GTX-1080 Mini, HDPLEX-300 DC-DC & Dell 330W AC-DC Power Brick PC-PartPicker
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Link to post
Share on other sites

So at this point I was still waiting and hadn't yet received my Thermolab LP53 CPU cooler yet... but in the meantime  did 4 things to my S4 build:

 

1. I installed a dual USB 3.0 Internal header adapter and used some creative cabling and empty space inside the S4 to plug in some wireless USB adapters to minimize exterior USB plug use.

2. I was able to fit the z270i STRIX's wifi antenna inside the S4 Mini, while allowing the antenna wires to be plugged in to the rear I/O plugs. (no pics of that, but I fished the wires from the gap between the rear I/O and the interior of the case) I was able to fit the wifi adapter next to the CPU 8-pin power plug on the botherboard, where there was some empty space.

3. I swapped my boot drive (the intel 600p M.2 250GB SSD) from the top M.2 port to the rear M.2 port, I was able to install it into the rear M.2 WITHOUT having to remove the motherboard from the S4-mini! :D

4. Oh and I also received my order of 3/4 inch soft Sorbothane Rubber feet so I could sit my S4 Mini horizontally! with pics!

Spoiler

 

Here's the dual-USB 3.0 header, for my Steam Controller wifi adapter and for my future Logitech wireless keyboard adapter. I wanted these two adapters to use the internal USB header ports to minimize having to worry about plugging and unplugging them when travelling. (which I do with this S4 mini every day to work) :)
33003987860_d1e7438880_k.jpg

Here's the moved M.2 port, it was awesome not having to remove the motherboard, i just slid it in and screwed it down! :D
33387063105_3f8c25eafd_k.jpg

Here's my 1/2 inch squishy Sorbothane rubber feet! They kinda squished down from the weight of the S4 because they are squishy, I REALLY wish they were a hard and didn't get squished down, so the S4 could float a little higher than that.
32544127324_a5da2e5405_k.jpg32544141074_a8d0ab292d_k.jpg33387058375_d5aa9bbd2e_k.jpg

32572771093_cedd9c1ab0_k.jpg33231292812_7ccf0c3f34_k.jpg33387051545_2887b589d8_k.jpg

Here's 2 pics of the case and how the Acrylics catches the RGB lighting of the z270i (sorry for iPhone 6 quality pics):
33346233706_7f3f812419_k.jpg32572721033_ee26dcea2b_k.jpg

 

and now for the main event of this post:

CPU Temp Testing [Pre-Delid, PART2] (Thermolabs/Cooltech LP53 vs NH-L9i):

My Thermolab LP53 came in yesterday afternoon,  Pics:
 

Spoiler

32904278103_94cabfe59c_k.jpg33588568261_120a7ad671_k.jpg33676941706_8581100e35_k.jpg33588568441_f6cd3a0035_k.jpg33717615645_44145e508a_k.jpg33561486292_0bf0eeb1ab_k.jpg33717615415_c0fc1f0250_k.jpg
33717615525_7d5de25bcc_k.jpg



And I started work on temp benchmarking my current NHL9i this afternoon...

Here's a preview of what I tested with my NT-H1 thermal compound on my 7700K at 4.5GHz turboboost @ stock vcore 1.24v:

  • IDLE temp
  • LOAD temp (after 10 minutes) or LOAD temp once I hit 99c/thermal throttle with a time-stamp
  • AMBIENT temp.


I'll be testing the following software:

  • Prime95 26.6 (custom, run FFTs in place, & max FFT size of 8kb)
  • ASUS ROG Realbench v2.43 Stresstest (set to use 8GB of RAM)
  • a custom x264 load/stability test, on all 8 threads (custom test from the Overclockers.net Kaby Lake OC'ing thread)


I'm testing both coolers with the fins parallel to the RAM in the following configurations (with the S4 Mini side panels CLOSED):

  • NHL9i +NF-A9x14 - STOCK (with motherboard VRM heatsinks ON)
  • NHL9i +NF-A9x14 - without mobo VRM heatsinks
  • LP53 +NF-A9x14 - without mobo VRM heatsinks


Right now, as I've just completed the benchmarks and am typing up the results.... the results are IMPRESSIVE. 1st, after removing the VRM heatsinks, I came across a decent temp drop that I will share in the results. 2nd The LP53, it WAS INDEED worth the 1 month wait after purchase to arrive, for sure, it has replaced my NHL9i going forward into my delid to occur next. :D

