Jump to content
Search In
  • More options...
Find results that contain...
Find results in...
Sign in to follow this  
  • entry
    1
  • comments
    4
  • views
    442

Why you might consider the new P600S over the Define R and S Series

TVwazhere

1,949 views

UPDATE: 4/30/19

Credits to @Firewrath9 for suggestions are corrections.

 

I was gonna do a status update but this started getting sorta long, so...

 

After watching Paul's review of the case which went into much more detail than other reviews I've seen so far, I drew a strikingly large amount of similarities between this and the Define R6/S2 cases from Fractal (some of my personal favorite cases) with some notable differences. The P600S is basically the Evolv X with (different (IMO better) exterior paneling. Some stats were taken from the Evolv X spec page since the P600S doesnt have an official one yet.

 

 

Case Comparison
Feature Define R6 Define S2  Eclipse P600S Notes
MSRP $150 $150 $150 Price in USD
Motherboard Max Size E-ATX E-ATX E-ATX

Note that EATX motherboard support is 285mm long for the R6/S2 and

280mm long for the P600S

360mm rad support Y(F,T) Y(F,T) Y(F,T)

F is Front, T is Top

175/NAmm (F,T) clearance for R6/S2

90/65mm (F,T) Clearance for P600S

420mm rad support Y(T) Y(T) Y(F)

F is Front, T is Top

Same clearances as 120mm

140mm Rad Top Mount

Motherboard/RAM Module Clearance

35mm 35mm 50mm Max Height of RAM/Mobo heatsinks
before interference with Top RAD occurs
Foam for Silence Y Y Y  
Side ventilation For airflow Y Y Y  
Front Openable for Best airflow Y N Y  
3.5" HDD Support 6 (up to 11)  [2] 3 4 (10) (#) is max possible config,
[R6 Open Layout max is 2]
Dedicated SSD Support 2 (4) 2 (4) 3 (#) is max possible config
Type A ports (3.0), (2.0) 2, 2 2, 2 2, 0  
3.1 gen 2 Type C Y* Y Y *Define R6 series with specific SKU or addon
Black, Gray, White Color Options Y Y Y  
5.25" Legacy Bay Y N N  
Hinged  Side Doors N N Y  
Fan Hub Incuded Y Y Y  
Top panel Removable for Airflow Y Y Y  
Vertical GPU Bracket Included N N Y  
Vertical GPU Cable Included N N N  
GPU Anti-Sag Bracket Included N N Y* *Mounts in rear PCI-E tabs
mITX dual config support N N Y* *Not included by default
Custom Watercool Fill Port Y Y Y Located on top radiator bracket,
removable
Custom Watercool Drain Port N N Y* *Access requires front panel removed
Good cable management Y Y Y  
PSU bracket for easy install Y Y Y  
Full length dust filter (front access) Y Y N  
PSU Showoff Cutout N N Y Subjective Aesthetic
Dedicated Reservoir mount N Y N  
Optional Pump Mount Y Y Y  
140mm Fans Included 3 3 3  
Top Panel Air Cover  Y Y Y For unused air fan/RAD locations

 

I could have easily gone in further like how both fan controllers can do 4 PWM and 3 DC voltage control, but at this point it's pretty clear that the cases trade blow for blow upon many of the categories. Many of the included accessories were welcome including the included Vertical GPU bracket (I'm not sure if only first party cables will work with this though) and Anti Sag Bracket. We have to praise Phanteks here from learning from their past mistake of making too much of the $200+ case "DLC" (Not including SSD trays? Vert GPU Bracket?)

 

RGB Not included. Not Sorry.



4 Comments


Recommended Comments

Define S2 is 130$, and always (all skus) have USB C, R6 is specific skus.

and theres more space for from rad than P600S (100+ vs 90ish)

also all them are fake EATX, (280mm vs 330mm)

Share this comment


Link to comment
8 minutes ago, Firewrath9 said:

Define S2 is 130$, and always (all skus) have USB C, R6 is specific skus.

and theres more space for from rad than P600S (100+ vs 90ish)

Shoulda Specified R6 was the one with different USB-C SKU's. I'll update that. 

 

I left it at MSRP, because prices will change (and might ultimately be a leading factor into which someone should buy at any given money) seeing as how non USB-C SKU's go as low as $105 at times

 

Where did you find max RAD+fan dimensions? Are these official dim's or just hand made measurements?

Share this comment


Link to comment
On 4/25/2019 at 5:08 PM, Firewrath9 said:

Phanteks has it on their site, 95mm front, 65mm top, and 280mm "EATX")

-snip-

thats 170mm front space for S2/R6 (ripped it off this review https://www.overclock3d.net/reviews/cases_cooling/fractal_define_r6_review/6)

and it has 285mm EATX.

also, I think you should specify where 420 and 360 rad support is i.e.

360mm rad support T/F T/F T/F  
420mm rad support T T

F
 

The 360 and 420 support Top/Front is listed in the notes, but your method is clearer. I'll update these with the notes and the "2019 E-ATX" size notes. I dont think I've seen any E-ATX cases released in the last few years that are true 12x13" boards. 

Share this comment


Link to comment

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×