 

NHL9i vs LP53 S4 Mini RESULTS (AMBIENT TEMP was 74F or 23C at all times):

Prime95_v26.6____IDLE__________LOAD
NHL9i Stock______39c_________99c@5min
NHL9i no VRMs___39c____________97c
LP53 no VRMs____36c____________92c

Realbench Stress__IDLE__________LOAD
NHL9i Stock______39c_________99c@2min
NHL9i no VRMs___39c____________94c
LP53 no VRMs____36c____________90c

x264 Custom Load_IDLE__________LOAD
NHL9i Stock______39c__________99c @ 2min
NHL9i no VRMs___39c________(94c@2min) 97c
LP53 no VRMs____36c________(92c@2min) 95c

 

RESULTS ANALYSIS:
Removing the VRM heatsinks gave me anywhere from a 2-4c improvement in load temps when using the NHL9i. this also allowed my load temps not to fail before the 10 minutes, where they were hitting 99c otherwise. :D
The LP53 beat the NHL9i in the same configuration without the VRM heatsinks, it dropped my idle temps by 3c, and my load temps dropped between 2-5c.

 

So here's the kicker! I went from... using the NHL9i with the VRM heatsinks (which I was using all this time), to the LP53 without the VRM heatstinks. This resulted in my CPU no longer throttling and failing my load tests, while dropping my load temps from reaching 99c in 2 & 5 minutes, to maintaining my load temps at a steady 90/92c after the full 10 minutes! That's an average of -9c on my load temps! on air! inside the S4 mini! :D:D:D

 

Pics and LP53 fitment story "1 Small compromise, for a no-compromise All-copper CPU cooling solution!" :

Spoiler

 


First step was removing the VRM heatsinks after I tested the NHL9i with them ON... the 2 screws for one of the VRM heatsinks was easy to access from the bottom of the mobo, the other two were hidden behind the S4 mini sidepanel, requiring I pull out the HDPLEX, disconnect SATA from the mobo, disconnect my PCI-Ex riser, to slide the mobo over to access the other two screws:

Screws:
33601884661_fc2a674932_k.jpg33601877231_dd85053e6c_k.jpg

how much I had to slide over the motherboard to reach the last 2 screws:
33601879601_90a1ebf6d3_k.jpg

VRMs off with my screw pointing at the VRMs (little black squares)
33346213720_ef7df54906_k.jpg33346208020_1786aae42a_k.jpg

VRM heatsinks off (I'll have mini heatsinks coming this Friday for all the exposed MOSFETS/VRMs, will install with Pics at that time)
32917496183_1f303755a3_k.jpg33601879601_90a1ebf6d3_k.jpg

My thermal paste application of NTH1 had great coverage (amount was the size of 1 uncooked rice grain):
32917490583_c84591087c_k.jpg

LP53's ALL COPPER mounting plate/surface and fins :cool::
33730733755_59dcb5a6f4_k.jpg

LP53 vs NHL9i + NF-A9x14 size comparison NOTE, the LP53 actually overhangs the mounting screws more on the pointy end of the heatpipes, as the LP53 is offset a bit, so that the bent ends of the heatpipes actually protrude LESS than the other end:
33730730475_578cd02e2c_k.jpg33690063586_4529cf9196_k.jpg33690062496_3d8f64213e_k.jpg33690061406_36680f7b63_k.jpg

Top: NHL9i mounting hardware, bottom: LP523 mounting hardware... truly amazing how minimalistic it is!
33601852431_6d01eeda29_k.jpg

CPU cleaned and ready for LP53 mounting fitments tests:
33574492882_ac6bba9870_k.jpg

LP53 mounting tests, without having to remove anything (and I even refitted the VRM heatsinks just to verify, although not pictured) you dont have to remove RAM or VRM heatsinks to fit the LP53 with the heatpipes over the M.2 slot, BUT this sadly forces the Heatsink's fins to be perpendicular to the RAM, limiting cooling potential:
32888165454_d14c010a1a_k.jpg

But with the fins parallel to the RAM, the LP53 protrudes OVER the first RAM slot on my ASUS STRIX z270i motherboard. Forcing me to pray that it will fit with the heatpipe bends facing the RAM instead, so I don't have to sacrifice RAM...
32917474403_d2b18c6bd0_k.jpg

Here you can see that the LP53 is offset from the motherboard mounting holes by quite a bit when pushed up against the first RAM stick, if trying to fit it with the fins parallel to the RAM...
33574488152_324a63747e_k.jpg

AAAAND! IT FITS! But see if you spot the small sacrifice I made:
33601854771_bedcb59478_k.jpg

I removed the first RAM slots outer heatspreader, as it was BARELY making contact with the LP53's heatpipe bends... and I was NOT comfortable with that. So you may not even have to do this, if you don't mind the heatpipes touching your RAM. :)
33601857151_5c27001220_k.jpg33601859401_e3aeb6aeff_k.jpg

So now comes the hard part, figuring out how to mount the NHL9i's fan onto the LP53!

I used black & thin plastic zip ties, I looped them over the pointy ends of the heatpipes snugly, but I had to loop them under the start of the bendy end of the other side of the heatpipe. The first pic is showing how much I had to slowly, notch by notch, tighten and refit the the zip-ties until they kept the fan SNUG against the LP53:
33346180080_f0c3d9b704_k.jpg

PROTIP: do the pointy ends first, at they can be lifted off and retightened easily, once you do the bendy ends, you cant move the fan off the heatsink to have enough room to loop the remaining zip-ties easily:
[33574472412_7a06052705_k.jpg33690045756_571f8924ca_k.jpg

Then just cut your ends off:
32917465463_a8cc00f5cb_k.jpg

Reinstall the side panel, and you'll have 5mm of space between the fan and the side panel, where the NHL9i had 9.5mm of space. Your fan might have a slightly more pronounces WOOSH sound, or hum at higher loads, but its not very noticeable to me. My S4 sits 3 feet away at ear level on my desk in a quiet room. :)
33574470692_9f6e73138d_k.jpg32888153214_3f601500dc_k.jpg

 

 

So my next post in this Build Log thread will be:

STAGE 3: CPU Temp Testing of the Termolabs/Cooltech LP53 on an i7-7700k (Pre-delid vs Post-Delid Temps)  Where I will be testing compiling and comparing temp numbers from all my previous configurations: NHL9i vs NHL9i* vs LP53* vs LP53 w/i7-7700k Delidded* - RESULTS! [*means my Z270i's VRM heatsinks were removed] (+a bonus alternate "mini" VRM heatsinks installation!)

 

Also, any feedback or questions, feel free to share them. :)

2006-2016 PC: CM-Stacker 830v1, ASUS Crosshairv1, Phenom2 x4-940BE, Zalman CNPS-9700, 2x4GB DDR2-800, ASUS GTX-770-DCU2-OC, EVGA-G2 750W.
2017 PC: NFC S4 Mini #193: ASUS z270i STRIX, i7-7700K, Thermolab LP53 & NF-A9x14-PWM, 2x8GB DDR4-4000, ZOTAC GTX-1080 Mini, HDPLEX-300 DC-DC & Dell 330W AC-DC Power Brick PC-PartPicker
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Link to post
Share on other sites

STAGE 3: CPU Temp Testing [Post-Delid] (Termolabs/Cooltech LP53 vs Delidded Temps) 

NHL9i vs NHL9i* vs LP53* vs LP53 w/i7-7700k Delidded* - RESULTS! (+bonus alternate "mini" VRM heatsinks installed!)
[/B]
PICS of the Delid process adventure, skip these and look at the results below if you like :) (theres a bonus video in there showing the ACTUAL delid moment, too!)

Spoiler

 

Getting ready to delid, got all my tools out.
33741562866_5253a908a0_k.jpg33741567646_11aa5be8f7_k.jpg33782467625_ed90bdab24_k.jpg33741568076_2d9418356b_k.jpg

Removing the 7700k revealed my LP53's mounting to the A9x14 PWM fan was on point:
32939400914_649e0f0329_k.jpg33782464845_d5c38b64e1_k.jpg

Also my NT-H1 application was on point:
33625939992_d3d851a294_k.jpg

Video of the Delid itself (the IHS pop was not super loud and was not bad at all!):
32939394224_83a605e4f7_b.jpg

Here's my verification pic for the overclockers.net forums delidded club:
33741569486_fcebda0c77_k.jpg

The bare CPU PCB/Die and the back of the IHS, note the GAP in the sealant Intel uses, i marked it with a red pen on the IHS to not lose track of it and remember to replicate it when i relid the CPU:
33782470225_a4889fe7c8_k.jpg32969526673_f1aecc95bd_k.jpg

Cleaned the integrated TIM from the CPU's die and the black sealant glue with my fingernail (perfectly safe on the CPU and I used the flat end of my old Discover card on the IHS's glue. Here's the bare CPU PCB/Die and the IHS:
33741572616_5c16aa2d8e_k.jpg32969531363_e2746b217a_k.jpg

Made sure to tape off the CPU die for applying my CLU (CoolLaboratory Liquid Ultra) I also tapped off the IHS:
33741574886_a25db561d0_k.jpg

Applying the CLU, was interesting since its got this strong surface tension, I placed a drop of it on the surface and had to spread it around with the little brushes provided with the CLU TIM until it covered the whole surface:
33397704820_c5cdcb2a67_k.jpg33741577936_e5f07f4625_k.jpg33625966702_f35b18c738_k.jpg

Both surfaces nicely covered, i used the brush to lap up any extra to make the surface as uniformly flat as possible, removing any excess CLU TIM:
33653105721_5eb2e98d26_k.jpg33625969202_f809dfd845_k.jpg

the tape surprised me and it worked prefectly once I peeled it off, any CLU that overapplied onto it, came off with the tape and it was a perfect application. And according to other's CLU application results, a good application like this, will last the life of the CPU. :)
32939426114_beb584dacf_k.jpg

Reinstalling the CPU WITHOUR SEALING THE IHS... :D I actually didn't use the black glue to relid the IHS, I just sat it perfectly ontop of the CPU once it was back in the socket and the retention bracket is holding it in place perfectly with ZERO budge, this also reduced the space between the CPU die itself and the IHS, potentially increasing cooling capacity of the relid for better heat transfer.
33741590026_3e76be55ff_k.jpg

NT-H1 applied (NOTICE ANYTHING???) I was able to reapply the Heatspreader to my RAM stick closest to the CPU socket as my LP53 wasn't pushing it aside that bad. :D:
32939439534_09fbbda8e1_k.jpg

LP53 back in. :D
33741592166_7b4f00e1c1_k.jpg

Everything back in place!
33653065461_b8271ea2f1_k.jpg

 

 

So, how did the Delid go, you may wonder? ....
 


... Well, wonder NO MORE!

PRE/POST DELID TEMP RESULTS DISCLAIMERS:
1) AMBIENT TEMP was 74F/23C at all times
2) * means my Z270i's VRM heatsinks were removed
3) Results were taken with the S4 Mini Side Panels On, in a vertical position (power button near the bottom)
4) Synthetic Benchmark temps taken after 10 minutes, or until i hit 99C (with timestamps included)
5) Gaming all done at 1080p in most CPU intensive area I could find, or using the game's built-in benchmark

Here's how I gathered my temps: My temp numbers were taken from the hottest core (core0) noting the highest temp that core had hit during the 10 minutes of continuous load from said benchmark/game. If the benchmark/game was showing erratic spiking of temps up/down within a range, I would take the average hottest temp of that range (ex: if spiking from 75-80c I'd average that to 77c).

  • averaged temps marked with a "~" RealBench, AIDA64,and Watch_Dogs 2 fluctuated within a Temp Range, and the temp noted is an average.
  • the orange temp delta shows the difference between the LP53 and the LP53 with the delid
  • the GREEN temp delta is used to show the difference between my "stock NHL9i" temps and my new "LP53 w/Delid" temps :D

Synthetic Benchmarks:
Prime95_v26.6____IDLE__________LOAD
NHL9i Stock_______39c_________99c@5min (FAIL) on core0, cores1-3 averaged 93c
NHL9i *___________39c_________97c on core0, cores1-3 averaged 91c
LP53 *____________36c_________92c on core0, cores1-3 averaged 86cc
LP53 & Delid*______35c_________79 on core0 , cores 1-3 were ALL at 77c (13c from pre-delid LP53) (-20c from "NHL9i Stock")

Realbench Stress___LOAD
NHL9i Stock_______~99c@2min (FAIL)
NHL9i *___________~94c@
LP53 *____________~90c@
LP53 & Delid*______~76c@ (-14c from pre-delid LP53) (-23c from "NHL9i Stock")

x264 Custom Load___LOAD
NHL9i Stock______99c@2min (FAIL)
NHL9i *__________97c@10min
LP53 *___________ 95c@10min
LP53 & Delid*_____ 78c@10min (-15c from pre-delid LP53) (-21c from "NHL9i Stock")

Intel Burn Test (Standard) Hottest Core after 10 runs
LP53 *___________99c@1min (FAIL)
LP53 & Delid *____75c (-24c from pre-delid LP53)

AIDA64 System Stress Test (15 minutes)
LP53 *___________~92c
LP53 & Delid *____~78c (-14c from pre-delid LP53)

Thats an average 14c temp drop (on the hottest core) from from pre-delid LP53 to Delidding, ALONE.
But let's look at where I started with the NHL9i w/VRM heatsinks on... then this becomes a total average of 20C temp drop (on the hottest core) on these synthetic benchmarks, going from an NHL9i, to an LP53 without VRM heatsinks, and then a CPU delid! :D

Gaming Benchmarks
Watch Dogs 2:
LP53 *___________~83c
LP53 & Delid *____~69c

Mirror's Edge Catalyst:
LP53 *___________77c
LP53 & Delid *____63c

Batman Arkham Knight:
LP53 *___________70c
LP53 & Delid *____57c

Gears of War 4 Benchmark:
LP53 *___________61c
LP53 & Delid *____55c

Rise of the Tomb Raider Benchmark:
LP53 *___________64c
LP53 & Delid *____59c

That's an average 13c temp drop (on the hottest core) in these Real-world PC-game tests!BONUS Pics of adjustments to the Motherboard VRMs (which were bare after removing the stock VRM heatsink towers). You can buy them here

Here's the little heatsinks I saw another user from the DanA4 Thread on [H]ardOCP use on this Z270i STRIX. I bought them and my order of 10 came in. They have a paper you peel with some black thermal glue on the back:

Spoiler

 


32969528343_616ef4a9bc_k.jpg

Bare VRMs before, after, and what  I used to apply the heatsinks:
33625972172_581ecc7c97_k.jpg32939435964_27b7af27c3_k.jpg

I used tiny pliers to apply them, then once in place i pressed them down lightly with my pinky until i noticed they were set.
33625975292_b70847255e_k.jpg32939430904_0951d9aa59_k.jpg

The heatsinks have not fallen off after 24H of use sitting in my S4 with the vertical position. :D

 

 

 

BONUS pics of adjusting my rear M.2 mounting with the proper spacer:

Spoiler

When I initially installed my boot M.2 drive on the back of my Z270i I didn't use a spacer. This had now been fixed. :D33741593416_57e5182992_k.jpg
32939445004_60861700c8_k.jpg

 

So... the delid was sucessful. I'm going to attempt to go for 5GHz now and see if I'm stable at a low enough vcore and temps. If not I'm fine with the 7700k at stock turboboost clocks (4.5GHz @ 1.2vcore)

Thanks to all of you who helped me with this build. This brings the main phase of this build's progress to an end... FOR NOW!

Things that might make me update this thread in the future:

  • A new 1080ti Mini from ZOTAC that fits in the S4 mini ...? (praying for one at least, if not for me but so Josh can get more customers! and more can join the SFF or S4 Mini community!) xD
  • The release of PC 4K/UHD Bluray PC Players, so I can drag all my 4K blurays that havent been ripped yet along with me when i take it with me for movie nights.


This post took me WAY TOO LONG to do, so glad my long-format updates are over for this build...

... and now that the latest version of CEMU is relased, I'm off to play Zelda Breath of the Wild in Glorius 4K! and then take the S4 to a friends house for some Mario Kart 8 4-player couch-multiplayer in Glorious 4K on his projector! :)

2006-2016 PC: CM-Stacker 830v1, ASUS Crosshairv1, Phenom2 x4-940BE, Zalman CNPS-9700, 2x4GB DDR2-800, ASUS GTX-770-DCU2-OC, EVGA-G2 750W.
2017 PC: NFC S4 Mini #193: ASUS z270i STRIX, i7-7700K, Thermolab LP53 & NF-A9x14-PWM, 2x8GB DDR4-4000, ZOTAC GTX-1080 Mini, HDPLEX-300 DC-DC & Dell 330W AC-DC Power Brick PC-PartPicker
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Link to post
Share on other sites

A GTX 1080 Mini in something smaller than a shoebox?

This chassis and build is amazing.   The Genie says it best ...   

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

×